Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Four Points From Shenzhen. Not One Mentions Ukraine

2026-11-19 · Washington Eye Team

An oil refinery in Groves, Texas, near Port Arthur; the Shenzhen declaration pledges more refined petroleum products for world markets (photo: Carol M. Highsmith, Library of Congress, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

The first meeting in history between an American president, a Chinese leader and a Russian president, with nobody else at the table, lasted about an hour and a half. What it produced fits on a single page. After President Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin rose from a round table at a lakeside villa in Shenzhen on Thursday, Beijing and Moscow released a short text titled the "Declaration toward Peace." It has four numbered points: reform of the United Nations, more refined petroleum for world markets, a warning to the International Criminal Court, and a promise to talk about nuclear risk.

What it does not contain is just as telling. The word Ukraine appears nowhere in it. Nor does Iran, the Strait of Hormuz, Taiwan, trade, tariffs or artificial intelligence. For a summit that Mr Trump had promoted as a chance to start resolving the wars in Ukraine and Iran and to write new rules for nuclear weapons, the document is notable mostly for how carefully it steps around every subject on which the three governments disagree.

That does not make it meaningless. Read closely, the four points reveal where Washington, Beijing and Moscow have found common ground, and the answer is not always reassuring for American allies.

What the three leaders actually signed

The opening paragraph says the three heads of state "had an in-depth exchange of views on the current international situation and committed to maintaining strategic stability and international security." The Russian and American presidents, it adds, thanked China for hosting what it calls a "historic trilateral Summit."

The first point commits the three permanent members of the Security Council to reform the United Nations so it can "respond more effectively to global challenges." It gives no detail on what that reform would be. The second says the three countries "plan to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products for the benefit of all nations" and reaffirms "the importance of stable energy flows." The third declares the principle of state consent and the immunity of state officials to be "of paramount importance" and says the International Criminal Court and similar bodies "must not abuse their jurisdiction." The fourth repeats the old formula that "a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought" and announces a dialogue "on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons."

The text was released by the Kremlin and by China's official news agency, and the two English versions match word for word apart from the order in which each lists the three countries.

The nuclear line is old, and still worth having

The fourth point is the one arms control experts had hoped for, and the one most likely to be described in Washington as a win. The sentence about nuclear war was first agreed by Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev in 1985, when the two superpowers agreed on almost nothing else. It created no inspections and cut no warheads, but it gave both sides a shared premise from which later treaties grew.

Repeating it now matters because the last binding limits are gone. New START, the final treaty capping American and Russian strategic arsenals, expired in February after Russia had already suspended its participation. China, which has refused to join any three-way talks on the grounds that its arsenal is far smaller, is expanding its stockpile quickly. Mr Trump opened the meeting by arguing that the three countries, "as the world's three largest nuclear powers by far," were "uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on earth." Mr Xi, according to a state media translation, went further and called for such weapons to be comprehensively prohibited and destroyed.

Yet the commitment itself is modest: a dialogue, with no date, no venue and no named negotiators. The text says nothing about warhead numbers, testing, or verification. Mr Trump himself conceded in his opening remarks that reducing nuclear weapons is "a very hard thing" to do. The declaration confirms that all three governments accept the premise. It does not show that any of them is ready to pay the price of acting on it.

The ICC clause is the real surprise

The most consequential line may be the third. The United States, China and Russia are all outside the International Criminal Court, and Washington has already imposed sanctions on it. The court has an outstanding arrest warrant for Mr Putin, issued in March 2023 over the alleged deportation of children from occupied parts of Ukraine. Its warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his former defence minister, issued in November 2024, hardened American opposition further.

In his opening remarks, Mr Trump attacked what he called "rogue globalist organizations," naming the court, and said it had "gotten out of control." He said he would propose joint measures with China and Russia to protect national sovereignty from it. The declaration turns that impulse into a signed statement that "respect for immunities of State officials" is of "paramount importance."

For Moscow, that wording is a diplomatic prize. It puts an American president's name beside a principle that, in practice, shields a Russian leader who is wanted by the court. Supporters of the administration will argue that the clause simply restates a long American position: the United States never accepted the court's authority over its citizens or its allies. Critics will note that Washington has now endorsed that position alongside the one head of state whose warrant arises directly from the war that the summit was supposed to help end. Both readings are accurate, and the clause will likely be debated on Capitol Hill long after the summit photographs fade.

Oil, and the war nobody named

The second point is the most concrete economic pledge, though it sets no volumes or timelines. Before the trilateral, sitting down with Mr Xi, Mr Trump said that both of them felt strongly that oil had to keep flowing through the Strait of Hormuz, where shipping has been disrupted by the Iran war. Mr Putin, whose country is one of the world's largest exporters of crude oil and fuel, told the meeting that the three powers should discuss energy security and food security. The final text speaks of "stable energy flows" without naming Hormuz or Iran. It also says nothing about Western sanctions on Russian oil.

Ukraine is the starker omission. Mr Putin arrived in Shenzhen after a setback on the battlefield, the crippling of a key bridge linking Crimea to Russia, and told the room that the three countries share interests in "the settlement of regional conflicts, including obviously the conflict in Ukraine." Mr Trump held a separate meeting with Mr Putin before the trilateral, called him a "friend," and said afterwards that the war was "pretty much what the discussion was about, and I think things are happening." The Kremlin said Mr Putin left that meeting in an "excellent" mood.

None of that made it into writing. Beijing had signalled for days that it did not want Ukraine on the trilateral agenda, and Mr Xi did not mention the war in his public remarks. Ukraine was not represented in Shenzhen, a point Washington Eye noted when the summit was first announced. The result is a peace declaration that is silent on the largest war in Europe since 1945.

Taiwan, on the sidelines

The most sensitive exchange of the day happened outside the trilateral. After his one on one meeting with Mr Trump, Mr Xi said that "on the Taiwan issue, the United States must keep doing the right thing to avoid the emergence of great turbulence in the China-US relationship." China's official news agency reported that Mr Trump told him Washington "does not support 'Taiwan independence.'" Taiwan's defence ministry, meanwhile, reported two Russian military aircraft flying to the island's east on Thursday.

What to watch next

Three questions will decide whether Shenzhen is remembered as a turning point or a photo opportunity. First, whether the promised nuclear dialogue acquires a date, a level and an agenda in the coming weeks, or simply fades. Second, what the United States does with the ICC language: whether it moves to coordinate new measures against the court with Beijing and Moscow, as Mr Trump suggested, and how European allies who are members of the court respond. Third, whether any concrete step on Ukraine follows from the separate Trump and Putin conversation, given that none was written down.

Mr Trump framed the whole exercise as a break with leaders who avoided talking to rivals. "No peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement," he said at the start. The declaration shows that engagement happened. It also shows its limits. On the issues where the three powers already agree, they signed their names. On the wars that brought them to the table, they wrote nothing at all.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X