Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

'No Coronation': Chris Van Hollen Is Working the Phones to Deny Chuck Schumer an Easy Return

2026-11-11 · Washington Eye Team

Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland speaking outdoors in Washington (photo: Senate Democrats, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

Chris Van Hollen does not look like the face of a revolt. He is 67, a father of three from an affluent suburb of the capital, and he has held public office without a break since 1991. He has run both of his party's national campaign committees, the one that elects House Democrats and the one that elects Senate Democrats. By any ordinary measure he is the establishment. Yet in the week since Democrats swept to control of both chambers, the Maryland senator has become the name progressive activists and several incoming senators reach for when they say Chuck Schumer should not lead the new majority.

The shift has been fast, and Van Hollen's own words have moved with it. Late last week, a source close to him told a television network that he was not planning to challenge Schumer and wanted the caucus to have "an honest and open conversation" about its agenda before choosing a leader. By Monday he was telling reporters at the Capitol that he was "in listening mode and haven't shut the door." By Tuesday evening, speaking at an event called "Popular Mandate" hosted by the progressive group Groundwork Action, he said he was "in the process right now of calling my colleagues." One reporter who was in the room wrote that he was "definitely talking like someone who wants to run for Senate majority leader."

He has still not declared. But the outline of a contest is visible, and the date is set: Senate Democrats are scheduled to elect their leaders on December 1, by secret ballot, with a simple majority of the caucus needed to win.

Van Hollen's argument so far is less about Schumer personally than about process and mandate. "What I've said from the very beginning is, we shouldn't have a coronation," he told reporters on Monday. "We should have a caucus discussion about what we're going to do with the power and responsibilities that have been invested in us." On Tuesday he put it more sharply: "We should not support anybody for leader without a very clear plan, and as you know, there are many people who think change is required."

He has also given the left a line it can repeat. Addressing activists on Tuesday, he told them: "We should bring a little more democracy to the United States Senate." And he framed the midterm result as a verdict on Washington itself. "Let's face it, there was also a clearly an anti-Washington establishment tone to this election," he said. "I'm clearly hearing the calls around the country for change. I think the question is whether those calls are being heard within the walls of the Senate Democratic caucus."

That is a pointed thing for a former campaign committee chairman to say, and it lands on a real grievance. Schumer and the party's Senate campaign arm, chaired this cycle by Kirsten Gillibrand of New York, favoured candidates they considered more electable in some primaries, including in Michigan. Two of the senators-elect who sat in Tuesday's caucus lunch, Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Troy Jackson of Maine, won their primaries without that early support; Schumer spent heavily for them once they were nominated. Van Hollen was the first senator to endorse El-Sayed, and he has not let the point go. "We have two members in that room, newly elected senators, who would not be there if Schumer and the DSCC had had their way," he said on Tuesday. His rule for the future: the committee should weigh in only in "very, very rare" cases. "Let the people decide."

What makes Van Hollen interesting as a figure is the route he took to this moment. For most of his career he was a skilled operator inside the party machine: 14 years representing Maryland's 8th District in the House, then the Senate from 2017, with stints running the party's campaign committees in both chambers. He was the kind of Democrat leadership relied on, not the kind it worried about.

The turn came in the spring of 2025, when he flew to El Salvador to press for the return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Maryland resident whom the administration had wrongly deported and whom federal courts said should be brought back. He did not secure Abrego Garcia's release on that trip. But the image of a senator travelling roughly 2,000 miles to confront the administration over one constituent made him, in the words of a wire service report at the time, a leading figure in the resistance to the president. It also set up an unflattering contrast. Schumer was then promising "extraordinary action" if the president defied the Supreme Court, without explaining what that action would be, while the administration resisted the Court's order to facilitate Abrego Garcia's return.

In 2025 Van Hollen also joined six other Democratic senators and the independent Bernie Sanders in a coalition that called itself the "Fight Club," formed to push Schumer to oppose the president more aggressively and to back more populist candidates in the midterms. Many of those populists are now senators-elect.

His platform now reads like the progressive wish list it is. At Tuesday's event he ticked through a wealth tax, restoring the lapsed health insurance subsidies under the Affordable Care Act, a $20 federal minimum wage and Medicare for All, which he conceded was unlikely to pass. He called the midterms a clear rebuke of the Iran war and said Democrats have a responsibility to "use our power to end the war, and that means not providing one more dime to an illegal war." He dared the president to shut down the government over the coming funding deadline: "That's his choice. But the American people have made their choice."

He has also drawn a line some on the left will not like. He said the president "obviously" committed impeachable offenses, but argued that Democrats' time "would be better spent focused on the oversight hearings and corruption and accountability."

The pressure on Schumer is real and growing. Sanders, who is in line to chair the Senate health and labour committee, said on Tuesday that he would not back Schumer. "I like Chuck. [There's] nobody who works harder than Chuck Schumer. But in my view, the time is now for change," he said. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan stood beside him and said that whoever wins her vote will need "a concrete plan that's definitively different." The progressive group Indivisible called for new leadership the day after the election, pointing to an October poll in which only 13 percent of registered voters viewed Schumer's leadership positively.

The incoming class matters most, because senators-elect vote in leadership elections before they are sworn in. El-Sayed has named Van Hollen as his pick since at least May, introducing him at a July rally as the "next Senate majority leader." Jackson, Adam Hamilton of Kansas and Juliana Stratton of Illinois have said plainly they will not support Schumer. Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota said this week she was not ready to commit and spoke of making sure "new voices" shape the Senate; Annie Andrews of South Carolina has called for a new generation of leadership. James Talarico of Texas has made no commitment.

But Schumer is still the favourite, and he is acting like it. "I'm confident I will be elected majority leader," he has said. On Tuesday, flanked by Gillibrand, Sheldon Whitehouse and Ruben Gallego, he told reporters: "We have great unity in our caucus, and I'll be proud to lead it as majority leader." His allies point to his fundraising and to the scale of the win: a net gain of at least seven seats, with Mississippi and Alaska still counting and a caucus that could reach 56. Gallego offered the baseball version of the argument: "When the manager takes you to the World Series, you give them another contract." Sherrod Brown, returning to the Senate from Ohio, answered the question of whether he backs Schumer with one word: "Yes."

There is also an awkward fact for the "new generation" message. Van Hollen and Schumer, who is 75, are both baby boomers. Van Hollen offers a change of direction, not of age.

From a progressive point of view, the strongest case for Van Hollen is not that he would certainly win. It is that the caucus should have to choose. Democrats won this majority partly on candidates the party establishment did not pick, in states such as Kansas and Texas where Democrats had not won these races in decades, and on an anti-Washington mood that, judging by his poll numbers, their own leader embodies for many voters. Handing Schumer the gavel without a contest would tell those voters their message stopped at the Senate door.

A real race would also force the questions that matter more than any name: whether the majority uses budget reconciliation for an ambitious economic bill, whether it ends funding for the Iran war, how hard it pushes oversight, and whether the campaign committee should keep choosing primary winners. Sanders, notably, has not decided whether to scrap the filibuster, saying he worries about "protecting minority rights," while arguing that a big reconciliation bill could "do a whole lot." Van Hollen's demand for "a very clear plan" before any vote is a demand that these choices be made in the open.

The risk is obvious. A bitter, close leadership fight weeks after a historic win could hand Republicans a story of Democratic disarray before the new Congress even meets on January 3. Senate Republicans, who re-elected John Thune as their leader on Tuesday after his critics failed to find a challenger, would have every incentive to amplify it.

David Karol, a political scientist at the University of Maryland, expects Van Hollen to move carefully. He said a losing challenge "It's not going to hurt him if he runs against Schumer and loses, unless he is totally humiliated," and predicted he will not run "unless he is assured of a significant number of votes." That is the calculation behind the phone calls. Van Hollen has said he has not yet reached every colleague, and that he has been playing "phone tag" with Schumer himself. He has also said in recent months that he is "kicking the tires" on a 2028 presidential run, which gives him reasons both to make a stand and to avoid an embarrassing defeat.

Whatever he decides, the late-career insider has already done something few Democrats managed in a decade: he has made Schumer's return a question rather than an assumption. With three weeks to go, the number to watch is not how many senators endorse Schumer, but how many keep refusing to say. In a secret ballot, silence is where an upset would hide.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X