Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Ten Bills, Five Agencies, One Hollowed-Out Department

2026-11-20 · Washington Eye Team

A student's math worksheet and graphing calculator during a teacher workshop in Portland (photo: US Department of Education, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

The Education Department has spent most of the past year giving its work away. Student loans went to the Treasury for day-to-day management. Job training and adult education went to Labor. Tribal programs went to Interior, international programs to State, and child care help for student parents to Health and Human Services. All of it was done by signed agreements between agencies, not by law. On Wednesday, four Senate Republicans introduced a package designed to change that and make the moves permanent.

The package, called Less Bureaucracy, Better Education, is ten separate bills. Senator Jim Banks of Indiana leads it, with Senators Tommy Tuberville of Alabama, Ashley Moody of Florida and Mike Lee of Utah. Together the bills would move almost every major program the department runs to five other departments. They would not shut the department's doors. They would leave it with far less to do.

Here is what the bills would do, what has already happened, what the department's own watchdog is warning about, and why the calendar matters more than the text.

Where each program would land

The biggest single move is money. A bill from Moody, filed as S. 5744 and referred to the Senate health and education committee on 18 November, would hand the administration of federal student aid to the Treasury Department. That covers Pell Grants, federal student loans, Federal Work-Study, and loan servicing and collection. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has described the loan book as a "$1.7 trillion federal student loan portfolio."

The Labor Department would gain the most programs. A Tuberville bill would send most functions of the Office of Elementary and Secondary Education to Labor, including Title I aid for schools with many low-income students, charter school programs, rural education, impact aid and education for homeless children and youth. A second Tuberville bill would move a long list of college programs to Labor as well, among them TRIO, GEAR UP, programs for historically Black colleges and other minority-serving institutions, support for veteran students and disability-related higher education programs. A Banks bill would move career, technical and adult education, including Perkins programs and adult education under the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act, to Labor.

The rest is spread out. Lee's two bills would move Title VI international education, foreign language programs and Fulbright-Hays to the State Department, and foreign medical accreditation to Health and Human Services. Other Banks bills would give State the job of enforcing the rules that make colleges disclose foreign gifts and contracts, move 22 tribal and Native education and job-training programs to the Interior Department, and move the Child Care Access Means Parents in School program and several family and community engagement programs to Health and Human Services.

The House is ahead on paper. Its Education and Workforce Committee advanced its own ten-bill version in July. None of those bills has had a vote on the House floor.

What has already moved

The bills are less a new plan than a way to write an existing one into law. In March 2025, President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing Education Secretary Linda McMahon to take lawful steps toward closing the department while keeping services running. Because the department was created by Congress, only Congress can abolish it. So the administration did the next closest thing: it signed agreements letting other agencies run parts of the department's work.

This week the department marked one year since it announced its first six partnerships. It said those have now grown to 14, with Labor, Health and Human Services, Justice, Interior, State and the Treasury. It listed results. More than 8,000 workforce payments worth over $2 billion went through a single Labor Department system. Nine K-12 grant competitions awarded more than $425 million through Labor's grants platform. About 1,000 new college and job-training grants were worth nearly $1 billion. In 2026, 21 states merged their career education and workforce plans into one state plan, up from nine in 2024.

The department also said every fiscal 2026 allocation under Part B of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act reached states on time and in full, supporting about 8.2 million students with disabilities, and that enforcement of that law stays with the Education Department. A new online center for borrowers in default launched with Treasury, and the department said 89 percent of early users found the rehabilitation process easy to follow. Under the foreign gifts partnership with State, it said 583 colleges and universities filed 142,552 disclosures worth $76.3 billion.

Cabinet officials lined up behind the record. "For too long, Washington measured success by how many rules it wrote rather than how well students were doing," McMahon said. Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling said the partnership covers education and workforce initiatives "that can keep pace with the evolving needs of job creators." Bessent said Treasury brings "unique financial and operational expertise" to student loans.

The physical footprint is shrinking too. Remaining staff are leaving the Lyndon B. Johnson headquarters building for a smaller building, and the Energy Department is set to take it over. A fact sheet on the move projected $4.8 million in rent savings for the Education Department.

What the sponsors say

The sponsors frame the package as finishing a promise. "For too long, the centralized bureaucracy of the Department of Education has overridden state and local control of schooling while failing America's families," Lee said. Banks said the bills would "make their reforms permanent, eliminate layers of Washington bureaucracy, and ensure taxpayers are no longer forced to prop up a failed department." Tuberville said schools should be "preparing the next generation of Americans for life" and "not pushing some woke ideology."

McMahon welcomed the bills, saying they would "make permanent the work we have done to align programs with the agencies best suited to support and return education authority to those closest to the child."

One point is easy to miss. Most of the bills move programs between federal departments. They do not, on their face, hand the money to states or end the programs. Title I would still exist. Pell Grants would still exist. The argument is about who runs them in Washington, and whether a department built for education should be the one doing it.

What the watchdog found

The department's own Office of Inspector General offered a more cautious view a few days earlier. In its annual report on the department's most serious management challenges, dated 13 November, it said the department will keep facing problems in 2027 tied to managing change and overseeing the schools, states and colleges that receive its money. It pointed to the interagency agreements, waivers from federal spending and accountability rules, and the 2025 layoffs.

"Change of this magnitude can result in challenges associated with employee resistance, fatigue, and uncertainty," the report said, including "decreased productivity, operational disruption, and lost efficiency." It noted that the department had not yet issued its annual performance plan for fiscal 2026, its annual performance report for fiscal 2025, its strategic plan for 2026 to 2030 or its performance plan for fiscal 2027.

The staffing cuts were large. Changes reached 16 of the department's 17 offices and reduced a workforce of more than 4,000 people at the start of 2025 by at least 40 percent. Critics have focused on the Office for Civil Rights. A report from the office of Senator Bernie Sanders, the Vermont independent, found that the office resolved only 1 percent of its cases in 2025, the lowest share in more than a decade.

In its reply to the watchdog, the department said it had "continued efforts to improve operational processes and maintain program delivery during a period of substantial organizational change" and had brought in contractor support to help resolve external audits. It has long said the changes do not affect the duties the law requires it to perform.

The calendar problem

The hardest fact for the sponsors is the date. Congress has roughly three weeks of legislative work left in December. In January, Democrats take control of both the House and the Senate, and the party has opposed the effort to wind the department down from the start. Like any ordinary bill, each of the ten would also need 60 votes to clear a Senate filibuster, which Republicans do not have. Tuberville is due to leave the Senate in January to become governor of Alabama.

That makes the package hard to read as a serious bid to pass a law this year. It reads better as a marker: a full statement of where Republicans want every program to sit, filed before the majority changes hands, that a future Republican Congress could pick up.

Democrats have signalled how they intend to push back. Before the midterms, Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland said his colleagues would seek language in a 2027 spending bill to bar the use of "any of these funds to shut down the Department of Education." Jon Valant, who directs an education policy centre at a Washington think tank, predicted that a Democratic Congress would "throw sand in the gears" through oversight hearings and spending-bill limits on the interagency agreements.

What to watch

First, the spending fight. The agreements were signed by the executive branch, and nothing in them has the force of a statute. A Democratic Congress cannot easily force the department to take programs back, but it can write conditions into the money that pays for them. Watch for riders in the next round of appropriations that limit or bar new interagency agreements.

Second, the student loan portfolio. Treasury already handles day-to-day management and collections under an agreement. If borrowers or colleges run into trouble during the handover, that will shape the debate faster than any committee vote, because millions of families feel it directly.

Third, oversight. The watchdog's list of missing performance plans gives a new majority an easy starting point for hearings. Expect questions about the Office for Civil Rights, special education enforcement, and how other departments are judged when they run programs on the Education Department's behalf.

For now, the department exists, its programs are funded, and its work is increasingly done by others. The ten bills spell out how Republicans would finish the job. Whether anyone can pass them is a question the next Congress, not this one, will answer.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X