The blue wave that swept Washington state this month was, by most measures, a rout. Republicans lost nine seats in the state House and will soon hold just 29 of its 98 seats, a superminority that leaves them unable to block much of anything. Democrats flipped legislative districts east of the Cascades that had not sent a Democrat to Olympia in more than three decades. It looked like a clean verdict.
Then came the ballot measures, and the verdict got messier. On the same ballot that handed Democrats their landslide, Washington voters did two things that sit uneasily together. They refused, by a wide margin, to repeal a new 9.9% state income tax on household income above $1 million, a policy championed by Democratic Governor Bob Ferguson. And they approved, by a margin almost as wide, Initiative 638, which bars students the measure defines as biologically male from competing in girls' school sports and requires girls to have their sex verified by a healthcare provider before they play.
Put simply, the same electorate gave the left its signature economic win and the right one of its signature cultural wins. The unofficial statewide count, updated on Saturday, shows Initiative 645, the repeal of the millionaires' tax, failing with 42.04% of the vote to 57.96%. Initiative 638 passed with 55.99% to 44.01%. Those are not narrow results driven by turnout quirks. More than three million ballots were cast on each question.
For national strategists in both parties, Washington is now a small laboratory for a question that will hang over the next two years: what exactly did voters endorse in 2026?
Start with the income tax. Washington has long been one of a handful of states with no personal income tax, and its voters have rejected income tax proposals repeatedly over the past century. The Democratic legislature passed the high earners' levy after a marathon debate earlier this year, and Ferguson signed it on 30 March. It takes effect on 1 January 2028, with first payments due in 2029. The state Department of Revenue estimates that about 20,000 households will owe it. Backers project $3 billion to $3.5 billion a year in revenue, and the law pairs the tax with an expanded working families tax credit, sales tax exemptions for diapers and hygiene products, and relief for small businesses.
The repeal campaign was led by Let's Go Washington, the conservative group founded by Brian Heywood, a Redmond hedge fund manager who has bankrolled several successful initiatives in recent years. This time he was badly outspent. The repeal side raised about $3.9 million, while opponents, led by public sector unions, put in more than $13 million, according to campaign finance reporting. Large employers, including the state's biggest technology company, stayed on the sidelines.
"While the income tax outcome is not what we hoped for, our fight to protect Washington taxpayers from (Gov.) Bob Ferguson's continuous cash grab is far from over," Heywood said in a statement conceding defeat. Ferguson, for his part, said in a video posted online that the repeal had gone down "in freaking flames," adding: "this was not just some King County thing."
On that point the county map backs him up. The tax did best in Seattle, where a precinct analysis found the repeal losing 80% to 20%. But a precinct consultant and a Seattle columnist who examined the results noted that the tax also survived in several counties east of the mountains that usually vote Republican, including Spokane, Whitman, Walla Walla and Yakima, and even in Klickitat County, where opponents chose to file their constitutional lawsuit. In Walla Walla, voters upheld the tax while electing Republicans to the legislature and to Congress. The suburbs of King County, from Bellevue and Redmond to Kent, Federal Way and Auburn, backed it too. Only the wealthiest enclaves, such as Mercer Island, Medina and parts of north Seattle, voted to scrap it.
"Some of the lower-income neighborhoods are very enthusiastic about taxing the rich," said Ben Anderstone, a Seattle political consultant who specialises in precinct analysis.
Now look at the sports measure, and the map almost inverts. Initiative 638 carried 35 of the state's 39 counties. In rural eastern counties it won landslides: roughly 80% in Adams County and 82% in Ferry County. It passed in suburbs that are represented by Democrats, about 53% in Bellevue and 52% in Mercer Island, according to the precinct analysis, and more strongly in the working-class suburbs of south King County: 57% in Kent, 58% in Federal Way, and above 62% in Auburn.
Even Seattle was not uniform. The city rejected the measure by roughly 75% to 25%, but a dozen precincts backed it outright, and some heavily immigrant neighbourhoods in the Chinatown-International District and Rainier Valley gave it 40% or more. One mixed-income public housing community in Rainier Valley, home to Southeast Asian and East African immigrant families and seniors, voted with the majority on both questions: keep the millionaires' tax, approve the sports restriction.
That is the uncomfortable overlap for both parties. The voters most eager to tax the rich in south King County were also among the most willing to restrict transgender girls in school sports. The wealthiest precincts, which voted to repeal the tax, include some of the same places that supported Initiative 638. The coalitions do not line up neatly with either party's platform.
Washington was not alone. Voters in Arizona, Colorado and Nebraska also approved measures requiring school teams to be separated by biological sex, making it four for four on sports eligibility measures this year. Colorado voters also approved a ban on certain gender surgeries for minors. The one partial exception was Missouri, where voters defeated an amendment that combined restrictions on gender transition treatment for minors with a ban on abortion, a pairing that made it hard to read as a verdict on either issue alone.
On taxes the national picture is more mixed than Washington's result suggests. California voters made the state's three highest income tax rates permanent, with about 61% in favour, and Colorado voters replaced their flat income tax with a graduated one that reaches 8.4% on income above $1 million. But California voters also rejected a one-time 5% tax on billionaires' wealth, which drew about 48% support. Iowa voters made it harder to raise income taxes by requiring a two-thirds legislative vote, and North Carolina voters lowered the state's income tax cap.
The lesson many analysts draw is narrow but important: voters in several states were willing to raise taxes on very high earners when the measure was framed around incomes, schools or relief for ordinary families, and less willing when it reached into wealth or looked like an open-ended grab. Washington's measure, with its $1 million threshold and its bundle of tax credits, fell into the first category.
For Democrats, the Washington results are a warning against reading the blue wave as a mandate for their full agenda. The party has spent the past two years arguing that affordability and economic fairness are its strongest ground, and the income tax vote supports that. But voters in the very districts Democrats just won, in central Washington and in the diverse suburbs south of Seattle, also voted for a sports measure that party leaders opposed. In central Washington's 14th District, which Democrats flipped for the first time in 34 years, the state party credits a 38-point swing among Latino voters toward its candidates. Many of those same voters live in counties that backed Initiative 638 heavily.
Some Democrats are already arguing privately that the party needs a position on transgender athletes that does not leave it on the losing side of a 12-point ballot result. Others argue that the measure, which imposes sex verification only on girls, will not survive the courts. Civil rights groups are preparing challenges under the state's anti-discrimination law and its equal rights amendment, and the American Civil Liberties Union has said it will "explore all potential next steps to uphold the rights of transgender girls and their access to school sports." State education officials say the new rules take effect on 3 December.
The stakes in numerical terms are small. State education officials have estimated that only five to ten transgender girls take part in school sports among Washington's 1.2 million public school students. But the political stakes are large, which is exactly why the issue keeps appearing on ballots.
For Republicans, the mirror-image problem is just as sharp. The party's position, and the position of the conservative lawyers now challenging the millionaires' tax in court, is that a state income tax is unconstitutional in Washington. Their case, brought by former Attorney General Rob McKenna and former state Supreme Court Justice Phil Talmadge, rests on a 1933 state Supreme Court decision that treated income as property, which the state constitution says must be taxed uniformly and at no more than 1%. A hearing is due in Klickitat County Superior Court in February, and the case is expected to reach the state Supreme Court.
Republicans may well win in court. The 1933 precedent has been upheld before. But they would be winning against the clearly expressed wishes of many of their own voters, including in the rural counties that form the party's base. If the tax is struck down, the pressure to shift Washington's tax burden toward the wealthy will not disappear. It will simply move to another vehicle.
The temptation after any wave election is to reduce it to one sentence. Washington's ballot makes that harder. Its voters wanted change, punished the party in power in Washington, D.C., and handed Democrats their largest state House majority in decades. They also wanted the wealthy to pay more and wanted firm sex-based rules in girls' sports. Those positions are not contradictory to the voters who hold them. They are only contradictory to the party platforms that have to absorb them.
In January, Democrats in Olympia will hold enough seats to pass almost anything. How they handle a voter-approved law most of them opposed, and how Republicans handle a voter-approved tax most of them despise, will say a great deal about whether either party has learned what the electorate actually said.
