Democrats already know they will run the Senate in January. What they do not yet know is how large their majority will be, and the answer now rests on two counts that could hardly be more different. In Mississippi, a state with no recount law, Democrat Scott Colom led Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith by 2,604 votes late Tuesday, according to a wire service tally, with about 97 percent of the expected vote counted. In Alaska, Democrat Mary Peltola led Republican Senator Dan Sullivan by 2,517 first-choice votes, with roughly a quarter of ballots still to be counted and a ranked-choice tabulation set for November 18.
Both leads are smaller than 2,700 votes, and both races are drawing lawyers. Mississippi's fight is over affidavit ballots and a voter roll purge that pushed thousands of people into them. Alaska's fight is over a second candidate named Dan Sullivan, a federal lawsuit that has already been thrown out once, and a voting system that its critics call confusing and its designer calls a safeguard.
The national picture first. Democrats have flipped seven Republican-held Senate seats, in Iowa, Kansas, Maine, North Carolina, Ohio, South Carolina and Texas, which gives them at least 54 seats against 44 for Republicans with two races uncalled. If Mr. Colom and Ms. Peltola both hold on, the chamber would stand at 56 to 44, and Democrats would have gone nine for nine in the seats they flipped. The difference between 54 and 56 is not cosmetic. It decides how many Democratic defections a majority leader can absorb on nominations, and how strong a base Democrats carry into a 2028 map.
Mississippi was never supposed to be on that list. Mr. Trump won it by 23 points in 2024, and analysts rated the race likely Republican. The state has not elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1982, when it returned John Stennis. If Mr. Colom's lead survives, he would also be the first Black senator from Mississippi since Blanche K. Bruce, whose term ended in 1881.
Mr. Colom, 43, is a district attorney from Columbus. In 2022 President Joe Biden nominated him to a federal judgeship with the backing of several leading Mississippi Republicans, and Ms. Hyde-Smith blocked the nomination. His campaign took off in October with an advertisement mocking the senator's earlier remark, on a local television station, that shoppers facing high beef prices had "so many proteins to choose from." National Democratic groups followed with money, including $2.2 million from the main Senate Democratic super PAC. Preliminary estimates published by a major American newspaper found that Mr. Colom ran 19 points better among white Mississippi voters than Kamala Harris did in 2024.
The count itself has moved in one direction. On election night, Mr. Colom's lead was a few dozen votes. It passed 2,000 by November 6 and has hovered near 2,600 since. Tuesday at 5 p.m. was the last chance for voters who cast affidavit ballots to return with a photo ID and "cure" them, and the last day for mailed ballots postmarked by Election Day to arrive. Counties must certify their results by Friday, November 13. The secretary of state declares the final result on December 3.
The decisive remaining batch is in Hinds County, which includes Jackson and is the state's largest county. Mr. Colom won about 79 percent of the vote there, according to a Mississippi nonprofit newsroom. A lawyer for the county told that newsroom the results of its outstanding affidavit ballots were expected to be uploaded on Wednesday. Mr. Colom says Hinds should settle the matter. "If she thinks she truly has the ability to win, explain how," he said of the senator on Tuesday. Ms. Hyde-Smith, who returned to Washington this week, told reporters only that she was "feeling very optimistic." The state Republican chairman, Mike Hurst, has argued that many outstanding ballots sit in Republican-leaning counties.
Why are there so many affidavit ballots? The answer lies in how Mississippi checks its voter rolls. Under a 2023 state law, the secretary of state's office signed a $50,000 contract in December 2024 with Experian, the credit reporting company, to flag voters who may have moved, and began using it statewide in July 2025. By Election Day, about 230,000 registrations were marked inactive, according to a Mississippi nonprofit newsroom. Voters who had been wrongly flagged had to cast affidavit ballots. The secretary of state's office reported processing 15,547 affidavit ballots, with about 76 percent accepted. Experian itself has said its service "was not designed or intended to validate voter records."
That is where the legal fight begins. Lawyers for Ms. Hyde-Smith wrote to all 82 counties demanding that affidavit ballots be kept separate from regular and absentee ballots, that each ballot's handling be documented and that all custody records be preserved. Their letter cited a state statute on post-election handling of ballot boxes and said the senator was "entitled to their preservation in an unaltered and identifiable state." Mr. Colom's campaign answered with its own letter calling the demand "unlawful and extraordinary" and warning county officials that following it "will violate Mississippi voters' rights." It argued that once an affidavit ballot is accepted and counted, keeping it apart from other ballots would undermine the secrecy of the vote. Mr. Hurst called the request standard procedure in a close race.
Because Mississippi has no recount law and no automatic recount, the path for a trailing candidate is unusual. After certification, a candidate could ask a judge for a county-by-county review supported by evidence, or ask the U.S. Senate itself to examine the result. The law sets out no clear procedure for such a contest, one reason both sides hired lawyers early. So far, monitors say the process has been orderly; an NAACP lawyer watching affidavit reviews said he had not had to "set foot in a courtroom."
One episode has raised questions. On Monday, the day before the cure deadline, Attorney General Todd Blanche visited Jackson City Hall to announce a $64 million public safety grant. Police closed streets around the building, which sits across from the Hinds County circuit clerk's office where voters were returning to show identification. Organizers from voting rights groups said some voters were turned away or were afraid to leave their cars. No official has explained the timing of the visit, and there is no public evidence about how many voters, if any, failed to cure ballots as a result.
Alaska's race is a different kind of close. After a ballot release on Monday night, Ms. Peltola had 106,321 first-choice votes, or 48.6 percent, to Mr. Sullivan's 103,804, or 47.5 percent. Her lead had sat at 637 votes for days before that release. Republican Gerald Heikes had 4,865 votes and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher, had 3,651. Mailed ballots postmarked by Election Day can arrive through November 13 and overseas ballots through November 18. If no one passes 50 percent, the state runs its ranked-choice tabulation that day, eliminating the last-place candidate and moving those ballots to each voter's next choice until someone has a majority. Certification is scheduled for November 25.
Each side says the later rounds favor it. Mr. Sullivan and Mr. Trump have suggested that the Republican would pick up more second-choice support. Ms. Peltola's campaign manager, Cheryl Bruce, said after Monday's release that "after every vote is counted, it is clear that Mary Peltola will be elected."
The second Sullivan is the reason Alaska has a legal story at all. Republicans, including Governor Mike Dunleavy, allege that Daniel J. Sullivan entered the race to siphon votes from the incumbent, and a major American newspaper reported on what critics now call the "Decoy Dan" candidacy. He has denied coordinating with the Peltola campaign, and state courts, including the Alaska Supreme Court, ruled that he could run. On the ballot, the senator appears as "Dan S. Sullivan" with "incumbent" and "registered Republican" beside his name, while the other candidate is listed as "Daniel J. Sullivan Jr." with no label.
Before Election Day, the Justice Department sued to delay certification if the senator narrowly lost and votes for the other Sullivan could have changed the result. It also asked that those ballots be set aside so the government could examine voters' intent. On November 1, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case for lack of standing. "The absence of any explanation from the United States as to how its requested relief could redress its alleged injury while simultaneously maintaining the secrecy of the ballot is telling," she wrote. The department filed a notice of appeal to the Ninth Circuit within about an hour. A federal prosecutor in Alaska has also confirmed a criminal investigation connected to the candidacy, and Mr. Dunleavy said on Sunday that state reviews were looking for anything "that might resemble perjury."
Whether any of this changes the outcome is doubtful on the current numbers. Under ranked-choice rules, a voter confused by the two names who ranked both men first and second would see the ballot move to the senator once the minor candidate is eliminated. Scott Kendall, the Anchorage lawyer who wrote the 2020 measure that created the system, said ranked-choice voting "neutralizes the impacts of schemes and spoiler candidates" and that the ballots counted so far "show minimal confusion." State records show that overvoted ballots, where two candidates are marked at the same rank, were 499 of about 266,800 in the 2022 Senate race. The other Sullivan's vote total is larger than the current margin, but it would matter only if large numbers of his voters failed to rank anyone else and had meant to choose the senator.
What should readers watch? In Mississippi, the Hinds County upload expected Wednesday, the county certifications due Friday and any court filing that follows. If Mr. Colom's lead grows once Hinds reports, the room for a successful challenge narrows sharply. If it shrinks, the affidavit ballot fight becomes the main event. In Alaska, the ballot releases expected Friday and next Wednesday, the ranked-choice tabulation on November 18 and any emergency motion in the Justice Department's appeal.
Beyond the arithmetic, the two counts test the same principle from opposite ends. In Mississippi, a purge built on commercial data sent tens of thousands of voters into a slower, more fragile kind of ballot, and the question is whether those ballots will be counted and left alone. In Alaska, the federal government has tried to look behind ballots to divine what voters meant, and a judge has said it could not do so without breaking ballot secrecy. Whatever the margins, both show how much of an election is now decided after the polls close.
