Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Bessent Says It's Just Oil. Your Doctor's Bill Disagrees

2026-11-15 · Washington Eye Team

The Marriner S. Eccles Federal Reserve Board Building in Washington (photo: Federal Reserve, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

Scott Bessent had a simple message for the Federal Reserve on Friday: relax. In a television interview, the Treasury secretary said the central bank should understand that today's inflation is "an energy supply shock" tied to the Iran war, that the numbers are "very noisy," and that the Fed is "supposed to look into the future, not look in the rearview mirror." Raising rates sharply now, he said, "isn't something that I would do if I were on the Fed. But I'm not on the Fed."

Within the hour, someone who is on the Fed answered him on the same programme. Austan Goolsbee, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, said politely that he respected the secretary, and then took his argument apart. Inflation, Goolsbee said, has spread to services and to areas like medical care "that are not usually responsive to the price of oil." In categories untouched by oil and tariffs, he said, "you are still seeing stalled progress and in some cases going the wrong way. That is not going away no matter what happens to the price of oil."

Goolsbee has the better of this argument, and it is not close. More to the point, the people who would pay for following Bessent's advice are not bond traders or Treasury officials. They are the workers whose paychecks are already running just to stand still.

Start with the data that set off this week's debate. Consumer prices rose 0.4 percent in October, after 0.6 percent in September, the third straight month of gains of 0.4 percent or more. Because last year's government shutdown stopped the collection of price data in October 2025, the government could not publish an official annual rate this time; the last one, for September, was 3.7 percent. The core index, which strips out food and energy, rose 0.3 percent for the third month in a row. Economists had expected 0.2.

Now look at where the increases landed. Hospital services rose 0.8 percent in a single month. Physicians' services rose 0.4 percent. Motor vehicle insurance climbed 0.7 percent. Beef rose 0.9 percent, and groceries overall rose 0.4 percent. Smartphone prices jumped 1.4 percent, the largest monthly increase on record, and television prices rose 3.3 percent, reversing the usual pattern in which electronics get cheaper every year. None of that is a gas station story. Your doctor does not bill you by the barrel.

That is exactly the point Lorie Logan, president of the Dallas Fed and a voting member of the rate-setting committee, made on Tuesday. Prices remain high, she said, for "visits to the doctor, childcare, dining out and hotel stays," and those services "aren't particularly sensitive to tariffs, conflict in the Middle East or surging demand for computer chips." Anna Paulson of the Philadelphia Fed put it more bluntly: "Underlying inflation is above target, and it hasn't come down. That tells me that elevated inflation isn't just about factors that will go away on their own." Governor Michelle Bowman, no one's idea of a dove on regulation or a hawk by temperament, said the pressures "may be broadening." Goolsbee himself called the figures "borderline disturbing."

When officials who disagree on a great deal all describe the same trend, the honest response is not to call the numbers noise.

To be fair to Bessent, part of his case is real. Oil prices have slid more than 5 percent over the past month as President Donald Trump has talked about winding down the fighting. Economists at a major investment bank published an estimate this week that almost all of the recent overshoot comes from tariffs and the energy shock, and that once those temporary drivers are stripped out, underlying inflation sits near the Fed's target. Raising rates also has costs, and those costs fall heavily on ordinary people: higher payments on mortgages, car loans and credit cards. Progressives have spent decades warning that the Fed too often fights inflation by throwing workers out of jobs. That warning still matters.

But the "look through it" argument has a shelf life, and it expired some time ago. The Fed tried patience at the start of the Iran war. Policymakers said openly that they could look past supply-driven price spikes. That was in the spring. It is now November, and inflation has been above the Fed's 2 percent target for almost six years. The central bank's own projections, published in September, do not see it returning to target until 2029, a year later than they forecast in June. A temporary shock that lasts that long is not temporary for the family living through it.

Even on oil, the picture is murkier than Bessent suggests. Governor Christopher Waller noted this week that the cost of insuring tankers through the Strait of Hormuz and avoiding attacks has added as much as $20 to $30 a barrel, and that diesel is likely to stay expensive because of lost refining capacity. Despite the recent slide, a barrel still costs about $30 more than it did a year ago. And because the United States now exports energy, recent research suggests higher oil prices can feed into corporate profits and wages at home, a second-round effect the Fed cannot simply wave away.

There is also an awkward fact about the shocks themselves. They did not fall from the sky. The tariffs that pushed up goods prices last year were the president's choice, imposed under emergency powers the Supreme Court ruled in February he did not have. The war that closed the Strait of Hormuz and sent crude soaring was launched by the United States and Israel in February. The surge in data centre spending, which is driving up prices for chips, power equipment and copper, is a boom the administration has cheered at every turn. When the people who made the shocks ask the central bank to ignore the inflation those shocks produced, they are asking someone else to absorb the cost of their decisions.

That someone is usually the wage earner. In October, average hourly earnings rose 0.4 percent before inflation. Prices rose 0.4 percent too. The government's own measure of real hourly pay was therefore flat. A worker who got no raise that month went backwards. Diane Swonk, chief economist at the accounting firm KPMG, summed it up in a post online this week: "Consumers who rely mostly on wages, not their stock portfolios, are paying the price."

Voters understood this before the economists did. The cost of living was the central issue of the 3 November midterm elections, in which Democrats took control of both the House and the Senate. More than 120 million people went to the polls. Very few of them were asking for an inflation rate that drifts down by 2029.

Then there is the matter of who is giving the Fed advice, and how. Bessent prefaced his comments by saying, "I'm not going to tell the Fed what to do," before spending several minutes doing roughly that. He was not alone. After the Fed's quarter point hike in September, Trump declared that interest rates "should be 1%, or less" and said he had discussed with Kevin Warsh, the chair he picked, how Warsh would vote. A major American newspaper reported this week that Warsh's most recent public calendar, the fifth since he took office in May, lists no call or meeting with the president. Several Senate Democrats had asked him over the summer to disclose any such contacts.

This is the part progressives should care about most. An independent central bank is not a conservative institution or a liberal one. It is a guard against the oldest temptation in politics: to run the economy hot before an election and leave the bill for later. Families on fixed incomes, renters, and low-wage workers who cannot negotiate a cost of living raise are the first to suffer when that guard is lowered. The right response to a Treasury secretary leaning on the Fed is not to cheer when he happens to want lower rates. It is to insist that the Fed decide on the evidence.

The evidence is pointing one way. Futures markets now put the odds of a rate increase at the December 8 to 9 meeting at about 90 percent, and expectations of a second move in January tripled in a single day after the October report. Logan has said the Fed could "move more rapidly this winter." Waller had said before the data came out that if core prices rose 0.3 percent or more in October, the committee should consider a half point increase. They did. "Hiking only 25 basis points would put our credibility at risk," he said, "a risk I am not eager to take."

Warsh, for his part, has argued that high inflation is a "choice." He is right, and the choice now is his. If the Fed blinks in December because the Treasury asked nicely, it will not spare working families from pain. It will only stretch the pain out, and make the eventual cure harsher. Inflation that is allowed to settle in becomes what people expect, and expectations are far harder to drag down than oil prices.

None of this lets the White House off the hook. The cleanest way to bring prices down without punishing workers is for the administration to stop creating new shocks: to end the uncertainty over the war, to stop treating tariffs as a first resort, and to make sure the roughly $30 billion in unlawful tariffs still owed to importers is actually paid back. Those are choices too, and they belong to the people who are now telling the Fed to look away. In January, a Democratic Congress will have the power to ask about them, under oath if necessary.

Bessent wants the Fed to look at the road ahead rather than the rearview mirror. Fair enough. Through the windscreen, the view is a fourth year of prices rising faster than the target, a hospital bill up nearly 1 percent in a month, and a paycheck that bought no more in October than it did in September. That is not noise. That is the economy most Americans are living in, and they are entitled to a central bank that takes it seriously.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X