House Republicans spent Tuesday deciding what kind of party they want to be in the wilderness, and they answered in two votes taken a few hours apart. Behind closed doors, they chose Rep. Jim Jordan of Ohio, the most combative figure in their ranks, to lead them into the minority, beating Majority Leader Steve Scalise of Louisiana 106 to 73 in a secret ballot, according to two people present for the tally. Then, on the open floor, they closed ranks around Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and voted 211 to 204 to send eight articles of impeachment against him to the Judiciary Committee, the procedural graveyard where such resolutions usually stay.
Taken together, the two results describe a conference that lost more than 40 seats a week ago and has decided that the answer is not a retreat to the centre but a sharper fight. They also exposed a soft spot on the other side of the aisle. Eleven Democrats missed the Hegseth vote on a day when their leaders had said they would vote to impeach, and the incoming majority now faces questions about its own discipline before it has even taken power.
Jordan's victory completes a long road. He ran for minority leader in 2018 and lost to Kevin McCarthy of California. When McCarthy was removed as speaker in 2023, Jordan lost a secret-ballot conference vote to Scalise, and when Scalise's own bid collapsed, a group of moderate Republicans refused to give Jordan the floor majority he needed to become speaker. Many of those moderates will not be in the next Congress. This time Jordan needed only a majority of his own conference, and he won it comfortably.
He made no secret of the kind of leader he intends to be. Jordan, 62, co-founded the House Freedom Caucus and served as its first chairman. He chairs the Judiciary Committee today and previously led the Oversight Committee. In a letter to colleagues he described himself as "battle tested on the oversight front", a pitch aimed squarely at the wave of Democratic investigations expected in January, and he faulted the outgoing leadership for having too often "operated without a clear plan to survive the hour or the day in front of us."
His first remarks as leader-elect were brief and on message. "Over the next two years, House Republicans will fight for American families," Jordan said. "When Democrats offer more government, we'll offer more freedom. And we will bring that fight in committee, on the floor and on the stump every single day." He thanked colleagues and left without taking questions.
Speaker Mike Johnson, who announced the day after the midterms that he would step back from leadership, declined to say how he voted, calling both candidates "my brothers." But he read the result plainly. "He's a fighter, and I think that's the signal that is being sent here," Johnson said of Jordan. He also offered a note of cold comfort about the job ahead: "It is easier to keep a group together when you're in the minority."
Scalise ran on experience and electability. Leaving the candidate forum, he argued that his record made the difference. "I could go to the most ruby red or the most swing district," he said, adding that Republicans would have to win back the swing seats they had just lost. Tellingly, his nominating speeches were assigned to Reps. Mario Diaz-Balart of Florida, Craig Goldman of Texas and Jeff Hurd of Colorado, a group weighted towards members who had just survived close races. That is precisely the kind of Republican whose voice shrank in last week's election, and the 33-vote margin suggests the surviving conference is more interested in confrontation than in the next swing district.
The rest of the leadership slate did not follow the same insurgent mood. Majority Whip Tom Emmer of Minnesota held off August Pfluger of Texas 103 to 76 and will serve as Jordan's deputy. Conference Chair Lisa McClain of Michigan won another term with 93 votes against 57 for Erin Houchin of Indiana and 27 for Greg Steube of Florida. Rep. Brian Jack of Georgia, a former political adviser to President Donald Trump, won the campaign committee chair 125 to 53 over Rudy Yakym of Indiana. The result is a mixed message: a new face at the top, familiar hands beneath him and a Trump alumnus running the effort to win back the House.
Some Republicans had wanted no vote at all yet. Ways and Means Chairman Jason Smith of Missouri argued for postponing the elections until the conference rewrote rules that he said had let individual members hold leaders hostage, and 31 members of the Republican National Committee signed a letter urging a delay of at least 30 days. Johnson said logistics made that impossible because new members were already in town for orientation.
Across the Capitol, Senate Republicans chose continuity. A push led by Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin to delay their own elections failed 31 to 15, and John Thune of South Dakota was then re-elected leader by acclamation, with John Barrasso, Tom Cotton and Shelley Moore Capito keeping their posts. The frustration was still audible. "This was the worst set of losses since Watergate," said Sen. Josh Hawley of Missouri. The contrast between the two chambers is worth noting: Senate Republicans kept a leader built for dealmaking, while House Republicans picked one built for combat.
The Hegseth vote showed what that combat will look like in practice. The resolution, filed by Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky, was privileged, which forced leaders to bring it to the floor within two legislative days. Its eight articles accused the defense secretary of waging war on Iran without authorisation and in defiance of the War Powers Resolution, ignoring laws meant to limit civilian casualties, carrying out extrajudicial killings in strikes on suspected drug boats, suppressing free speech, seizing then Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro and waging an unlawful war in Yemen. One count pointed to reported cuts at a Pentagon office focused on preventing civilian harm before a US missile struck an Iranian primary school during the war.
Massie, who lost his primary earlier this year after Trump and Hegseth helped campaign against him, was the only Republican to vote against sending the resolution to committee. Every one of the 203 Democrats who voted sided with him. The other 210 Republicans who voted, joined by independent Kevin Kiley of California, backed the motion, according to the official House roll call.
Hegseth answered the effort with open contempt before the vote. "What one disgruntled and defeated congressman is attempting is not oversight, and it's not accountability," he said. "It's a political spectacle, a personal manifesto driven by ego and resentment." Johnson called the resolution "a political gambit for attention" and Massie "a disgruntled congressman." Even some Republicans who have criticised Hegseth said the charges did not rise to high crimes and misdemeanours. Rep. Don Bacon of Nebraska, who is retiring, said he did not agree with the impeachment itself, while warning that House Republican leaders "can't just be a rubber stamp for the president."
The Democratic side of the ledger is the more awkward one. Eighteen members did not vote: seven Republicans and eleven Democrats, among them former Speaker Nancy Pelosi. The arithmetic matters. Had the eleven absent Democrats voted no while every other vote stayed the same, the motion would have failed 211 to 215 and the articles would have come to the floor. But that is only half the picture. Had the seven absent Republicans also shown up and voted with their party, the motion would have passed anyway, 218 to 215. The absences did not by themselves decide the outcome, but they handed Republicans a margin of comfort and handed critics a story.
Some of the absences had ordinary explanations. Rep. Lou Correa of California said he was in his district for a medical procedure. Rep. Melanie Stansbury of New Mexico said she was held up by a traffic incident and a police escort near the Capitol and reached the chamber just after the vote closed, then recorded that she would have voted no. Democratic leaders had also chosen not to pressure their members. "It's not being whipped," said Rep. Pete Aguilar of California, the caucus chair. "We didn't put our finger on the scale."
That decision now looks like a calculated hedge. Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries, who had said he would vote to impeach, faces a vote next week on his bid to become speaker, and his leadership team appears to have judged that forcing frontline members onto the record on a Republican-authored impeachment in a lame-duck session was not worth the risk. Jeffries said he had not discussed the vote with the floor team. "This is not the end of it," he said. "It's just the beginning."
Massie was blunter about his own party. "My diagnosis of Congress is these people know what to do," he told reporters. "They just can't bring themselves to do it, even when it would benefit them politically." He compared the midterms to the Titanic striking the iceberg and said colleagues had turned down the life raft he offered. He now plans to force a vote on a war powers resolution, testing whether Republicans who blamed the Iran war for their losses will vote to constrain it.
Even a successful House impeachment would have faced a two-thirds threshold in the Senate, a bar no cabinet impeachment has ever cleared. But the significance of Tuesday was never mainly about removal. It was about where each party draws its lines heading into January. Republicans, with Jordan at the top, have signalled that they will defend the administration's officials as a bloc and treat Democratic oversight as a fight to be won rather than a process to be managed. Democrats, about to hold the largest House majority either party has had in decades, showed that their members still answer first to their districts, and that their leaders are willing to let them.
The lame-duck calendar will test both conclusions quickly. Congress faces an 11 December deadline to fund the government, a defense policy bill and a farm bill. Thune has promised to "finish this legislative session strong." A war powers vote from Massie would force Republicans to choose between the party line and the message many of them say voters sent on 3 November. And when the new Congress arrives, Jordan will lead a much smaller conference against a much larger majority, armed with the oversight experience he sold to colleagues and facing Democrats who have already promised that the investigations will run the other way.
For now, House Republicans have made their choice. They did not pick the leader who promised a road back through the swing districts. They picked the one who promised a fight, and on the same afternoon they showed they are prepared to wage it on behalf of the administration's most embattled cabinet secretary.
