Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

A Bird in the Hand: Why Democrats Should Finish the Permitting Deal Before January

2026-11-10 · Washington Eye Team

A high-voltage transmission tower and lines crossing desert public lands in Arizona (photo: Michelle Ailport, Bureau of Land Management Arizona, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

A week after voters handed Democrats large majorities in both chambers, the first big decision of the lame-duck Congress has split the party almost exactly in half. On Monday evening the Senate voted 73 to 25 to begin debate on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a sweeping rewrite of federal permitting law. Fifty-one Republicans voted yes. So did 21 Democrats, including Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, and independent Angus King of Maine. Twenty-three Democrats voted no, joined by Senator Bernie Sanders and one Republican, Mike Rounds of South Dakota.

The Democrats who voted no are not cranks. They include Ed Markey of Massachusetts and Jeff Merkley of Oregon, two of the most serious climate legislators in the chamber, and they are backed by the largest tribal advocacy organisation in the country, by many of the big national environmental groups and, in the House, by Hakeem Jeffries, the man expected to be the next Speaker. Their argument is simple and, after last Tuesday, seductive: why accept a compromise negotiated under Republican control when a far stronger hand arrives on January 3?

It is a fair question. The answer is that the hand is not as strong as it looks, and the bill is better than its critics allow. Democrats should finish this deal before the year ends, and they should use the next few weeks of amendments to fix its genuine weak points rather than to kill it.

Start with what the legislation actually does. The bill, introduced on Sept. 30 by Republicans Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia and Mike Lee of Utah and Democrats Martin Heinrich of New Mexico and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island, runs to more than 400 pages. It sets hard clocks on federal reviews: once an environmental review is complete, agencies taking part would have 90 days to decide outstanding permits, and a lead agency would have 45 days after a final environmental impact statement to issue its decision. It narrows the definition of the federal actions that trigger review under the National Environmental Policy Act. It touches the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act and the National Historic Preservation Act.

It also contains things progressives have wanted for years. It would expand federal authority to site and approve certain large interstate transmission lines and give Washington more oversight of utility planning. It protects permits that have already been issued, a direct answer to Democrats angered by an administration that has held up wind projects in Pentagon reviews. And it would require large data centers to pay for more of the grid upgrades needed to serve them, rather than passing those costs on to ordinary ratepayers. Weekend revisions added requirements for tribal consultation, a bigger role for states in transmission planning and a new Department of Energy programme to help communities cope with data-center impacts.

The transmission provisions are the heart of the climate case. Wind, solar and batteries are now cheap to build, but they are useless if they cannot reach customers. At the end of 2025, according to figures cited in coverage of the vote, 2,060 gigawatts of generation and storage capacity were waiting in queues to connect to the grid. Interstate lines can take a decade to build. Ben King of the Rhodium Group, whose modelling finds that the bill would lower domestic emissions, put the point plainly: the bill "sets up the ability to build stuff more quickly for when the next wave of climate policy happens."

That phrase matters, because the case for waiting rests on an assumption that the next wave is only weeks away. It is not. Democrats will control Congress in January, but Donald Trump will control the veto pen until January 2029, and the Senate filibuster does not disappear because the majority changes hands. Any permitting bill written in the next Congress will still need 60 senators and a presidential signature. The current bill already has the president's support. He urged his followers on his social media platform to call their senators, promising that it would let the country build "Pipelines, Mines, and Power Plants faster than ever before." A Democratic bill that tilted harder toward clean energy would be unlikely to keep that endorsement.

Jane Flegal, a senior fellow at the Searchlight Institute, made the timing argument well before the vote: "the filibuster and veto don't go away in January." Her deeper point is about implementation. Permitting reform takes years to work its way through agency rules, court cases and project pipelines. If Democrats hope to win the White House in 2028 and move quickly on energy costs, the time to plant those seeds is now, not in a 2027 negotiation that could easily stall. Heinrich, who is likely to chair the Senate energy committee next year, said much the same: "It doesn't necessarily get easier just because of who the chair is."

There is also the politics of the election itself. Democrats did not win on abstractions. They won, in large part, on affordability. The head of the main clean-power trade group put it simply after the election: "to reduce energy prices is to pass permitting reform." Heinrich used Monday's press conference to argue that Americans had sent "a clear message" that they want Congress focused on making life cheaper. Whitehouse was blunter in a statement before the vote: the bill "is a bird in the hand. We'd be fools not to take it." A party that campaigned against rising power prices should be wary of telling voters that the fix can wait for a better deal that may never come.

None of this makes the opponents wrong about everything. Their strongest objection concerns the courts. Under the bill, a challenge to an environmental review would have to be filed within 150 days, by someone who had already submitted a detailed comment and could show direct harm. Most cases would go straight to a federal appeals court. And for a violation of the environmental review law, the normal remedy would be to send the decision back to the agency to fix within 180 days, without cancelling the permit or halting the project in the meantime.

Those rules would not only speed up transmission lines. They would apply to gas pipelines, mines and, as the American Civil Liberties Union warned senators in a letter, to the administration's plans for large new immigration detention facilities, which lawyers have used the same environmental law to challenge. Abigail Dillen, president of Earthjustice Action, called the bill "the single biggest overhaul" of American environmental law since the 1970s. The oil industry's main trade association has hailed it as "a historic opportunity," and Democrats are right to ask why.

The tribal objection is just as serious. Mark Macarro, president of the National Congress of American Indians, called the bill "such an existential threat to Indian country." Senator Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada voted to begin debate but said she would oppose final passage unless the provisions affecting the National Historic Preservation Act are removed. Markey, explaining his no vote, said Democrats owed voters a deal that delivers clean power and lower bills "without leaving so many important members of our community on the losing side of the ledger."

And there is the emissions question, which is genuinely unsettled. Rhodium's model shows emissions falling. A model by Kevin Kircher, an engineering professor at Purdue University, shows them rising, in part, he argues, because updated grid queues look more dependent on gas than older estimates assumed. Kircher himself urged humility, noting that none of the models has had time for peer review.

These are reasons to amend the bill, not to abandon it. Whitehouse has promised a "very healthy amendment process," and the votes are there to make it real. Twenty-one Democrats voted to proceed; the bill's authors need a good share of them to reach 60 again, and Cortez Masto has already shown how to use that leverage. Democrats who want this law should insist, as a condition of their final votes, on removing or narrowing the historic preservation changes that tribes object to most, and on tightening the judicial review limits so they do not become a fast lane for detention centers and export pipelines. If the sponsors and the White House refuse, the no votes will have earned their case.

The House is the harder problem, and it argues for urgency rather than delay. Analysts at one investment bank wrote before the vote that the House "now appears to be the binding constraint." Jeffries has said the bill "falls short in several areas" and that he will not "rubber-stamp legislation without more constructive involvement with our caucus." On Monday he said the revisions were "still under review." On the Republican side, the House Energy and Commerce chairman, Brett Guthrie of Kentucky, has reportedly sought changes to the transmission section that Southeastern utilities fear. Leaders could route the bill through the Rules Committee, try to pass it under suspension with a two-thirds vote, or attach it to must-pass spending or defense legislation, as Congress did with the Energy Act of 2020 after Trump lost that year's election.

Every one of those paths is narrow, and the session is short. The lame duck is scheduled to run to about Dec. 18, with a week off for Thanksgiving. That is precisely why Senate Democrats should treat the coming amendment votes as a negotiation to be won, not a delay to be engineered. A Jeffries who gets real changes for tribes and on the courts has every reason to say yes. A Jeffries who is asked to wait for 2027 has every reason to inherit a fight he cannot finish while Trump holds the veto.

Bill McKibben, the climate writer, said it would be "highly ironic" if the first act of a Congress chastened by data-center anger were to make data centers easier to build. He is right about the irony and wrong about the choice. This bill makes the largest power users pay their own way, and it speeds the transmission lines that clean energy cannot do without. Those are the things that cut bills. The rest, as Whitehouse put it, is "the floor, not the ceiling."

Progressives have spent a decade warning that the climate cannot wait for perfect politics. They should take their own advice. Fix what can be fixed in the next five weeks, then pass the bill, and spend the new majority building on it rather than starting over.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X