Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Fighter or Floor Manager: Inside the Scalise-Jordan Rematch for the House GOP

2026-11-09 · Washington Eye Team

Official portraits of Rep. Steve Scalise (US House Office of Photography, public domain) and Rep. Jim Jordan (United States Congress, public domain), via Wikimedia Commons, edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

One week after the worst night House Republicans have endured in decades, the people who survived it will file into a closed room on Capitol Hill on Tuesday afternoon and choose who speaks for them for the next two years. The choice is between two men they have known for a long time and have already measured against each other once: Steve Scalise of Louisiana, the sitting majority leader, and Jim Jordan of Ohio, the chairman of the Judiciary Committee.

The ballot is secret. The winner needs a simple majority of the Republicans who will serve in the 120th Congress, which one Capitol Hill newsletter put at around 82 votes. Both camps described the contest on Sunday as tight. Whoever wins becomes minority leader in January, the Republican face of the House opposition to a Democratic majority that, by the latest counts, holds at least 254 seats with 19 races still uncalled.

In October 2023, after Kevin McCarthy was removed as speaker, Mr. Scalise beat Mr. Jordan in a secret-ballot conference vote for the speaker nomination, then withdrew a day later when it became clear he could not win on the House floor. Mr. Jordan tried and failed next. Mike Johnson emerged only after weeks of infighting. Three years later the two runners-up are back, and the question in front of the conference is less about personality than about what a party in the wilderness needs most: a manager or a fighter.

The opening came from Mr. Johnson himself. On the morning after the election he told his staff on a call that he would not seek the minority leader post, and one report said he cited the toll the job had taken on his family. His public statement struck a defiant note. "While the outcome of this midterm is not what we'd hoped and fought for, a new battle is just beginning," he said, warning that the incoming Democratic majority would be "led by the most radical and extreme leftists in American history."

The mood among his members was harsher. Republicans woke up "in shock," one news site reported, and within hours the shock had turned to anger. Representative Greg Steube of Florida posted a message to his own leaders on a social media platform: "Please do us all a favor and step aside so new leadership can take a truly conservative direction." Another Republican lawmaker, speaking anonymously, put it more simply: "When you have the worst defeat in modern history, you need a new playbook."

"Iran, Iran, Iran ... we should have never done the war before the midterms," one Republican told a reporter. Another pointed to "Iran, ICE, inflation, fuel prices, lack of focus on pocketbook issues." Neither candidate for leader has publicly blamed the president, and that matters. Both men are known on Capitol Hill as close allies of Donald Trump, and neither has put daylight between himself and the White House in announcing his bid.

Mr. Scalise, 61, is in his 10th term and has spent more than a decade in the leadership. His case is stability, and he makes it without apology. In an interview on Sunday he said members were "moving toward" him and described a new regime of discipline for a conference that has often refused to follow its own leaders. "We've got to start acting like a team if we're going to be a team," he said. "I know how to build teams, but also we need a level of accountability."

His second argument is electoral. Republicans will not get the majority back, he said, without winning the swing seats they just lost, and he claimed he could campaign in "any district, the most ruby red or the most swing." The implied contrast with Mr. Jordan, a hero to the conservative grassroots and a lightning rod for Democrats, did not need to be spelled out. A person familiar with his plans described him to reporters as "a proven and tested leader who is ready on day one."

Mr. Scalise's biography also carries weight inside the conference. In 2017 he was shot by a gunman at a Republican congressional baseball practice and suffered serious injuries. He was later diagnosed with multiple myeloma, a blood cancer, and said in 2024 that he was in remission.

He also holds structural advantages. His team has run and won several leadership races, and Republican leaders on Friday evening introduced a new steering committee map that, according to one detailed account, gives considerable influence to his traditional power base in the South: six of the 19 regional seats are held by four Southern states.

His weakness is the one Mr. Steube identified. Mr. Scalise was part of the leadership team that presided over the defeat. Several House Republicans warned before the election that a heavy loss would fuel calls for an entirely new slate, and one report said every member of the current leadership now faces a challenger.

Mr. Jordan, 62, offers the change that Mr. Scalise cannot. He was not in the leadership during the 119th Congress, which spares him direct blame for its decisions. A co-founder of the House Freedom Caucus and a former college wrestler who later coached the sport, he was for years considered too much of a firebrand to lead the whole conference. He has spent the past week trying to show otherwise. He said on Sunday that he had spoken with "just about" every House Republican, some of them several times.

His pitch is that the minority will be defined by one fight above all: the coming wave of Democratic investigations. "I am battle-tested on the oversight front and I know the Democrats' playbook," he wrote in a letter to colleagues. "For too long, we have operated without a clear plan to survive the hour or the day in front of us. That will not cut it against an emboldened and energetic Democrat majority." He defended Mr. Trump through both first-term impeachments, often in combative television appearances the president praised.

That record is the core of his appeal. Representative Jamie Raskin of Maryland, likely the next chairman of the Judiciary Committee, said in September that "there's a long list of potentially impeachable offenses" involving the president, his family and his inner circle. One Republican source told a Capitol Hill outlet that the president "should want a warrior like Jordan with impeachment experience in charge." Representative Andy Harris of Maryland, the current Freedom Caucus chairman, endorsed Mr. Jordan in a television interview, calling him "the type of communicator we need" against what he described as a Democratic majority dominated by the party's democratic socialist wing.

Mr. Jordan has tried to sound forward-looking rather than vengeful. "We can't dwell on all this stuff in the past," he said on Sunday. "We got to think about what comes next and how we build our party back over the next two years." To the charge that he cannot compete in moderate districts, he said he has campaigned in swing seats too. "After Tuesday, we're all battle-tested," he said.

He carries a liability that has followed him for years: questions about what he knew of sexual abuse by a team doctor at Ohio State University when he worked there as an assistant wrestling coach beginning in the 1980s. He has repeatedly denied knowing about the abuse, and several Republicans said in 2023 that the issue had not affected their support.

The president, whose word could still move votes, has so far kept his distance. Mr. Trump told reporters at the White House on the day after the election that he intended to stay out of the race. On election night, asked about Mr. Johnson, he offered praise but no endorsement: "They're going to have to make that decision." With both candidates loyal to him, either outcome keeps the conference close to the White House. The real difference is in tone and method.

For conservatives trying to rebuild, the choice exposes a genuine tension. A minority party has two jobs. It must make the case against the majority, loudly and daily, and it must win back the voters it lost. Mr. Jordan is the stronger candidate for the first job. Few Republicans are more effective in a hearing room or a television studio, and the next two years will be full of both. Mr. Scalise is the stronger candidate for the second. He is a vote counter and a coalition manager in a conference that has struggled, in the words of one Capitol Hill newsletter, even to pass a rule this week.

The lame-duck calendar will test whoever wins before he takes office. Representative Thomas Massie of Kentucky, a Republican who lost his primary, is expected to force a floor vote by Wednesday on impeaching Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. Government funding runs out after Dec. 11, and Iran war spending has become the central dispute. The annual defense bill and the expired farm bill are still pending.

The races further down the ballot will shape the result as much as the top one. Majority Whip Tom Emmer of Minnesota is defending his post against Representative August Pfluger of Texas, the outgoing chairman of the Republican Study Committee, though Mr. Emmer's allies believe he has the votes. Representatives Brian Jack of Georgia and Rudy Yakym of Indiana are competing to run the party's House campaign arm, whose current chairman, Richard Hudson of North Carolina, was on track to lose his own seat. The conference chair, Lisa McClain of Michigan, faces a three-way contest with Representatives Erin Houchin of Indiana and Greg Steube, who had urged the leadership to step aside.

In the Senate, hard-line conservatives led by Senator Ron Johnson of Wisconsin want to delay the Republican leadership elections also set for Tuesday, though Majority Leader John Thune plans to go ahead. House Democrats vote on Nov. 18, when Hakeem Jeffries is expected to win the speaker nomination.

G. William Hoagland, a former Senate Republican leadership aide, told one Capitol Hill publication he takes seriously a prediction from Steve Bannon, the president's former chief strategist, that the party will be engulfed in a civil war over its future. "Expect that civil war to play out over the next couple of weeks," Mr. Hoagland said.

Tuesday's vote is the first battle in that war. If Republicans choose Mr. Scalise, they are betting that the road back runs through discipline and the swing seats they lost. If they choose Mr. Jordan, they are betting that a party out of power earns its way back by fighting, starting with the investigations already being planned for 2027. Either way, the conference will have answered a question it dodged in 2023, and it will have to live with the answer through the next presidential campaign.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X