On October 15, in a sealed courtroom in Washington, a Justice Department lawyer gave a federal judge an answer she clearly did not expect. Months earlier, the government had told Judge Ana C. Reyes that there were no planned removals of Iranians to Iran. "The answer in August was no," the lawyer, Dimitar Georgiev, said, according to a transcript made public on November 5. "Today that answer has changed and it is yes."
Judge Reyes stopped him. "I'm sorry, I just want to make sure I understand this correctly," she said. "We are going to remove people in our custody to a country with which we are at war?" A few minutes later she reached for the starkest comparison an American judge can make. "It is like saying we have individuals in 1942 in this country that we are going to send back to Nazi Germany," she said. "That is the equivalent of what you are telling me."
Less than four weeks later, Immigration and Customs Enforcement loaded Iranian detainees onto a plane in Mesa, Arizona. That flight was cancelled on the tarmac. Two days later a second attempt took off and turned back within half an hour, after Pakistan, the planned transit point, declined to receive the passengers. Nobody was delivered to Tehran. But the record raises a question that should trouble Americans of every political stripe: how did a government at war with Iran end up working alongside Iranian officials to send people back to the regime they fled?
The case that exposed all this was not originally about deportation flights at all. In July, the Iranian American Legal Defense Fund, working with the litigation group Public Citizen, sued Secretary of State Marco Rubio, the State Department, the Department of Homeland Security and ICE. The complaint accused the government of handing Iranian officials confidential information from asylum files, which federal regulations bar from being disclosed to third parties. Those files spell out why a person fears for their life: a conversion, a political affiliation, a protest.
"In this case, the U.S. government has already admitted that it revealed the confidential legally protected credible fear information of asylum seekers to government officials of Iran," said Yasmine Chubin, the group's executive director. That is the plaintiffs' characterisation, and the government has contested the broader claim. Two ICE officials told the court in October, according to one news report, that their contacts with Iranian diplomats were limited to travel arrangements and documents. The Homeland Security Department has said that ICE "actively coordinates" with foreign countries to secure travel documents and is committed to telling detainees of their right to speak with consular officials.
Yet the record now public describes something more than paperwork. According to the transcript, the government told the court it would "facilitate the travel" of Iranian detainees to a third country, and that the government of Iran would handle the rest of the journey. Officials from Iran's interests section in Washington, which operates under the umbrella of Pakistan's embassy because the two countries have no diplomatic relations, were sent to detention centres to meet detainees.
One account in the filings stands out. In June, a man detained after a routine appointment at an immigration office in San Jose was taken to a detention facility in California City. A week later, he said, an officer led him to a private room where two men were waiting. They told him they knew "a great deal" about him, including his past ties to an Iranian opposition group and the years he spent at Camp Ashraf in Iraq before he resettled in the United States in 2015. "We know everything about you, do not worry," one of them said, as he later recalled in court papers.
Judge Reyes did not grant the preliminary injunction the plaintiffs wanted, and she has yet to decide whether their case can go forward. What she did instead was modest on paper. Her written order of October 15 requires the government to tell the court within 24 hours once it finalises any plan to remove Iranians to Iran, including through a third country where Iranian officials would arrange the onward trip, and to give five business days' written notice before any such removal. The order says it "should be read broadly to include any removal of Iranians that could result in those individuals being sent to Iran." From the bench she was blunter. "If anything happens that violates either of those two orders, I will hold every single person associated with violating it," she said. "I will start contempt proceedings."
Eight days later, on October 23, the government told the court that ICE's removal division had "finalized a plan to remove certain Iranian nationals subject to a final order of removal," according to the plaintiffs. On November 3 it filed another notice, this one ex parte, meaning the plaintiffs have not seen it. The next day it asked the judge to dissolve her order altogether.
The administration's case deserves a fair hearing. Government lawyers argue that the notice requirement works as an injunction because it carries the threat of contempt, that the advocacy group lacks standing to sue, and that immigration law strips the court of power to review removals. They quote the Supreme Court's warning against "unwarranted judicial interference in the conduct of foreign policy." Every person on the planned flights, the government says, had a final order of removal from an immigration judge.
The Homeland Security Department has gone further in public. A spokesperson said the second flight "contained criminal illegal aliens who have criminal histories that include arrests and convictions covering assaults, drug trafficking, child abuse, domestic battery, and illegal weapon possession." The spokesperson added: "Every illegal alien has their claims heard and receives due process. If a judge finds an illegal alien has no right to be in this country, we are going to remove them. Period." The department has not publicly identified the individuals or matched those charges to particular people, and lawyers for the detainees say many on the lists were asylum seekers, most of them Christian converts.
Then came the first weekend of November. According to a sworn declaration filed on November 8, an Iranian government official met seven detained men at an Arizona facility on November 6, announced a flight schedule and, when asked, showed one of them a list bearing his name and ten others. The plan, the filing says, was to fly eleven Iranians, ten men and a woman, from Arizona at about 4 a.m. on Sunday, November 8, refuel in the country of Georgia, land in Islamabad on 15-day Pakistani visas, and transfer them on to Iran two days later. By late Saturday night, he had called his wife to say ICE was moving the group to Mesa, whose airport serves as a staging site for removals.
The plaintiffs did the arithmetic in a filing they titled a notice of apparent violation. Counting five business days from the November 3 notice, and skipping the weekend and the Veterans Day holiday, the earliest permitted removal date would be November 10. A Sunday departure would follow only three business days' notice. The plaintiffs conceded they could not see whether the sealed November 3 notice covered this flight, and asked the judge to check.
At least eight Iranians were put on the plane that Sunday morning, according to Ali Rahnama, a lawyer for the defence fund. It was cancelled without explanation. On Tuesday, November 10, a small ICE charter jet left Mesa at about 5 a.m. and came back within 30 minutes, according to a nonprofit group that tracks deportation flights. Two people familiar with the matter said Pakistan had declined to receive the passengers. Lawyers say the detainees have been told they could be put on another flight soon.
ICE has sent Iranians home before: it told the court it arranged three flights returning more than 100 Iranian nationals between September 2025 and January 2026. What makes this round different is the war. By the plaintiffs' count the conflict has lasted eight months. President Trump said this month that Iran "militarily is effectively over," but no peace has been signed, the naval blockade continues, and Iran claimed a strike in Bahrain only this week. Sending people back there, Judge Reyes said in October, meant they faced "at a minimum a serious threat of certain death."
It is a contradiction the president has written himself. In January, as protests spread across Iran, Mr. Trump told Iranians that "help is on its way." At the start of the war he urged them to rise up: "When we are finished, take over your government. It will be yours to take." For four decades, governments of both parties treated people fleeing the Islamic Republic as living proof of its cruelty. Federal law and the Convention Against Torture, which the United States has ratified, forbid sending anyone to a country where they are more likely than not to be tortured. An immigration judge's final order does not erase that principle; it is supposed to have applied it.
Consider Hannaneh Alikaram, a Christian convert who crossed the Darien Gap with her husband to seek asylum in late 2024. He won asylum; her nearly identical claim was rejected. Last month, after almost two years in detention, she received an ICE message telling her to contact Iranian government officials in Washington about her case. "If they send me back to Iran, what will happen to me?" her husband recalls her asking through tears. She remains in a Louisiana detention centre with a heart condition, her habeas petition still pending.
Ms. Chubin says her group's lawyers know of at least a dozen detainees approached about removal in recent weeks. "We're at war and it's unsafe to send anyone back to Iran," she said.
The legal ground under these detainees is shifting. In September the Supreme Court let the administration resume deporting migrants to countries other than their own without giving them a chance to show the harm they might face there, and the justices will hear arguments on that policy on December 9. The route through Pakistan sits in exactly that grey zone: a third country on paper, a pipeline to Tehran in practice.
There is a reasonable conservative argument that a single district judge should not be running foreign policy from the bench, and the administration is entitled to make it on appeal. But Judge Reyes has not stopped a single removal. She has asked only to be told in advance, so that a court can check whether people are being handed to a government that the United States has been bombing. If that request is too much for the executive branch to honour, the problem is not the judge.
Democrats, who will control Congress from January, now have a concrete set of questions to ask: what Iranian officials were told about these detainees and when, who authorised their visits to American detention centres, and whether the November 3 notice described the flights that followed. Judge Reyes has her own questions, and a contempt warning on the record. For the Iranians sitting in Arizona and Louisiana, the answers will decide whether the next plane turns back again.
