Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

'8-0 2027': The Map War That Survived the Backfire

2026-11-18 · Washington Eye Team

Aerial view of the Missouri State Capitol in Jefferson City beside the Missouri River (photo: KTrimble, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

When Missouri's highest court blocked a new Republican congressional map from taking effect, the man who will lead the state Senate next year answered with a short post online. State Sen. Nick Schroer wrote: "8-0 2027." The message was hard to misread. A map designed to defeat every Democrat in Missouri's House delegation.

Then came Election Day. Missouri voters rejected the map in a referendum, approved a constitutional amendment designed to stop lawmakers from quietly reviving it, and handed Democrats a third congressional seat on the old lines. Across the country, the same story played out in state after state where Republicans had redrawn districts in the middle of the decade at President Donald Trump's urging. The maps were meant to protect a House majority. Instead, many of them helped Democrats build one.

Yet the fight over the lines is not over. It is changing shape. Here is what happened, why some experts say the lesson is being misread, and the five places to watch next.

How the backfire happened

The mid-decade push began when Mr. Trump called on Texas lawmakers to redraw their map to net as many as five more Republican seats. Other Republican-led states followed. By one count, Republicans redrew 15 seats to their advantage before the midterms. A week after the election, they appeared on course to lose all but two of them.

In Texas, Republicans won just one of the districts they reshaped and will hold 24 of the state's 38 seats. In Ohio, a commission dominated by Republicans drew lines aimed at two more seats; Democrats won eight districts, including those of the two Democratic incumbents the map targeted, Reps. Marcy Kaptur and Greg Landsman, leaving Republicans with seven. In Florida, where Gov. Ron DeSantis pushed a map meant to net up to four seats, Democrats won all four of the targeted districts.

North Carolina was the starkest case. Republicans already held 10 of the state's 14 seats and redrew the map to make it harder for Rep. Don Davis, a Black Democrat in the northeast, to win. Davis won anyway. If results certified by local officials hold, Democrats will hold 11 of the state's 14 seats in the next Congress, after entering Election Day with four.

The mechanism has a name among mapmakers: the "dummymander." To squeeze out extra seats, a party spreads its own voters more thinly across more districts. In a normal year, each district still holds. In a wave, the cushions vanish. One post-election analysis found that Republican mapmakers had bet the 2026 electorate would look like 2024's, when Mr. Trump made big gains with Latino and working-class voters. Instead, voters behaved more like they had in 2020 or even 2018.

Tennessee's 4th District became the textbook example. Republicans cut its margin from a district Mr. Trump won by 44 points to one he won by 24, part of a redraw that also carved up the Democratic seat in Memphis, which Republicans won. An early count showed the Democrat, Victoria Broderick, ahead by roughly 280 votes, and a week later the race was still rated a toss-up.

"The maps themselves did fail, and failed quite epically," said John Bisognano, president of the National Democratic Redistricting Committee. An unnamed House Republican, speaking to a cable news network, was blunter about his own side: "It was definitely the wrong move. One of the truisms in politics is never to overreach. We did and that was part of the reason for the backlash."

The case that gerrymandering still worked

Not everyone accepts the obituary. Nicholas Stephanopoulos, a Harvard professor who studies redistricting, argues that judging the maps against Republican dreams of five extra seats sets the wrong baseline. Compared with a neutral map, he said, many of them "performed very well for Republicans."

Texas is his main exhibit. Democratic statewide candidates won more than half the vote there, yet Republicans will still hold 24 of the 38 seats. "Nobody should think gerrymandering failed when Republicans are winning 65% of the seats in Texas with 45% of the vote," Mr. Stephanopoulos said. "That's a massive victory for a gerrymander."

Adam Kincaid, the Republican mapmaker who drew the Texas lines, said the pickup seats were always meant to be competitive, not safe, so that incumbents would not be put at risk in a bad year. On North Carolina, he offered a sharp distinction: "The point is not to protect from the flood, it's to protect from the wave."

The warning for Democrats is that the maps remain on the books. Mr. Stephanopoulos said that in Florida, Texas and elsewhere, "if we snap back to a more neutral electoral environment in 2028 or 2030," many of these districts "will just flip right back to Republicans." Mr. Bisognano made a similar point from the other side: Democrats, he said, "should not have needed to overperform by 10 to 15%" to win.

In other words, the gerrymanders lost a battle they were never built for. Whether they lose the next one depends on the weather in 2028.

What to watch: five fronts in the next round

1. Missouri: can Republicans try again?

Mr. Schroer, who becomes Senate majority leader in January, has not let go of the idea, but he concedes the ground has shifted. The new Amendment 6 bars lawmakers from passing laws "similar in effect" to measures voters have rejected by referendum, unless at least 80 percent of both chambers agree to send the question back to voters. That means 131 votes in the House and 28 in the Senate, far more than Republicans hold on their own.

"Are we handcuffed by Amendment Six?" Mr. Schroer said. "We've got several attorneys looking into this, myself included." The amendment does not define "similar in effect." Would a map targeting a St. Louis seat instead of the Kansas City district count? Travis Crum, an election law professor at Washington University, has said he believes any new map before the 2030 census would be covered. No court has tested that.

His own party is divided. Incoming Senate President Pro Tem Jason Bean said, "I don't think redistricting is high on our list of priorities." Sen.-elect Mike Deering went further: "The voters spoke. They want to keep the map as is, and that's what we should do." Secretary of State Denny Hoskins has claimed the current map is unconstitutional because of a Supreme Court ruling on Louisiana, though that decision did not order Missouri to redraw anything.

There is also a practical problem. A Republican pollster, Titus Bond of Remington Research Group, ran this year's results through the rejected lines and found Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver would still have won, by 491 votes, while two Republican incumbents would have held on by fewer than 2,000 and about 10,700 votes. Those estimates assume voters would have behaved the same way under different lines. The organisers of the referendum say they will be back if needed. "Will People Not Politicians continue to exist?" said its executive director, Richard von Glahn. "I guess we will."

2. Maryland: Democrats' turn with the pen

Maryland voters approved Question 3 by about 20 points, removing state constitutional requirements that congressional districts be compact and connected. Democrats, led by Gov. Wes Moore, are now expected to redraw the map to target the state's sole Republican House member. If they do, the national map war will have moved from a Republican offensive to a tit-for-tat, with Democrats borrowing the tactic they spent the year denouncing.

3. Louisiana: two runoffs on Dec. 12

Louisiana redrew its map after the Supreme Court ruling that struck down a district drawn mainly on racial grounds, aiming to eliminate one of its two Democratic seats. Two House runoffs on Dec. 12, with early voting starting Nov. 28, will decide whether that worked. In the 5th District, Democratic state Rep. Pat Moore faces Republican state Rep. Gabe Firment for the seat left open by Sen.-elect Julia Letlow. In the 6th, Democrat Chauna Banks faces Republican state Sen. Blake Miguez. Combined first-round votes favoured Republicans in both. If Democrats win either seat, the redraw will not have gained Republicans anything.

4. The recounts that set the final number

Democrats had won at least 257 House seats as of Tuesday, matching their 2008 total, with a handful of races still uncalled. Several recounts, all in Republican-leaning districts, will settle the rest. In North Carolina's 5th District, Rep. Virginia Foxx, chair of the House Rules Committee, requested a recount after trailing Democrat Chuck Hubbard by just over 300 votes. In the 10th District, election workers in five counties were recounting ballots on Wednesday at the request of Democrat Ashley Bell, who trails Rep. Pat Harrigan; he has declared victory but said he respects her right to ask. In Minnesota's 1st District, Rep. Brad Finstad is seeking a recount against Democrat Jake Johnson, who leads by about 300 votes and has begun his transition.

5. The blue states that drew back

California shows what a gerrymander looks like when the wave runs with it. Voters there approved a Democratic redraw in response to Texas, and Republicans won only four of the state's 52 seats. In Utah, a court-chosen map created a Democratic-leaning Salt Lake City seat, which Ben McAdams won by 47 points. In Virginia, by contrast, the state Supreme Court threw out a voter-approved Democratic map, and Democrats still gained two seats on the old lines. Those results will shape how hard each party pushes when the next opportunity comes.

The real lesson

The easy reading of 2026 is that gerrymandering does not work. The more accurate one is narrower and, for both parties, more uncomfortable. Maps drawn to squeeze out every last seat are fragile in a wave, and voters in Missouri showed they will punish a power grab at the ballot box when given the chance. But maps that bank a solid advantage, as in Texas, can survive even a historic defeat and still deliver seats out of proportion to the vote.

That is why "8-0 2027" still matters. The next round will be fought in state legislatures, state courts and on ballot measures, often far from Washington, and the outcome will help decide whether the House Democrats just won is a lasting majority or a one-wave wonder.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X