For almost a year, the question of how many advanced American AI chips Washington had cleared for sale to China was answered with a shrug. Officials spoke of "strict conditions" and "limited volumes." Companies said they followed the rules in force at the time. On Thursday, the House Foreign Affairs Committee stopped waiting for a straight answer and published the numbers itself.
The documents, released under a rarely used provision of the Export Control Reform Act, show that the Commerce Department's Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) received applications to sell 3,444,160 high-end Nvidia and AMD chips to Chinese companies between December 2025 and May 2026, and approved 879,868 of them across 21 licences. Some of the approvals went to companies that the Pentagon itself lists as "Chinese Military Companies." And nearly every Nvidia application named, as possible installers of the hardware, firms that have been publicly linked to chip smuggling.
The committee's chairman, Representative Brian Mast, a Florida Republican, called it "the most detailed public disclosure in the history of the Export Control Reform Act." It lands at an awkward moment for Nvidia and for Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, both of whom face questioning on Capitol Hill in the coming weeks.
What exactly was released?
Two documents. The first is a short summary drawn from a BIS briefing to the committee dated May 11, 2026. The second is a table listing individual licence applications: the date filed, the exporter, the Chinese customer, the number of chips and the outcome.
The chips in question are Nvidia's H200 and AMD's MI325X. Neither is the newest product either company makes, but both are powerful data centre processors of the kind used to train and run large AI models. The door to these sales opened in December 2025, when President Donald Trump said Nvidia could ship H200s to "approved customers in China" provided the United States received a 25 percent cut of the sales.
The committee used its power under the law to make such information public when it "determines that the withholding of the following information is contrary to the national interest." Members voted to release the material at a committee meeting on Thursday, and the panel's senior Republican and senior Democrat both spoke in favour of making it public.
Who got the chips?
The approvals read like a directory of China's technology giants. According to the summary, BIS cleared 75,000 chips for Alibaba, 150,000 for Tencent and its subsidiaries, 43,000 for the search company Baidu and 4,000 for the carmaker BYD. All four appear on the Department of War's June 2026 list of Chinese Military Companies, the designation Washington uses for firms it considers contributors to China's defence industrial base.
The table adds more names. It shows approvals for 75,000 chips each for ByteDance and a ByteDance subsidiary, 41,300 for the online retailer JD, 24,780 for the ride-hailing company Didi, 57,810 for the video game maker miHoYo, 75,000 AMD chips for the short video company Kuaishou, and smaller batches for carmakers including Li Auto, Great Wall Motor and Tesla's Shanghai operation. Nearly every approved line carries the same status: "Approved, not shipped."
The requests were far larger than the approvals. Alibaba and its subsidiaries asked for 948,950 chips. A single Nvidia application filed on February 6, 2026 sought 610,000 for Alibaba, and another sought 508,000 for a ByteDance unit in Malaysia. Both were returned without action. The committee also says it holds other applications that do not appear in the May summary, including a December 19, 2025 Nvidia request to send 445,000 H200s to Tencent.
Why are lawmakers alarmed?
The sharpest finding concerns the companies that would physically set up the hardware. All but two of the Nvidia applications given to the committee list Maginfra, Beijing New Matrix Information Technologies, ZTE Kangxun Telecom and Lenovo or its subsidiaries as entities that "may install the systems in the datacenter." The summary notes that there have been public reports raising questions about diversion risks posed by Maginfra, New Matrix and a third installer, Aivres Systems.
Mr. Mast did not mince words. "Both are fake companies," he said of Maginfra and New Matrix at Thursday's meeting. "If BIS approved the sale of these chips to these firms, obviously that is of tremendous concern to us, especially given that President Trump made clear last year that the sale of any AI chips to China will have very real national security conditions." A major American newspaper reported earlier this month that both firms had empty offices and ties to companies under national security sanctions. Neither company replied to requests for comment, according to a US business news report.
Another line in the summary is likely to come up again and again in the hearings ahead: "Every NVIDIA and AMD application stated that the proposed transfer posed a 'low' risk of diversion."
Representative Gregory Meeks of New York, the committee's top Democrat, aimed his fire at the regulator rather than the companies. "The Bureau of Industry and Security has failed to enforce the rules, and Congress must now conduct rigorous oversight of the administration's policies," he said. "The public has the right to know how these decisions were made."
What do Commerce and the chipmakers say?
BIS defended its process. A spokesperson said the agency had shared information with Congress on both approvals and denials, and that "licensing decisions are the product of deliberation and consultation among multiple U.S. Government agencies."
Nvidia said it had followed the regulations in effect at the time. "The review and licensing process spanned more than half a year, with approvals subject to strict conditions and limited volumes," said John Rizzo, a company spokesperson. "Despite receiving some licenses, we have since stopped shipping H200s to China." AMD said it "complies with applicable U.S. export control laws and regulations and maintains rigorous processes to ensure compliance across our global operations."
Some industry analysts think the outrage outruns the numbers. Stacy Rasgon, a senior semiconductor analyst at the investment firm Bernstein, called 879,000 approvals "not that many." "It doesn't sound to me like they're approving everything they got willy nilly," he said. "There was a process in place, and it sounds like they approved about one out of every four."
If the chips were approved, why were so few shipped?
Because the other government involved said no. Analysts have reported that Beijing did not approve large-scale imports of the H200, apparently preferring to push its own companies toward domestic chips. That is why so many approved lines in the table read "not shipped." Nvidia has said H200 shipments to China were less than 1 percent of its data centre revenue in the quarter that ended in July.
The picture is not entirely clean, though. On Tuesday Nvidia reported $2.4 billion in quarterly revenue from H200 and related chip sales in China, and customers in China and Hong Kong made up about 9.5 percent of its total revenue. The disclosure does not explain how those sales map onto the licences, and that gap is exactly what lawmakers now want filled.
How does this connect to the Nvidia scandal?
Directly. The release follows the resignation this month of Nvidia's co-founder and chief executive, Jensen Huang, after reports of extramarital affairs, including one with Alice Huang, a suspected Chinese spy. She was an executive until 2025 at Megaspeed, a Singapore company that US investigators suspect of diverting Nvidia chips to China. China has denied that she was a spy, and Megaspeed has denied that any smuggling took place.
A major American newspaper has reported that some of the installer firms named in the licence files are linked to Megaspeed. Mr. Lutnick has come under fire over his relationship with Mr. Huang and for failing to act against Megaspeed.
The calendar is now crowded. Mr. Huang is due to sit for a closed-door transcribed interview with the Foreign Affairs Committee and two other House committees on December 1. Nvidia's general counsel, Tim Teter, is scheduled for December 2. Senator Tim Scott of South Carolina, who chairs the Senate Banking Committee, has said that both Mr. Huang and Mr. Lutnick have agreed to testify before his panel.
Is the administration already tightening the rules?
It is, at least on one front. On Monday, Commerce issued an interim final rule closing a loophole that let Chinese companies rent advanced Nvidia computing power from data centres in third countries. BIS said the rule was "written by and at the direction of" the Treasury Department and the White House National Security Council.
The rule appears to bite. Tencent said on Wednesday that the ban would cut the advanced computing capacity available to it and slow its model training. Alibaba's chief executive, Eddie Wu, said on an earnings call on Thursday: "Based on our initial assessment, the long-term target of 20 gigawatts may be lowered, which will also lead to a reduction in our overall capital expenditure plan."
AMD is facing questions of its own. Its shares fell on Thursday after an investment research firm published a report alleging that a blacklisted Chinese server maker, IEIT Systems, kept receiving newer AMD firmware. The claim has not been independently verified.
What happens next?
Three things are worth watching.
First, the hearings. The December sessions will test whether the "low" risk ratings in the applications were checked by anyone at BIS, and whether officials knew about the reports on the installer firms when they signed off. Expect lawmakers to quote the licence table line by line.
Second, legislation. Members of both parties have called for tougher statutory export controls on advanced AI chips to China and other adversaries since the Huang scandal broke. Republicans control the Senate only until January 3, when Democrats take over both chambers. A bill that moves now would be a bipartisan one; a bill that waits would be written by Democrats who, as Mr. Meeks made clear, want to put the regulator under a microscope.
Third, Beijing. The real brake on these sales was never Washington's paperwork but China's own import decisions. Tencent and Alibaba both say they expect Chinese chipmakers to produce advanced AI hardware at scale by 2027 or 2028. If that happens, the fight over who approved what in 2025 and 2026 may end up mattering more as a test of congressional oversight than as a shift in the balance of AI power.
For now, the lesson is simple. The United States agreed to sell nearly 880,000 of its best AI chips to Chinese companies, including some the Pentagon calls military contributors, on the strength of applications that all rated the risk as low. Congress has the list. The questions start in December.
