The Senate is about to pass one of the biggest rewrites of American building rules in half a century, and it is doing so at a sprint. The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a 494-page bill known around the Capitol by its clumsy acronym BAAJA, cleared its last major procedural hurdle on Wednesday by a vote of 65 to 31. Senators also approved another manager's amendment, 69 to 27, that had been released only the night before. A final passage vote is expected as early as Friday, just ahead of the Thanksgiving recess.
On paper, this is a rare bipartisan triumph in a Congress that has struggled to agree on much of anything. The bill was negotiated behind closed doors by senators from both parties together with the Trump administration. It is backed by renewable power developers and fossil fuel producers, by manufacturers, chemical companies and major labor unions. Its champions say it will help the country build the power lines, power plants, pipelines and mines it needs as data centers for artificial intelligence push electricity demand sharply higher.
But look closely at the vote counts and a second story appears. Support is slipping, not growing. A procedural vote early last week passed 73 to 25. Monday's vote to end debate passed 70 to 27. Wednesday's dropped to 65 to 31. And the coalition forming against the bill is one of the strangest in recent Washington memory: tribal nations, environmental groups, a populist Republican from Missouri, a South Dakota Republican worried about his state's utility regulators, and the two Democratic senators from Washington state.
What the bill actually does
The core promise is speed. Developers have complained for decades that environmental reviews and lawsuits can stretch a project's timeline for years before a shovel touches the ground. The bill attacks that problem on several fronts at once, touching four landmark laws: the National Environmental Policy Act, the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act and the National Historic Preservation Act.
Under the bill, lawsuits challenging a project would have to be filed within 150 days of its approval, and only people who took part in the formal public comment period could sue. Environmental reviews would only have to weigh alternatives that meet the goal of the company sponsoring the project. Certain activities, including expansions of natural gas pipelines, would be exempted from environmental review altogether.
Transmission lines are the heart of the deal for many Democrats. The bill would let federal regulators approve interstate power lines when states fail to act on them, and it directs the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to set timelines for utilities to upgrade existing lines and adopt advanced technologies when the benefits outweigh the costs. Supporters argue that this could cut the time it takes to build a major new line from a decade or more to five or six years. That matters most for wind and solar farms, which are often built far from the cities that need their power and sit in long queues waiting for a connection to the grid.
There is something in the bill for both parties' energy wish lists. It would make it harder for any president to yank permits that have already been granted. That cuts against President Trump's efforts to block wind projects that were already approved, and equally against moves like a Democratic president's revocation of approval for the Keystone XL oil pipeline. Developers could also sue the government if they can show a pattern of unequal treatment of particular energy sources. And in a nod to the affordability politics that dominated the midterm elections, large data centers would be required to pay for the extra costs their heavy electricity demand imposes on the grid, rather than passing them on to households. One energy research firm has estimated that the package would lower household electricity bills by 2040 by getting cheaper power onto the grid and shielding ordinary customers from data center costs.
Senate Majority Whip John Barrasso of Wyoming has framed the bill in the simplest terms. "They will make it easier to build energy projects: pipelines, coal mines, and power plants," he said on the Senate floor this week. "We are not dictating what gets built. We are simply protecting the ability to build."
Senator Martin Heinrich of New Mexico, the top Democrat on the Energy and Natural Resources Committee and a co-sponsor, has made the same pitch from the left, arguing in a statement that the bill "will help lower energy costs, strengthen Tribal consultation, and create more good-paying jobs."
The opposition nobody planned for
The loudest objections have come from tribal nations, and they are aimed at one part of the bill in particular: its changes to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. That provision requires federal agencies to consult with tribes, states and local governments before approving projects that could harm historic or sacred sites, and it often leads to projects being redesigned rather than blocked.
David Hill, principal chief of the Muscogee Nation, offered a concrete example in a letter to the bill's authors. A proposed cellular tower would have spoiled the view from the Kolomoki Mounds in Georgia, a site his nation's ancestors built with the surrounding landscape in mind. Through the consultation process, the agency agreed to move the tower. "Section 106 works," Hill wrote.
Tribal leaders say the bill would narrow the range of projects they can weigh in on, shorten the windows for challenging them, and limit what courts can do to stop a historic site from being destroyed. Mark Macarro, president of the National Congress of American Indians, the oldest and largest organization representing American Indian and Alaska Native nations, dismissed the revised consultation language as "box-checking." His verdict on the amendments was blunter still: "Any amendment to S. 5653 merely puts lipstick on a pig." In a letter to a major American newspaper, he wrote that the provisions "would shut tribal nations out of the rooms where decisions are made about their lands and sacred places."
In the Pacific Northwest, Leonard Forsman, chairman of the Suquamish Tribe and president of the Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians, which represents 57 tribal governments, said in an interview that some permit reform is needed, "But this isn't it: Just to give a free pass to the energy industry." He called the bill "a real disaster for cultural resource management, and for water quality and salmon, too." Melissa A. Gilman, chair of the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe, put it more starkly in a joint letter to Congress on November 8: "Our ancestral places are not renewable resources. Once destroyed, they cannot be replaced."
The bill's sponsors did respond. The substitute amendment from Senator Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia, chair of the Environment and Public Works Committee, pared back some changes, extended some deadlines, required consultation with tribal and state historic preservation officers on key reports, and allowed tribal or state agencies to serve as the lead agency on a project. Tribal leaders say none of that changes their position. Senator Adam Schiff of California has offered an amendment to strip the historic preservation title out of the bill entirely, but it is unclear whether Senate leaders will allow a vote on it.
Tribal opinion is not uniform. The bill lines up with the advocacy of the National Tribal Energy Association, which has pushed for faster federal permitting of energy development, and at least one nation, the Crow Tribe in Montana, has expressed approval.
Hawley, Rounds and the Washington state problem
On Wednesday only two Republicans voted no. Senator Mike Rounds of South Dakota has voted against the bill repeatedly, citing his state's Public Utilities Commission, which objects to provisions that would let federal regulators override state decisions on where transmission lines go. That puts Rounds at odds with his own home state colleague, Majority Leader John Thune, who has pushed hard for passage. Senator Josh Hawley of Missouri voted to begin debate on the bill earlier but has now voted against it twice in procedural votes this week.
Among Democrats, the opposition list on Wednesday ran from progressives such as Bernie Sanders and Ed Markey to swing state senators such as Jon Ossoff and Mark Kelly. Washington state's two senators, Patty Murray and Maria Cantwell, have been among the most vocal Democratic critics, echoing concerns from tribes in their state. "We all need new sources of energy and power," Cantwell said at a news conference this week. "But this bill as it's currently drafted is not the answer." She added: "I hope we can slow down, and if we can't, I hope the House stops it."
The process itself has become an argument. The bill never received a committee hearing in the Republican-controlled Senate, the usual step that invites outside testimony. Critics say a measure that rewrites four foundational environmental laws deserves regular order. Supporters reply that regular order is exactly what has failed to produce permitting reform for more than a decade.
The House is the real test
Even if the bill clears the Senate on Friday, its future is far from settled. House Democrats are split. The Congressional Progressive Caucus opposes the bill as written, while the centrist New Democrat Coalition has signaled support. Representative Jared Huffman of California, who is in line to chair the House Natural Resources Committee when Democrats take control of both chambers in January, has attacked its limits on environmental reviews, its transmission changes and its new right for companies to sue over fuel discrimination. On the Republican side, Energy and Commerce Committee Chair Brett Guthrie of Kentucky has called for changes to address grid reliability, and some House Republicans share the tribes' concerns and the states' worries about losing control over transmission siting.
That calendar is the hidden engine of this week's rush. Democrats will hold majorities in both chambers next year, which changes the bargaining power on every line of this bill. For Republicans and the administration, the lame duck session may be the best chance to lock in limits on lawsuits and reviews. For pro-building Democrats like Heinrich, it may be the last chance to secure the transmission reforms that clean energy developers have wanted for years before a new Congress reopens the whole deal. For opponents, the goal is simple: run out the clock until January.
What to watch
First, the margin on Friday. Another drop from 65 would signal that the coalition is fraying and give House skeptics cover. Second, whether Senate leaders allow a vote on the Schiff amendment to remove the historic preservation title; dropping it could peel away tribal opposition but cost support from developers who see Section 106 as a source of delay. Third, whether House leaders schedule the bill at all before the session ends, or let it die and leave permitting reform to a Democratic Congress with very different priorities.
The underlying question is one both parties now claim to care about: whether America can build again, and at what cost. Washington has decided that the answer involves fewer lawsuits and faster reviews. The fight this week is over who gets left out of the room when that happens.
