Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Democrats Won Big. Now They Can't Agree Why

2026-11-15 · Washington Eye Team

Supporters crowd around James Talarico at a campaign rally at The Backyard in Texas, September 2025 (photo: H. Michael Karshis, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

For three days in a Denver music hall, the Democratic Party tried to answer a question it has not had to ask in a long time: what do you do after you win? The conference was called "What's Next," and it was staged like a festival, with concert-style posters and a busy merchandise booth. The mood was celebratory. The arguments were not.

The setting matters. Democrats are coming off their best midterm performance in more than half a century, with victories in states as red as Kansas, Texas and Mississippi. They are projected to hold at least 255 House seats to the Republicans' 169, with a dozen races still uncalled, and at least 55 Senate seats, possibly one more once Alaska finishes counting. President Trump still holds the veto for two more years. Those numbers frame everything the party now says about itself.

Almost every speaker agreed on the priority. Lowering the cost of food, housing and health care came up in speech after speech, from the likely incoming House speaker, Hakeem Jeffries, to a string of possible presidential candidates. "In every single state and in every single demographic group, cost of living was the most important issue," Charlotte Swasey, director of analytics at the centrist Searchlight Institute, told the crowd. The data analyst David Shor offered a sharper version: on the day the Iran war began, he said, the president's approval on gas prices "went from 49% to 33% within days."

Below that consensus, three fault lines ran through the room. Each will shape what a Democratic Congress does in January, and each will shape the 2028 primary that has already quietly begun.

Fault line one: what did voters actually say? The broadest disagreement is about the meaning of the win itself. The centrist reading, which Searchlight calls "supermajority thinking," holds that voters fired Republicans without hiring the left. "They are telling us loud and clear that they are real sick of Trump and his folks and the associated chaos," Swasey said. "But they're not super hype for a wild swing in the other direction."

Representative Jake Auchincloss of Massachusetts, who chairs Majority Democrats, the political action committee that hosted the event, pushed that reading furthest. He named "bad ideas" he wants his party to drop, including rent control, banning fossil fuels, "open borders" and inattention to the national debt, while urging Democrats to "swing for the fences" on new ideas such as a four-day work week. "This is the moment to challenge and cast off these bad ideas and embrace the best and most radical one we ever had: equal opportunity for all and special privileges for none," he said.

Progressives read the same results as a mandate for economic populism. Representative Ro Khanna of California, a possible presidential candidate, urged the party to stop chasing the political center and drew loud cheers for a platform that included universal health care, a wealth tax, a $25 federal minimum wage, deep Pentagon cuts and abolishing Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Texas Senator-elect James Talarico, the first Democrat the state has sent to the Senate since 1988, got a raucous reception when he attacked an "economic system that only benefits the top 1%" and called on Congress to "unrig the political system so no billionaire, no trillionaire, can buy our elections."

Both camps can point to evidence, which is exactly why the argument will not end soon. "It's to be expected that there will be a big debate because the Democratic victory was so broad it swept in centrists, southern Democrats and more progressive and left-wing Democrats," the veteran party strategist Elaine Kamarck said. In Michigan, a progressive, Abdul El-Sayed, won the Senate seat. In North Carolina and Montana, new members backed by the host committee are heading for the centrist Blue Dog caucus. The landslide was large enough to contain both theories.

Some speakers tried to wave the question away. Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, another potential 2028 contender, said voters "don't give a damn" about ideological litmus tests and care only about whether Democrats deliver. Senator Elissa Slotkin of Michigan made a similar plea. "If you have elected officials who are spending all their time fighting progressive vs. moderate, then they have missed the plot of the election," she said.

Fault line two: work with Trump or fight him? The most striking clash came over the president himself. Talarico urged Democrats to make Mr. Trump's last two years the most productive of any presidency. The line drew only tepid applause. Within minutes, two of the party's best-known figures answered him from the same stage.

Representative Jamie Raskin of Maryland, expected to chair the House Judiciary Committee and lead investigations of the administration next year, described the Republican Party as an authoritarian cult of personality. "We're going to reassert all of the powers of Congress that have been surrendered and abdicated by the MAGA Congress to King Trump," he said. "We're going to enforce the Constitution against him." Former Attorney General Eric Holder went further, warning against bipartisanship itself. "If we retreat into caution, if we operate out of fear, if we take refuge in the niceties of the old Washington and seek approval from those who have been and are actively dismantling our institutions, we will fail," he said.

Colorado's governor-elect, Phil Weiser, who beat Senator Michael Bennet, a member of the host committee, in the Democratic primary largely by emphasizing his record of fighting the administration, took the same line. "Never bend the knee," he said. "Never try to give up on what we believe in, thinking we're going to get something for it, because we won't."

This is not only a question of tone. It decides the shape of the next Congress. A party that wants to sign laws with this president has to write bills Republicans and the White House can accept, and it has to ration subpoenas. A party that wants to confront him will spend its first months on oversight, and its bills will be written mainly to be vetoed and campaigned on. Most Democrats in Denver said they wanted both. Few explained how to do both at once with a single floor calendar.

Fault line three: who leads, and who pays? The third divide is about power inside the party, and it played out in plain sight. Protesters interrupted Jeffries on stage, shouting for Medicare for All, a Green New Deal and an end to arms sales to Israel, and accusing him of being too timid. One called him a "traitor." Jeffries did not engage. "We've been working hard collectively across the House Democratic caucus, to do what was necessary to aggressively push back against MAGA extremism," he said. "And now we'll have the collective responsibility to really get to work fighting for an affordable America."

Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland arrived having just announced a challenge to Senator Chuck Schumer of New York for leadership of the incoming Senate majority. He framed his bid as a fight with entrenched interests. "Our candidates ran on platforms that are popular to the American people," he said. "But what they ran on was not so popular with many powerful special interests who profit from the status quo." Outside, activists held a banner opposing Schumer's "coronation."

The host itself was part of the argument. Majority Democrats is not an official party body. Founded in July 2025, it says it backs "a different kind of Democrat" who can win in Republican-leaning places, and it opposes high-profile left-wing ideas such as Medicare for All. Federal Election Commission filings show its top donors are the hedge fund billionaire Stephen Mandel and his wife, Sue, who have given nearly $11 million, with contributions also from former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg and from James and Kathryn Murdoch. Progressive groups including the Sunrise Movement and the Democratic Socialists of America protested outside. Several of the left's insurgent winners, among them Denver's 29-year-old democratic socialist representative-elect, Melat Kiros, were largely absent from the stage.

Supporters of the host committee say that is the point: the party needs candidates who can win the seats it just flipped and hold them in 2028. Critics say a donor-funded showcase is a poor place to settle the party's direction. Colorado's state party chair, Shad Murib, said there was room for both centrists and socialists, and that he would not trade the noise "for the Republicans' system of just following behind a leader."

What it means for 2028. Strip away the speeches and the conference was an audition. Khanna, Shapiro, Slotkin, former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg and Arizona Senator Ruben Gallego all took the stage, each testing a version of the same pitch: deliver on costs, and do it fast. Their differences are less about the goal than about the vehicle. Khanna is betting that a bold, government-led agenda is what voters rewarded. Shapiro is betting that voters reward results and punish labels. Others are still deciding which side of the fight-or-work question to stand on.

What united the room was a kind of anxiety. Several speakers described the win not as a lasting mandate but as a temporary opportunity. Gallego noted that many Hispanic voters who backed Mr. Trump in 2024 had voted Democratic this month. "It was not, though, a love letter to the Democratic Party," he said. "It is a short-term loan that we need to keep paying, or we will lose it." The political analyst Lakshya Jain said Democrats need a brand "associated with cost of living almost exclusively."

That is the real test the next few months will set. The first deadline is close: government funding runs out on December 11, while Republicans still control both chambers, and some progressives want to use it as leverage over the Iran war. After January, the House majority will have to choose which bills reach the floor first, how many subpoenas to issue, and whether to send the president bills he might sign or bills he will surely veto.

Holder framed the challenge in a way both wings could accept. "The question now before us is not whether Democrats can win power," he said, "but whether our party will prove worthy of the authority and the trust that the American people have vested in so many of the leaders in this room." Denver showed that Democrats agree on the question. They have not yet agreed on the answer, and voters, by the party's own account, will not wait long for one.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X