Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Hold the Line on Prices: The Conservative Case for a December Rate Hike

2026-11-10 · Washington Eye Team

The Marriner S. Eccles Federal Reserve Board Building in Washington, D.C. (photo: AgnosticPreachersKid, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

Tuesday's inflation report settled an argument the White House would rather keep having. Consumer prices rose 0.4 percent in October, the Labor Department said, a tenth of a point more than forecasters expected. Prices excluding food and energy, the core measure central bankers use to judge the underlying trend, rose 0.3 percent for the third month in a row, also above expectations. The headline figure cooled from September's 0.6 percent mainly because gasoline stopped surging. Almost everything else kept climbing.

For conservatives, the right response is uncomfortable but not complicated. The Federal Reserve should raise interest rates when its policy committee meets on 8 and 9 December, and Republicans in Washington should say plainly that they support the decision. Sound money is not a technocratic preference. It is a conservative principle, and it is about to be tested by a Republican president who has spent two terms demanding cheaper money.

Start with the numbers, because they are broad rather than narrow. Food prices rose 0.5 percent in October, with beef up 0.9 percent. Shelter rose 0.3 percent and accounted for more than 30 percent of the overall increase. Transportation services jumped 0.8 percent and car insurance 0.7 percent. Electricity rose 0.9 percent, a pressure some analysts link to the power demands of the artificial intelligence buildout. The government could not publish a yearly inflation rate this time, because the shutdown a year ago meant no prices were collected in October 2025. The last annual reading, for September, was 3.7 percent. By most counts inflation has now run above the Fed's 2 percent target for roughly five and a half years.

There is one honest caveat on the other side of the ledger. Clothing, a category that is highly exposed to tariffs, rose only 0.1 percent, and used car prices fell 1.2 percent. Not every line in the report is flashing red. But a central bank does not set policy on its best categories. It sets policy on the trend, and the trend has not been moving in the right direction.

The most persuasive voice for action is inside the Fed itself. Speaking in London on Tuesday, hours before the data came out, Governor Christopher Waller did not soften his words. "Let's just say it," he said. "September's inflation data were bad. There was no silver lining." He noted that the Fed's preferred gauge, the personal consumption expenditures price index, was up 3.7 percent over the year to September, and 3.1 percent excluding food and energy. More than 70 percent of the components of core services prices had risen by over 3 percent in a year. That is not a single shock passing through. It is inflation spreading.

Waller also set a clear test. He said he would back a quarter point increase in December even if October improved. If core consumer prices rose by around 0.3 percent or more, he said, a half point increase "should be considered," adding: "Hiking only 25 basis points would put our credibility at risk, a risk I am not eager to take." A few hours later, the core figure came in at exactly that level.

Markets understood the message at once. Traders moved to price a quarter point increase as all but certain and raised the odds of a half point move. The two year Treasury yield, the one most closely tied to expectations for the Fed, was on course for its biggest one day jump since the tariff turmoil of April 2025. The ten year yield, which sets the tone for mortgages and car loans, climbed toward 5 percent. In other words, investors are already charging Americans for inflation risk. The question is whether Washington will reduce that risk or add to it.

The White House response has been mixed. On Election Day, in a telephone interview, President Trump declared: "The inflation is solved." On Tuesday his own top economic adviser, Kevin Hassett, called the new report "disappointing." Speaking in a television interview, Hassett said energy prices were up 20 percent from a year earlier and gasoline 37 percent, and that "the trickle-down from the higher energy prices is definitely very palpable in the data." He deserves credit for candour. That candour now needs to reach the president.

Trump's record on the Fed points the other way. After the central bank raised rates in September for the first time in three years, he called members of its board "hostile" and "partisan." The Fed held its benchmark range at 3.75 to 4 percent in October after what Chairman Kevin Warsh, the man Trump chose to lead it, called "a heck of a family fight." Warsh insisted that politics played no role and that the coming decision would have "nothing to do" with it. Republicans should help him keep that promise rather than make it harder.

Why should conservatives in particular care? Because inflation is a tax that no one votes for. It quietly takes from savers, retirees on fixed incomes and workers whose pay rises lag behind prices. In October, by one widely reported reading of the government's figures, inflation wiped out wage gains for the month, leaving average weekly earnings flat after adjusting for prices. A party that says it speaks for working families cannot shrug at that.

Conservatives also have a recent record to live up to. In 2021 and 2022 they rightly criticised a Federal Reserve that called rising prices temporary and waited too long to act while inflation spread. It would be hard to explain why the same delay is wise now, simply because the occupant of the White House has changed. Principles that only apply to the other party's president are not principles.

History offers a better model. In the early 1980s, Ronald Reagan stood by Paul Volcker while the Fed held rates high enough to break a decade of inflation. The cost was a painful recession, and Republicans paid for it at the polls in 1982. The reward was a long expansion and a generation of stable prices. Nobody is suggesting rates anywhere near those levels today. The point is that a Republican president once chose long term credibility over short term relief, and the country was better for it.

There is also a hard, practical argument. Waller made it in his speech: once the Fed has signalled that higher rates are coming, failing to follow through loosens financial conditions on its own, because markets stop expecting tighter policy. A central bank that is seen to bend to political pressure pays a different price. Investors demand more to hold long term debt, and long term rates rise even if short term rates stay put. For a government that is selling $125 billion of notes and bonds in a single week, and that saw mixed demand at Monday's three year auction, that is not an abstract concern. The fastest way to bring mortgage rates down over time is a Fed that markets trust.

None of this means a hike is free, and conservatives should be honest about the costs. Waller himself described a "low hire, low fire" labour market that is stable but may not be healthy. The share of unemployed Americans who have been looking for work for more than six months has risen above 27 percent, and young people entering the workforce are finding it unusually hard to get hired. Higher rates will make that harder at the margin. Businesses that borrow, families buying homes and a federal government with heavy debts will all feel it.

The strongest objection is that much of today's inflation comes from oil, and interest rates do not pump crude or reopen shipping lanes. The war with Iran has kept energy costs high. Waller noted reports that insurance for tankers crossing the Strait of Hormuz, and the transfers needed to guard against Iranian attacks, are adding $20 to $30 a barrel to oil prices, and that tight refining capacity is keeping diesel expensive. That is a fair point. But Fed research he cited suggests that since the pandemic, energy shocks have been passing into core prices more strongly than before, possibly well into 2027. And October's report showed price increases far beyond the gas pump. A central bank that keeps waiting for supply shocks to fade risks waiting forever.

The Fed cannot carry this alone, and here conservatives have work of their own. Fed officials have said for months that tariffs, along with the war, are feeding into prices. A party that believes in free markets should be working to lower the import taxes Americans pay, not adding new ones. A party that believes in limited government should be serious about the deficits that put upward pressure on borrowing costs. And a party that believes in American energy should keep pushing to make it easier to build pipelines, power plants and transmission lines, so that the next oil shock hurts less.

The politics are not as frightening as they look. Rising prices helped power the Democratic sweep in last week's midterm elections. Republicans will not win those voters back by blaming the Fed for doing its job. They can win them back by being the party that took inflation seriously, backed an independent central bank when it mattered, and cut the costs Washington itself imposes. If they instead join attacks on the Fed, they will own whatever inflation follows, right up to 2028.

The December meeting is four weeks away. Warsh and his colleagues will have more data before then, including another jobs report and new wholesale prices. They should weigh it carefully and decide on the merits. Whatever size they choose, they should raise rates, and Republicans who believe in sound money should stand behind them. Holding the line on prices is not a betrayal of the president's agenda. It is the only way any agenda for working families can succeed.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X