Sixteen billion dollars has not moved since the spring of 2025. The money, awarded by the Environmental Protection Agency in the final months of the Biden administration to a group of nonprofit clean energy lenders, sits in accounts at Citibank, the bank the government hired to pay it out. A federal appeals court order still in force says that no party may take "any action, directly or indirectly, with regard to the disputed contracts, grants, awards or funds."
Now the Trump administration wants the Supreme Court to break the deadlock. In a petition filed on November 2, Solicitor General D. John Sauer asked the justices to overturn a ruling by the full US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit that stopped the EPA from cancelling the grants. Citibank, caught in the middle, has filed a petition of its own. The case, Zeldin v. Climate United Fund, has been described as the largest grant cancellation case ever, and the questions it raises reach far beyond climate policy.
Here is how the money got stuck, what each side argues, and five things to watch as the justices decide whether to take the case.
How $27 billion became a lawsuit
In 2022 Congress passed, and President Joe Biden signed, the Inflation Reduction Act. Among its spending lines was $27 billion for a new Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund at the EPA. The law said the agency would "make grants" so that recipients could invest in projects that cut greenhouse gas emissions, with most of the money earmarked for "low-income and disadvantaged communities." The model is often called a green bank: public money used to unlock private lending for clean energy and efficiency projects.
In August 2024 the EPA awarded about $20 billion of that money to eight nonprofits. According to the government, several of them were formed specifically to apply for it. Rather than keep the undisbursed money in the Treasury, the government placed it with Citibank as its financial agent, to be released as grantees incurred costs. Five of those nonprofits, which together received more than $16 billion, are the main plaintiffs today, joined by four subgrantees of one of them.
After the 2024 election, the government says, the outgoing EPA leadership amended the grant agreements in ways that made them harder to cancel, including by removing the agency's express power to end grants that no longer fit its priorities. It also changed the account agreements so that Citibank would keep paying out in certain circumstances. The government's petition quotes one outgoing EPA official likening the rush to "throwing gold bars off the Titanic."
The new leadership under Administrator Lee Zeldin reviewed the program and said it found conflicts of interest, political connections among the grantees, weak oversight and pass-through structures that moved money down to subgrantees and then to sub-subgrantees. Among the examples the government cites: a former director of the fund who had personally overseen a $5 billion grant to his previous employer, and a nonprofit with ties to a prominent Democratic official that received $2 billion after reporting $100 in revenue the year before. On March 11, 2025, the EPA sent termination notices citing "substantial concerns regarding program integrity, the award process, programmatic fraud, waste, and abuse, and misalignment with the Agency's priorities." It said it would put the money back to work with more oversight.
The grantees sued in federal district court in Washington. They argued that the terminations violated the Administrative Procedure Act, federal grant rules, the Inflation Reduction Act and the separation of powers. In April 2025 a district judge blocked the cancellations, finding that the EPA had "failed to explain its reasoning and acted contrary to its regulations." The appeals court quickly froze the money in place, and that freeze has held ever since.
A law repealed, a court split
Then Congress changed the facts. In July 2025 President Donald Trump signed the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which repealed the provision that created the fund and rescinded its unobligated balances. The money already awarded to the grantees stayed frozen in its accounts, and the lawsuit went on.
In September 2025 a three-judge panel of the D.C. Circuit sided with the administration, two votes to one. Judge Neomi Rao, joined by Judge Gregory Katsas, wrote that the grantees' claims were "essentially contractual and therefore must be heard in the Court of Federal Claims," the specialised court that handles money disputes with the federal government. Judge Cornelia Pillard dissented. In December the full court agreed to rehear the case and set the panel ruling aside.
The full court's judgment, issued on August 4, 2026, is a study in fracture. Ten judges took part. Six voted to uphold the heart of the injunction, the part that bars the EPA from carrying out its termination notices. Their reason was the Inflation Reduction Act itself. By trying to end the grants and claw back money already paid out "based solely on a policy disagreement" with the law, the court said, the EPA "likely contravened the IRA's mandatory appropriation."
Four judges, Chief Judge Sri Srinivasan and Judges Katsas, Rao and Justin Walker, would have lifted that part of the order. In their view, once Congress repealed the fund, the EPA likely could end the grants without breaking that law. The chief judge added that, but for the repeal, he would have voted to keep the injunction. On the rest of the order, including the ban on future terminations and the instructions to Citibank, the court divided evenly, which left those parts in place without a majority behind them.
What each side says
The administration calls the ruling "manifestly incorrect in multiple respects." Its main argument is about the forum, not about climate. Under the Tucker Act, a law dating to the nineteenth century, claims founded on contracts with the United States belong in the Court of Federal Claims, which can award money damages but cannot order the government to keep a deal alive. The grantees, the government says, are bringing "a classic contract claim" and seeking "the classic contract remedy of specific performance." No plaintiff, it argues, should be able "to compel the United States" to keep performing a contract "rather than pay ordinary damages for any breach."
Its second argument goes to the merits. The provision the appeals court relied on, the government says, "simply appropriates money for EPA 'to make grants,'" and nothing in it stopped the agency from ending them. Because Congress has since repealed it, the petition adds, "there is no statute left for the preliminary injunction to enforce." The solicitor general also warns that the question carries "potential implications for billions of dollars across dozens of other grant programs" that Congress repealed at the same time.
The grantees see a different case. The judges who have sided with them accepted that the nonprofits were not asking for damages but, in the district court's words, for "access to funds they are presently entitled to." Judge Pillard, in her panel dissent, described the claim as one for the "recovery of property that is lawfully theirs." The Coalition for Green Capital, one of the plaintiffs, has said the terminations threatened projects meant to lower electricity costs, create jobs and improve clean air and water. The grantees' formal answers to the petitions are due on December 15.
Five things to watch
1. The calendar. The Coalition for Green Capital asked for 30 more days to respond, which would have pushed its brief into January. The government objected, saying that would delay the case to the court's February 19, 2027, conference and "effectively prevent the Court from hearing the cases this Term absent expedited merits briefing." It asked that no extension run past December 8. On November 12 the court split the difference and gave every respondent until December 15. Whether the justices can still hear and decide the case before their summer break is the first thing to watch.
2. Whether this becomes the test case. Twice in 2025, in short emergency orders in Department of Education v. California and NIH v. American Public Health Association, the Supreme Court signalled that claims "based on" federal grants likely belong in the Court of Federal Claims. Lower courts remain "sharply divided" anyway, the government says, listing rulings on both sides. The Fourth Circuit has sent similar claims to the claims court; district judges elsewhere have kept hearing them in disputes over research money, education funding and transit grants. A full ruling here could settle a question that hangs over dozens of cases.
3. What a repeal does to money already awarded. Five of the appeals judges thought the repeal likely did not reach funds already obligated and paid out to the grantees. Four thought it freed the EPA to act. That disagreement matters for every program Congress cancels after the money has gone out, and it is the second question the government has asked the justices to answer.
4. The bank in the middle. Citibank holds the money and was ordered by the district court to resume payments, an order that has never taken effect because of the appeals court freeze. Its own petition sits on the docket beside the government's. How the justices treat a private bank caught between a federal agency and its grantees could shape how future administrations route public money through outside agents.
5. The politics around the money. Democrats won full control of Congress in this month's midterm elections, but reviving the fund would take a new law that Mr. Trump would have to sign. For now, the fate of the $16 billion runs through the courts, not through Capitol Hill.
It takes four justices to agree to hear a case. If they do, the court will be deciding more than whether a set of climate lenders keep their money. It will be deciding who gets to sue when Washington walks away from a grant, and in which courtroom. If they decline, the appeals court's split decision stands, and the money stays where it has been for more than a year and a half: frozen, and fought over.
