Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

No Hackers Found. The Cyber Chief Is Out Anyway

2026-11-20 · Washington Eye Team

Airmen at the 616th Operations Center, 16th Air Force (Air Forces Cyber), Joint Base San Antonio-Lackland, Texas, 3 March 2021 (photo: U.S. Air Force / Vincent Childress, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

For a week, Americans have watched the machinery of daily life stutter. Flights stopped across the country. A major software company's services went dark. Bank transactions failed. Even the National Security Agency's classified internal communications went offline. Through all of it, the administration's message was consistent: this was not an attack. On Thursday, the White House nonetheless replaced the official whose job is to coordinate the federal government's cyber defenses.

Sean Cairncross, the national cyber director since August 2025, is leaving the administration, a White House official confirmed on Thursday evening, Washington time. His replacement, serving in an acting capacity, is Kirsten A. Davies, the Pentagon's chief information officer. The position requires Senate confirmation, though Ms. Davies has already been confirmed by the Senate once, for her current job.

The move raises an obvious question. If the outages were, as three senior officials told Congress on Wednesday, separate technical failures and not the work of hackers, why does the person in charge of cyber policy have to go? The answer appears to have less to do with any single failure than with politics, credentials and a White House reshaping itself under a new chief of staff.

A week of failures

The run of disruptions began in earnest with the nationwide ground stop of November 13, when telecommunications failures forced air traffic controllers to halt flights for more than four hours. Officials later traced the breakdown to the installation of a new router at a facility in Arkansas, which flooded the network with data and overwhelmed an older system. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin has blamed old copper wiring.

Other failures followed in quick succession: problems with a major software provider's products, outages at large banks and airlines, and a disruption to the National Security Agency's internal systems on Monday. The clustering of these events fed public anxiety and speculation online that the country was under coordinated assault. One major American news organization reported that the outages have fueled a wave of blackout panic and a boom in prepping.

At the House Homeland Security Committee's annual worldwide threats hearing on Wednesday, the Director of National Intelligence, Jay Clayton, tried to put that theory to rest. "These are separate service outages associated with maintenance and technical changes. They are not a coordinated or state-sponsored attack," he said. The FBI's deputy director, Christopher Raia, said there was "no indication whatsoever" of malicious cyber activity. Democratic members of Congress have broadly said the same, although some observers have suggested that artificial intelligence tools may have played a role in the failures.

That leaves the administration in an awkward position. It has spent days insisting that nothing sinister happened. Yet the personnel change on Thursday will be read by many Americans as an admission that something went wrong on someone's watch.

Why Cairncross, and why now

The official explanations are mixed. According to reporting from several US news outlets, Mr. Cairncross's departure was described by two sources as amicable. But two White House officials told a US news site that the new chief of staff, Stephen Miller, sought the change and pushed Mr. Cairncross out because, in the words of one, he "lacked the strong cyber credentials to perform the job."

That critique has followed Mr. Cairncross since his nomination. He is a longtime Republican lawyer and party operative rather than a career technologist. He served as chief operating officer of the Republican National Committee during the 2016 cycle and returned to the committee in the 2024 cycle as a deputy to its then chief operating officer, Chris LaCivita. During President Trump's first term, he was a senior adviser to the White House chief of staff. When he was confirmed in 2025, the White House praised his "extensive leadership experience." His predecessors in the role, by contrast, included a former deputy director of the National Security Agency, Chris Inglis, and a former senior intelligence executive, Harry Coker Jr.

The timing also fits a broader pattern. A major American newspaper reported that his exit continues the ouster of aides associated with Susie Wiles, who resigned as White House chief of staff on November 5 after the midterm elections. Mr. Miller, who succeeded her, has been moving quickly to put his own stamp on the staff. Ms. Davies made the connection plain herself: in a social media post, she thanked the president and Mr. Miller for "your faith and steady confidence in me."

Mr. Cairncross's office had also been thinning out. His head of policy and senior adviser, Thomas Lind, left in June. And he had been drawn into some of the administration's most contentious technology fights, including its deliberations over artificial intelligence after Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick directed the AI company Anthropic over the summer to take down its two most powerful systems on national security grounds. Mr. Cairncross held technical meetings with the company's leaders in the aftermath.

Who is Kirsten Davies?

Ms. Davies arrives with a résumé that looks far more like the job description. As the Pentagon's chief information officer, she has been the principal adviser to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth on information management, information technology, cybersecurity and information assurance. Before joining the administration, she spent close to two decades in corporate technology and security leadership, including leading global cyber resilience at the consumer goods giant Unilever, and holding technology and cyber roles at Estée Lauder, Barclays Africa Group, Hewlett Packard and Siemens. She also founded a nonprofit, the Institute for Cyber, focused on citizen safety online.

"Kirsten has the credentials to excel in this position and has already been Senate-confirmed," an administration official said. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who also serves as national security adviser, said on social media that he looked forward to working with her "to strengthen America's cybersecurity." Mr. Hegseth called her "a dedicated patriot and professional" who would "advance President Trump's America First agenda across the cybersecurity landscape."

Her own statement framed the moment in sweeping terms. "Our nation stands in the crossroad of analog, digital, and quantum technologies, our American way of living increasingly interconnected," she wrote, adding that the opportunity to "dominate the cyber landscape for generations to come" would only be realised if the country modernises and drives "resilience into the foundations our great nation runs on."

That last word, resilience, may be the most telling. The failures of the past week were not, by the government's own account, about adversaries breaking in. They were about ageing systems breaking down, upgrades going wrong and networks that could not absorb a shock. That is a problem of infrastructure and engineering as much as security, and it is one that a Pentagon technology manager may be better placed to speak to than a political lawyer.

The limits of the job

Still, the national cyber director has limited direct power over most of what failed. The Office of the National Cyber Director, created in 2021, coordinates cybersecurity policy and strategy across the federal government. It does not run the air traffic control system, operate private banks or manage a software company's cloud. The FAA's telecommunications network sits under the Transportation Department; the NSA answers to the Pentagon and the intelligence community. Private companies own most of the country's critical infrastructure.

That gap between responsibility and authority is one reason the change may prove more symbolic than operational, at least at first. Ms. Davies will join a cyber team that, according to a source close to the White House, also includes Mr. Clayton, the White House science and technology policy director Michael Kratsios, and Mr. Rubio. How she divides labour with them, and whether she gains any new authority over agencies whose systems failed, will matter more than the name on the office door.

What Congress will ask

The change also lands as Washington prepares for a transfer of power on Capitol Hill. Democrats will take control of the House in January, and the outages have already become a line of attack. Democrats have criticised the administration's response and warned that American cyber defences are falling behind threats amplified by artificial intelligence. At Wednesday's hearing, Representative Dan Goldman of New York pressed Mr. Clayton on whether the NSA disruption was internal or external, calling it "a pretty binary" question and accusing him of not answering directly.

Ms. Davies's acting status gives senators a natural opening. If the president formally nominates her, a confirmation hearing would be the first chance for lawmakers to question a senior official at length about what actually broke over the past week and what is being done to prevent it happening again. Even without a nomination, the incoming House majority is likely to want answers about why so many critical systems failed in so short a window.

For the administration, the calculation is straightforward. It can keep saying the outages were not an attack, and the evidence so far supports that. But it cannot tell a country that has just lived through grounded flights and frozen bank transfers that nothing needed to change. Replacing the cyber chief is a visible way to signal action without conceding that anyone got in.

Whether it is more than a signal will depend on what comes next: whether the new director pushes the agencies that run ageing networks to modernise faster, whether Congress funds that work, and whether the next upgrade at a regional facility can be rolled out without bringing a national system to its knees. Those are engineering questions as much as political ones. For now, the White House has answered only the political one.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X