Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Bitcoin Just Halved. Good Thing Washington Never Bought

2026-11-21 · Washington Eye Team

Rows of bitcoin mining machines with glowing green lights inside a mining farm warehouse (photo: Marko Ahtisaari, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

Exactly one year ago, on the morning of 20 November 2025, the Texas Comptroller's office spent $5 million of public money on a bitcoin fund. A single coin cost $91,336 that morning. The state called it a "placeholder investment" for its new Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, the first of its kind funded by an American state, and its acting comptroller promised a reserve that "strengthens the state's balance sheet."

On Friday, the first anniversary of that purchase, bitcoin fell below $60,000 for the first time since July. By Saturday it had touched $57,716, its lowest level since September 2024, and was trading near $56,000. That is more than a third below what Texas paid, and less than half the peak above $126,000 the coin reached in October 2025. If the fund has tracked the coin, the Texas placeholder is now worth a little over $3 million.

Three million dollars will not break a state with a $338 billion budget. But Texas was meant to be the pilot, not the main event. The main event is in Washington, where the President is still "interested" in buying bitcoin with federal money, where a Senate bill would have the Treasury buy a million coins, and where a House committee has already voted to put a national reserve into law. Friday's crash is the clearest argument yet that Congress should do one simple thing before this Congress ends: write into law that the United States government will not buy bitcoin with taxpayer money. Not now, not at a discount, not through an accounting trick.

What happened this week

Bitcoin did not fall alone, which is part of the point. It fell with the riskiest corners of the stock market. The S&P 500 and the Dow Jones Industrial Average both closed Friday more than 10 percent below their record highs, confirming a correction. The Nasdaq Composite had its worst week since March 2020 and turned negative for the year after the record stock market debut of the artificial intelligence company Anthropic fizzled. Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook said in a speech on Friday that the central bank's policy rate is not high enough to deal with inflation, and traders now treat a rate increase at the Fed's 8 and 9 December meeting as close to certain.

Bitcoin was meant to be the hedge against exactly this kind of turmoil. Instead it behaved like a leveraged technology stock. It was down about 23 percent for November by Friday, on pace for its worst month since June 2022. Investors pulled roughly $3.5 billion out of American spot bitcoin funds this month, including $582 million on Thursday alone, according to the fund-flow tracker Farside Investors. About $2 billion in leveraged bets on rising crypto prices were wiped out in a single day. "Bitcoin is along for the ride here, typically weak in deleveraging environments," said Andy Baehr of the trading firm GSR.

Even the optimists sound chastened. James Butterfill, head of research at the asset manager CoinShares, said his firm had expected bitcoin to trade between $60,000 and $90,000, and called a break below that range "uncomfortable rather than thesis-changing." That may be a reasonable view for a fund manager whose clients chose to take the risk. It is not a reasonable view for a Treasury that would be holding the risk on behalf of every taxpayer who never chose it.

Where the federal reserve stands

To be fair to the White House, the United States has not bought a single bitcoin. Executive Order 14233, signed on 6 March 2025, created a Strategic Bitcoin Reserve filled only with coins the government had already seized and forfeited in criminal and civil cases, and ordered that coins deposited in it "shall not be sold." It allowed new acquisitions only through strategies that are "budget neutral and do not impose incremental costs on United States taxpayers." In August 2025 Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said in a television interview: "We're not going to be buying that, but we are going to use confiscated assets."

That restraint has been wise, and the numbers show why. The blockchain analytics firm Arkham counted about 328,000 bitcoin in government-linked wallets in February, and lists about 307,000 in its most recent tally, although about 127,000 of those coins remain tied up in forfeiture litigation and may yet go back to victims. Those coins cost the taxpayer nothing. Even so, at last October's peak, 307,000 coins were worth roughly $39 billion. At Saturday's prices they are worth roughly $17 billion. A free asset can lose $20 billion of paper value in 13 months and nobody is hurt. A purchased one cannot.

The pressure to buy has not gone away. Patrick Witt, who stepped down in October as executive director of the President's council of advisers on digital assets, said in a podcast interview on 9 November: "I can tell you the president's interested in it. I can tell you that there has been a lot of discussion about how we might be able to do that." He also admitted that outright purchases on the open market were of "questionable legality," because Congress controls federal spending, and said lawmakers had already put a provision in the annual defence authorisation bill to block them.

The bills on the table

Two pieces of legislation would change that. The first, Senator Cynthia Lummis's BITCOIN Act, S. 954, would direct the Treasury to buy one million bitcoin over five years and hold them for at least 20 years, paid for partly with money from the Federal Reserve and the Exchange Stabilization Fund. It has sat in the Senate Banking Committee since March 2025.

Do the arithmetic on a holding of that size. A million coins valued at the October 2025 peak would have been worth more than $126 billion. At Saturday's price they would be worth about $56 billion. A real purchase programme would have been spread over years, so the loss would not be that tidy. But the scale of the swing is the lesson: an asset that can lose $70 billion of value in 13 months, on a holding that size, is not a reserve. It is a wager.

The second bill is more modest, and more likely to survive. Representative Nick Begich of Alaska introduced H.R. 8957, the American Reserve Modernization Act, in May. On 16 September the House Financial Services Committee voted 28 to 21 to advance it. As introduced, it would require the Treasury to build secure storage for the reserve, hold deposited coins for at least 20 years, publish quarterly proof of its holdings with an independent audit, and study the costs and benefits of buying more over five years. The bill says it does not authorise borrowing, new taxes or deficit spending to buy bitcoin. The committee approved an amended version whose text has not yet been published.

Parts of that bill are good. Americans deserve to know exactly what the government holds, and the case for one secure, audited custodian is strong. In January the US Marshals Service confirmed it was investigating claims that more than $40 million had been taken from government-linked wallets tied to a custody contractor. Seized crypto scattered across agencies and contractors is a security problem, and fixing it does not require a single new coin.

The trouble is the study, and the door it leaves open. A study of "the costs and benefits of acquiring more" is how purchase programmes begin. And the most popular "budget neutral" idea among reserve supporters is no less risky for being clever. The Treasury holds about 261 million troy ounces of gold, carried on its books at a statutory price of $42.2222 an ounce, a book value of about $11 billion. Revalue that gold closer to its market price and a large paper gain appears, which could in theory be spent on bitcoin without new appropriations. But a paper gain on gold spent on a volatile asset is still public wealth exposed to a crash. Calling it budget neutral does not make it risk neutral.

Why the politics just changed

The odds of any purchase programme have fallen sharply since 3 November, when Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress. Senator Elizabeth Warren, the industry's fiercest critic in the Senate, is expected to lead the Banking Committee, through which the Lummis bill would have to pass. The broader crypto market structure bill, the CLARITY Act, already failed a Senate procedural vote 49 to 50 on 15 September. Mr Witt himself said codifying the reserve would be "really hard" with a divided Congress.

That is exactly why the moment matters. Without a law, the reserve rests on an executive order, and so does the restraint. A future administration of either party could rewrite the budget-neutral language with a stroke of a pen, or find a creative reading of the Exchange Stabilization Fund. The lame-duck session that runs until the new Congress is sworn in on 3 January is the last chance for lawmakers who wrote the reserve bills to decide what their legacy is.

What Congress should do

Our position is simple. Keep the reserve as a custody account for coins the government has lawfully forfeited. Pass the parts of the House bill that require audits, proof of holdings and one secure custodian. Then strip out the acquisition study and add one sentence: no federal funds, and no revaluation gains, may be used to buy bitcoin or any other digital asset. Supporters who believe in bitcoin are free to buy it themselves, and millions do. That is the difference between an investment and a policy.

None of this is an argument that bitcoin is worthless, or that the technology has no future. Bitcoin has crashed by more than half before and recovered to new highs, and it may do so again. That is precisely the problem. An asset whose fans tell you to hold on through 50 percent drops is an asset for people who can afford to wait, and who chose the risk. A government's reserves exist for the opposite purpose: to be there, at full value, on the worst day.

Friday was one of those days. Stocks fell, leveraged bets were wiped out and the Fed signalled more rate rises. Bitcoin lost more than 8 percent in a day and more than half its value from its peak. The University of Houston economist Ed Hirs warned last year, when Texas made its purchase, that if confidence ever collapsed, "taxpayers will be left holding the bag." Texas taxpayers are holding a small bag this weekend. Congress should make sure federal taxpayers never hold a big one.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X