Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Pride Flags, Vaccine Photos and 17 Missing Stars

2026-11-21 · Washington Eye Team

Close-up of a US Army general's shoulder with two stars pinned on at a promotion ceremony (photo: Pfc. Hejong Lee, U.S. Army, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

Every year the American military runs one of the most carefully engineered personnel systems in government. Boards of senior officers meet behind closed doors, review stacks of service records, and choose which colonels and Navy captains will become generals and admirals. Their choices are meant to be insulated from politics. The board picks; the president nominates; the Senate confirms.

This year, according to officials and officers who have described the process, something new happened in the gap between the board's choice and the president's nomination. A senior Pentagon official says staff were told to run internet searches on officers already selected for one star and two star rank, looking for any trace of support for diversity programmes, the Covid vaccine campaign, the withdrawal from Afghanistan, or Gen. Mark Milley, the former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff who became one of President Donald Trump's sharpest critics. Seventeen officers chosen by two separate promotion boards were then held back, the official says. Every woman and every person of colour on those lists except one was among them.

On Thursday, eight Democratic senators led by Mark Kelly of Arizona, a retired Navy captain, sent Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth a letter demanding to know how many officers were blocked, on what criteria, and under what legal authority. They gave the Pentagon 30 days. In January, Democrats take control of both chambers of Congress, and the people asking these questions will hold the gavels.

Here is what has been reported, what the Pentagon says, what the law requires, and why the fight is about to get much bigger.

What was in the files

The most detailed account surfaced on November 9, when a cable news outlet reported on what it described as paper only files assembled on senior officers whose promotions were then withheld. The files, according to that report and to two of the affected officers, were built from internet printouts the officers themselves never saw. Instructions about the new criteria were given by telephone rather than in writing. The two officers said they learned by phone that their promotions had stalled and were given no chance to respond.

The material cited against more than a dozen officers, as described in that reporting, was strikingly ordinary. It included Pride Month activities and rainbow flags. It included the creation of a diversity committee and task force aboard the amphibious assault ship USS Kearsarge, a speech at a Hispanic heritage celebration aboard the aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt, a minority aviation panel at the Naval Academy and an International Women's Day panel at US Africa Command. One item was a photograph of a ship's command team taken after a second Covid vaccination aboard the USS Carl Vinson.

"I was like, 'You gotta be kidding me,' but of course we need people to get confirmed," the senior official said, speaking anonymously out of fear of retaliation. "We need nominations to go through. We need decisions made."

Much of what was flagged was not private political activity. It was official duty. Commanders carried out the vaccine mandate because they were ordered to. Diversity task forces and heritage events were Defense Department policy under previous administrations. That is the core of the senators' complaint: officers, they wrote, "may be penalized for faithfully implementing lawful policies and directives issued by previous administrations."

How big is this, really?

The numbers depend on who is counting and what they count, and readers should be careful not to add them together.

The figure of 17 comes from a single senior official and covers officers picked by two boards for the one star and two star ranks. Earlier tallies were wider. In June a wire service reported that Mr. Hegseth had struck nine of 31 officers selected for promotion to one star admiral, including all three women on the list. By late August, a major American newspaper counted at least 45 officers removed from promotion lists this year after being selected by boards, more than half of them women or Black officers. A coalition of 33 civil rights and women's groups, including the NAACP, the National Women's Law Center and the American Civil Liberties Union, cited a figure of at least 40 senior officers blocked in a letter in September. A military news site has counted more than 80 generals and admirals fired, pushed out or blocked from promotion during Mr. Hegseth's tenure, a category that also includes dismissals at the very top.

The groups also noted that the share of women nominated for high ranking promotions had fallen to its lowest level in more than two decades. Among those whose advancement they said had stalled were Adm. Sara Joyner and Rear Adm. Stephen D. Barnett, both of whom, the groups said, had actively recruited women and people of colour.

The Pentagon's answer

The Pentagon has not disputed that promotions were withheld. What it disputes is the motive.

Sean Parnell, its chief spokesman, said Mr. Hegseth is "reviving the warrior ethos" and wants senior officers "committed to war fighting, lethality, and dominance in combat." He added that "the Department is committed to ensuring that all advancement is merit-based" and that the secretary "has acted and will continue to act within his authority." When the civil rights groups accused Mr. Hegseth of blocking officers because of race and sex, another spokeswoman, Kingsley Wilson, replied: "This is a lie, and we have said so repeatedly."

There is a serious argument on the secretary's side, and it deserves a fair hearing. Mr. Hegseth has said openly that he wants to shrink the ranks of generals and admirals by 10 to 20 percent to "streamline leadership by reducing excess general and flag officer positions." Many conservatives, and some reformers who are not conservative at all, have argued for years that the senior officer corps is bloated relative to the size of the force. Civilian control of the military is a constitutional principle, not a slogan, and promotion boards are not meant to have the final word. At the three star and four star level, even the civil rights groups conceded, the secretary has more discretion.

Supporters of the secretary also argue that officers who championed programmes they see as divisive should not be rewarded with stars, and that a new administration is entitled to choose leaders who share its priorities. That is a political judgment voters can weigh. The legal question is narrower: whether the process used to act on that judgment followed the rules Congress wrote.

What the law says officers are owed

Federal law reserves the power to remove a name from a general or flag officer selection board report to the president. Under Title 10 of the US Code, section 618, when a removal recommendation rests on information the board never saw, that information must be shown to the officer, along with a "reasonable opportunity to submit comments." Pentagon rules carry similar protections.

Congress tightened the rules less than a year ago. A provision signed into law on December 18, 2025 requires the defense secretary to notify the congressional defense committees within 30 days whenever a name is removed from a board report for any reason other than misconduct. Officers whose promotions stay stalled beyond 18 months can be dropped from the list altogether, although the law allows certain extensions. In practice, a delay that is never resolved can end a career without anyone formally saying no.

Whether those protections were triggered depends on distinctions the Pentagon has not publicly addressed. Withholding a nomination, delaying a promotion and formally removing a name are legally different acts, and the department may hold names back in some circumstances, such as a review of adverse information. If the officers were simply never forwarded, the department may argue that no removal occurred. Critics reply that a file of printouts the officer cannot see, followed by an open ended hold, is a removal in everything but name.

Cody Harnish, a military defence lawyer and former Army judge advocate, put the critics' case bluntly, calling the practice of pulling officers after selection illegal. "If 'professionally unqualified' can mean 'executed a lawful program the current Secretary opposes,' the promotion system and law has no function left," he said.

Why January changes everything

Democrats have been asking these questions for months with little to show for it. In July, Senators Cory Booker of New Jersey and Brian Schatz of Hawaii asked the Pentagon's inspector general to investigate the removals, calling the secretary's involvement "highly irregular." Senator Tammy Duckworth of Illinois has pushed legislation requiring written explanations whenever a promotion is withheld, delayed or denied. None of it forced an answer while Republicans controlled the committees.

That ends in January. Thursday's letter was signed by Mr. Kelly, Ms. Duckworth, Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut, Mazie Hirono of Hawaii, Tim Kaine of Virginia, Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts, and Gary Peters and Elissa Slotkin of Michigan. Mr. Kelly, a member of the Armed Services Committee, is in line to chair one of its subcommittees. In the House, Representative Adam Smith, set to chair the Armed Services Committee, has already named "purging of the ranks based on loyalty and ideology" among his oversight targets.

"Decisions about who advances to these positions must be based on merit, not political loyalty," Mr. Kelly wrote.

The promotion files arrive on top of other pressure. Representative Thomas Massie, a Kentucky Republican, said this week that he plans to reintroduce an impeachment resolution against Mr. Hegseth in the new Congress and would drop it only if the secretary resigned. A lengthy magazine report published Friday quoted officials accusing Mr. Hegseth of overselling the Iran war's successes to the president, which the Pentagon denied, saying the secretary gives Mr. Trump "the complete, unvarnished picture."

What to watch

Three things will decide where this goes. The first is the paper trail. The senators asked for documents showing how each decision was made; if the instructions really were given only by phone, the absence of records will itself become a story. The second is the 30 day notice law passed last December: if names were removed and Congress was never notified, that is a straightforward statutory question rather than a fight about ideology. The third is the calendar. Officers held back this year are edging toward the 18 month line, and a Senate under new management can slow or stop the confirmations the Pentagon needs.

The deeper question is one the military has tried for generations to keep out of the promotion room: whether an officer's career should depend on the politics of the orders they once carried out. The Pentagon says it is restoring a fighting culture. Its critics say it is punishing people for doing their jobs. Starting in January, the answer will be argued under oath.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X