Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Measles Is Back. A Republican Doctor Says Replace RFK Jr.

2026-11-17 · Washington Eye Team

Senator Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, official Senate portrait (photo: United States Congress, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

On Tuesday, the United States officially lost something it had held for a quarter of a century. The Pan American Health Organization announced that measles is once again endemic in the country, meaning the virus has spread in an unbroken chain for more than a year. "The commission concluded that the endemic measles transmission has now been reestablished in Bolivia, Mexico and the United States, and recommended that their measles elimination status be withdrawn, a recommendation which I have accepted," the organization's director, Jarbas Barbosa, told reporters.

The country earned that status in 2000. It took a generation of parents, paediatricians, county health departments and federal officials of both parties to win it. It took less than two years of outbreaks to lose it.

Two days before the announcement, a Republican senator who is also a physician said out loud what many conservatives have been saying only in private. Senator Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, a doctor who chairs the Senate health committee, said in a Sunday television interview that Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is "obviously trying to provide cover for failure." Then he went further. "If I were president, I would choose someone else," he said, "because there needs to be accountability for higher healthcare costs, more measles deaths, losing elimination status, and no progress on processed foods."

Conservatives should take that advice seriously. Not because Democrats are demanding it, but because it is the conservative position.

The numbers behind the verdict

The decision was technical, and it was not close. A commission of eight public health experts spent days in Washington this month reviewing genetic data from cases that had nothing to do with foreign travel, to see whether outbreaks in different states were linked. They were. A senior administration official has said the outbreak in Utah, which began in June 2025, was central to the finding.

More than 5,400 cases have been recorded this year, more than double last year's total and the highest count since 1991. State health departments have reported 10 deaths this year. Across the past two years, researchers at a leading university count more than 830 hospitalisations, at least 13 measles-associated deaths, including a seven-month-old in New York and infants in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, and roughly $125 million in medical care, emergency response and lost work. Of the more than 7,600 confirmed cases since January 2025, only about 3 percent were in people who had been vaccinated.

That last figure is the heart of the matter. Two doses of the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine prevent about 97 percent of infections. When about 95 percent of a community is immunised, the virus runs out of people to infect and outbreaks burn out. National kindergarten coverage has slipped to about 92.4 percent. The gap looks small on paper. In a disease this contagious, it is the difference between a contained outbreak and a national one.

What the administration says

Fairness requires stating the administration's case, and part of it is true. Childhood vaccination rates were falling before the current team took office, and they have been sliding since the pandemic began. An HHS spokesperson attributed the resurgence to gaps that opened years ago. The department says it allocated about $100 million in extra outbreak funding in October and sent experts to help states. Kennedy and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Director Erica Schwartz "continue to recommend MMR vaccination as the most effective way to prevent measles," the department said.

Dr. Schwartz, who has been in the job for about three months, struck the right note. "Losing a designation doesn't mean we abandon an evidence-based approach," she said. "It means we remain focused on stopping outbreaks." A White House spokesperson, Allison Schuster, said the president and the secretary "have repeatedly encouraged measles vaccination, coordinated with states, and facilitated the deployment of vaccine doses across the country."

If that were the whole record, Senator Cassidy would have little to complain about. It is not. The president himself said in August that the MMR vaccine could be "quite lethal," which it is not. Kennedy, who led a prominent anti-vaccine group before taking office, has spent two decades casting doubt on the very shots his department now says it recommends. Under his leadership, the agency's advisory panel on vaccines was restocked with sceptics, staff who worked with pharmacies and community groups to raise vaccination rates were pushed out, and an agency webpage that once said plainly that vaccines do not cause autism was rewritten to suggest a possible link. Career scientists say reports on large outbreaks in South Carolina, Utah and Pennsylvania still have not appeared in the agency's flagship weekly journal. HHS calls any suggestion that it is suppressing measles data "false."

And in January, a senior agency official described losing elimination status as the "cost of doing business" in a connected world. That is not how a serious public health department talks about dead babies.

"No longer any leverage"

What turned frustration into open revolt was something Kennedy said last week. With Democrats about to take control of the Senate, he suggested the gloves were off. "The Senate no longer has any leverage over me," he said, "and that's a big deal. And then we have Stephen Miller in, who's a friend of our movement. And I don't think anything is going to get in our way now."

Every Republican senator who voted to confirm him should read that sentence twice. Senator Cassidy did. He voted to confirm Kennedy last year, and he has since said the secretary broke promises made to him. His reply on Sunday was blunt: "The logic that because Republicans have been there, but now Democrats are in charge, will make it easier for him? There is no logic. This is about covering a series of failures."

A cabinet secretary who boasts that the Senate cannot touch him has misunderstood the Constitution, not just the politics. Advice and consent is not a hurdle to be cleared once and forgotten. Conservatives spent years arguing that unelected officials in Washington had slipped free of accountability. They cannot now cheer when a political appointee announces that he has, too.

This used to be a Republican fight

The saddest part of this story is how recently the right owned it. In 2019, when a large outbreak spread through communities in New York and New Jersey, the Republican chairman of the Senate health committee, Lamar Alexander of Tennessee, did not mince words. "Internet fraudsters who claim that vaccines are not safe are preying on the unfounded fears and daily struggles of parents," he said, "and they are creating a public health hazard that is entirely preventable." Alex Azar, the health secretary in President Trump's first term, stood beside the then CDC director, Robert Redfield, at a press conference stressing the "importance of on-time vaccination."

That was the first Trump administration. It treated measles as a threat to be beaten, not a talking point to be managed. Nothing about conservatism has changed since then. What has changed is who holds the job.

Supporting vaccination is not a concession to big government. The best defence against measles has never been a federal mandate. It is the trust between a mother and her paediatrician, between a pastor and his congregation, between a county nurse and the families on her list. Federal leadership matters because it either strengthens that trust or erodes it. For two years, it has eroded it.

Senator Cassidy made the point in personal terms. Babies cannot receive their first measles shot until around their first birthday, so they depend on everyone around them. "If you've not been vaccinated, you could be the person that brings death to another," he said. "We're seeing children die from measles who are too young to be vaccinated." That message, he said, needs to be "pounded, pounded, pounded." It is a call to personal responsibility, the oldest idea on the right.

The politics Republicans cannot ignore

There is also a hard political case, and Republicans who just lost the House and the Senate should hear it. Democrats are lining up to make Kennedy their symbol. Senators Angela Alsobrooks and Raphael Warnock have said he must resign or be fired. One incoming Democratic senator from South Carolina, Dr. Annie Andrews ran on impeaching him. In January, the people asking the questions at health hearings will be Democrats with subpoena power.

Senator Cassidy, who has said he does not see an impeachable offence, framed the choice as the president's own. "This is ultimately the president's legacy," he said. The president may want a record of higher health costs and lost elimination status, he added, but "if the president wants actually something positive, he should change." He tied it directly to the election: "The American voters signaled at the midterm they don't like status quo, particularly in healthcare, and I think it's time for something different."

He also spoke to the voters Kennedy was supposed to win over. Hundreds of parents in the movement Kennedy built, the self-described MAHA moms, contacted the senator during the confirmation fight. What they wanted, he said, was progress on ultra-processed food. "There's been minimal progress, and now we've lost our measles elimination status, and we have infants dying from measles," he said. "They have every right to be disappointed."

Conservative editors argued this week that the party needs to "recover a sense of institutional self-respect" after its midterm defeat. Few tests of that are cleaner than this one. A Republican senator, a doctor, the chairman of the relevant committee, has said a Republican cabinet secretary has failed. The evidence is in the case counts, the hospital wards and now an international verdict. The question is whether his colleagues will say so before Democrats say it for them.

What winning it back would take

Elimination can be regained, but not quickly. Current outbreaks must end, and future ones must stop spreading within a year. Paul Rota, a microbiologist and former CDC official, warns that moment is not yet on the horizon. "Bigger fires create more embers," he said, "and any one of those embers can seed another fire."

The fire will not go out on its own. It will take vaccination rates back above 95 percent in the communities where they have fallen, outbreak reports published fast enough to guide doctors, and federal leaders who say, unprompted and often, that the MMR shot is safe. Republicans have only a few working weeks left in control of the Senate and a president who can choose his own health secretary. Senator Cassidy has told them what he would do. On measles, the conservative answer and the right answer are the same.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X