On Wednesday, the day after his own party buried his attempt to impeach the defense secretary, Representative Thomas Massie of Kentucky got the number he wanted. "This morning we reached the required 218 signatures on my discharge petition for Epstein Files Transparency Act II," he wrote in a post online. The last two names belonged to Democrats, Adam Smith of Washington and John Garamendi of California. That detail is the problem.
Of the 218 members who signed, 214 are Democrats, every one of them in the House. Only four are Republicans: Massie himself, Nancy Mace and Ralph Norman of South Carolina, and Brian Fitzpatrick of Pennsylvania. All four are on their way out of the chamber. In other words, not a single Republican who expects to sit in the next Congress has put a name to a bill whose central idea, that a federal agency should face consequences when it ignores a law, is about as conservative as legislation gets.
That is a mistake, and it is one Republicans still have time to correct when the bill reaches the floor.
What the bill actually does. The first Epstein Files Transparency Act, signed by President Trump on November 19, 2025, after the House passed it 427 to 1, ordered the Justice Department to publish its unclassified records on Jeffrey Epstein within 30 days. It had two working parts, one ordering the release and one requiring a report to Congress. It had no enforcement mechanism at all.
The sequel, H.R. 9694, fills that gap. It would let state attorneys general, district attorneys and other authorised state officials, members of Congress and Epstein's victims sue the attorney general in federal court for unlawfully withholding, delaying, redacting or failing to publish covered records, either in Washington or in their home state, with cases moved quickly. Victims would get the right to see the full, unredacted records about themselves, including the FBI interview summaries known as FD-302s, although the department could still black out details identifying other victims. State and local prosecutors would get unredacted records they need for their own cases, with secure access to classified material, without going through the department's usual process for outside requests. The bill would also bar the department from leaning on common law privileges, such as the deliberative process privilege, to avoid the original law's disclosure rules, and would make clear that officials who knowingly conceal, destroy or falsify covered files face existing federal criminal penalties.
Massie wrote it with two Democrats, Ro Khanna of California and Teresa Leger Fernández of New Mexico. Senators Jeff Merkley of Oregon and Ben Ray Luján of New Mexico, also Democrats, carry the Senate version. That roster explains some of the Republican reluctance. It does not justify it.
The department's record. The Justice Department missed the December 19, 2025 deadline. In January it announced that it had published nearly 3.5 million pages, with more than 2,000 videos and 180,000 images, and said more than 500 attorneys and reviewers had worked on the release. It said anything not produced was a duplicate, was withheld under deliberative process or attorney client privilege, fell under the law's exception for depictions of violence, or was unrelated to the Epstein and Maxwell cases. It insisted that reviewers were told to limit redactions to protecting victims and their families, and that "notable individuals and politicians were not redacted."
Massie does not accept that account. "Since the Epstein Files Transparency Act was signed into law on November 19, 2025, the Department of Justice has flagrantly and consistently ignored EFTA's disclosure requirements," he said when he introduced the bill. "The Department of Justice continues to unlawfully withhold over 3 million Epstein files that should be released to the public."
Conservatives can argue about his count. What they cannot wave away is what their own side found. On Tuesday the Republican majority on the House Oversight Committee, under Chairman James Comer of Kentucky, released the result of a 15-month investigation built on 19 transcribed interviews and depositions. It concluded that the crimes Epstein committed after 2005 could have been prevented if not for failures by federal investigators and prosecutors in South Florida and Washington, starting with the 2007 non-prosecution agreement that let him plead to lesser state charges. And it found that, after the 2025 law took effect, the department "failed to adequately communicate about document releases and failed to sufficiently protect survivors," with deficient redactions that exposed survivors' sensitive personal information.
Among the committee's recommendations: the department should give survivors and their representatives a process to see their own files in unredacted form. That is one of the core provisions of the Massie bill. "The federal government has failed the survivors of Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell's horrific crimes for decades," Comer said.
The state attorneys general who back the bill go further. In a letter in October, New York Attorney General Letitia James and 16 colleagues told congressional leaders that the personal information of at least 43 victims was exposed in the released files, and that millions of documents remain withheld, often on grounds of privilege. Her office also says that in a case in federal court in Washington, Phang v. Blanche, the court noted that the attorney general had conceded he was in violation of the first law.
Why this is a conservative cause. For two decades the American right has made one argument about Washington more consistently than any other: federal agencies, left to police themselves, protect themselves. Republicans have said it about the Internal Revenue Service, about the FBI's handling of politically sensitive investigations, about agencies that answer requests from Congress late, partially or not at all. The remedy they have usually proposed is the one in this bill: give someone outside the agency the standing to drag it into court.
A transparency law with no way to enforce it is not much of a law. It is a request. Congress made that request almost unanimously last year, the president signed it, and nearly a year later the department's critics say it has not been met in full, while a Republican chairman's report says the department failed to protect survivors in carrying it out. If a statute passed 427 to 1 can be slow-walked without consequence, every future disclosure law will be written in the knowledge that it can be, too.
There is also a federalism case that ought to appeal to the party of the Tenth Amendment. The bill does not hand new power to Washington. It hands it to state prosecutors, who would get the records they need to pursue crimes within their own jurisdictions, and to the victims themselves. Conservatives who believe that justice works best close to the people it serves should find that hard to vote against.
The objections are real. They are fixable. There are honest reasons for Republican caution, and they deserve a hearing rather than a sneer. The coalition of attorneys general pushing the bill is led by Letitia James, a Democrat who has been one of the president's most persistent legal adversaries, and a new right to sue could become a vehicle for politically driven litigation against the administration. Giving local prosecutors secure access to classified material is a significant step that would need careful handling. A blanket bar on deliberative process privilege could reach further than its authors intend. And the more hands that hold unredacted files, the greater the risk that a victim's name ends up somewhere it should not, the very harm the Oversight Committee has already documented.
There is the political objection, too. A spokesperson, Lauren Bis, said in a statement that the president has "been totally exonerated on anything relating to Epstein," and argued that by releasing documents, cooperating with the Oversight Committee's subpoena and signing the first law, he "has done more for Epstein's victims than anyone before him." The committee's report backs the central part of that claim: it said the facts gathered in its investigation do not suggest President Trump is implicated in any of Epstein's or Maxwell's crimes, and that it found no documents implicating him in any related criminal activity.
But that finding cuts in favour of the bill, not against it. If the committee is right, Republicans have nothing to fear from fuller disclosure and a great deal to gain from owning it. The narrow concerns can be addressed the way legislators always address them: by tightening the standing provisions, by setting firm protocols for classified access, by narrowing the privilege language, by writing in stronger penalties for anyone who exposes a victim's identity. Those are amendments. They are not reasons to let four departing members carry the party's name on an issue the public cares about.
The clock, and the choice. Under House rules, the petition now sits on the discharge calendar for seven legislative days. After that, any signer can call it up, the speaker must schedule it within two legislative days, and the House debates the discharge motion for 20 minutes before voting. If the motion carries, the House takes up the rule, H.Res. 1430, which provides an hour of debate split between the leaders of the Judiciary Committee and then a final vote, with the bill sent to the Senate within a day of passage. With the Thanksgiving recess intervening, floor action could come as early as December 2 or 3, although leaders could bring the bill up sooner if they chose.
Republican leaders are not in a mood to reward this kind of manoeuvre. House Republicans are discussing new conference rules that could discipline members who undermine party leaders, a debate driven partly by members who used discharge petitions to go around them, according to reporting by a Washington political news site. Discharge petitions, once rare, have succeeded eight times in this Congress. Leaders understandably see them as a threat to their control of the floor.
Yet the politics of the next two years point the other way. After this month's midterm losses, Republicans will hand the speaker's gavel to Democrats in January, and Senate Republicans expect to lead from the minority as well. If this bill dies in the lame duck, it will almost certainly come back under Democratic management, with Democrats writing every line and Republicans cast as the party that stood between survivors and their own records. If Republicans vote for it now and improve it in the Senate, they get to shape its limits and share its credit.
Massie, who leaves the House when this Congress ends, does not need the votes for his career. His colleagues who are staying might need them for theirs. The Oversight Committee's chairman has already told them, in a report with his party's name on it, that the federal government failed these women for decades. The least the party can do is give them a way to make the government answer for it.
