Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

The Medicaid Deal Republicans Already Wrote

2026-11-19 · Washington Eye Team

The waiting room of the Lytle Community Health Center, a rural clinic in Lytle, Texas, photographed on 5 December 2017 (photo: U.S. Department of Agriculture, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

For more than a decade, the fight over Medicaid expansion in the last holdout states had a simple shape. Democrats wanted it, Republicans blocked it, and the map barely moved. The November midterms appeared to blow that stalemate apart. Democrats will take the governor's office in Georgia, Kansas, Texas and Wisconsin, four states that have refused to fully expand the program, and all four governors-elect campaigned on doing exactly that.

"This win is for the caregiver who can't afford healthcare and needs Georgia to finally expand Medicaid," Georgia's governor-elect, Keisha Lance Bottoms, told supporters on election night.

It is a powerful promise, and on paper the numbers behind it are large. More than a million people across the four states could be covered by full expansion, according to 2024 estimates from a health policy research group. In Texas alone, expansion could bring up to $10 billion a year in federal money and cover more than a million additional residents.

But the governors-elect are walking into a different world from the one in which this argument began. The rules for any new expansion were rewritten last year, and they were written by Republicans. The 2025 budget law that President Donald Trump signed, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, did not abolish the expansion option. It did something that may prove more durable: it changed what expansion means. For Republicans still holding key state legislative chambers, that is the real story of the post-midterm Medicaid debate. The terms of any deal are already on the books.

What the 2025 law changed

The Affordable Care Act was meant to require every state to expand Medicaid to low-income adults. A 2012 Supreme Court decision made it optional. Forty states and the District of Columbia have since opted in, most recently North Carolina in 2023. Ten have not.

For years, the case for the holdouts to join rested partly on generous federal money. Washington pays 90 percent of the cost for the expansion group, and new expansion states were offered an extra financial bonus. North Carolina received more than $1 billion in such bonus payments, which it put toward a new children's hospital, mental health care and workforce programs.

The 2025 law ended that bonus. It also tightened the limits on taxes that states levy on hospitals and other providers to help fund their share of Medicaid, and it set those limits lower for full expansion states than for states that have not expanded. Wisconsin's own health department warned last year that the law's provisions made expansion there "fiscally and operationally unfeasible," citing the lost incentive, reduced provider taxes and a requirement that expansion adults have their eligibility checked every six months.

Most important politically, the law created the first federal Medicaid work requirement. Starting January 1, 2027, many enrollees aged 19 to 64 in the expansion group must show they work, volunteer, attend school at least half time or join a work program for at least 80 hours a month, or earn at least about $580 a month, unless they qualify for an exemption. On November 13 the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services gave states an optional six-month grace period. States that take it must still check whether people meet the rule, but cannot drop anyone solely for failing it until after June 30, 2027. States have until December 11 to say whether they want the delay.

Republicans got what they asked for

Here is the irony Democrats now have to manage. The very provisions they spent last year attacking answer many of the objections Republicans raised against expansion for a decade.

Leo Cuello, a research professor at Georgetown University's Center for Children and Families who supports expansion, made the point bluntly in a recent interview. Many Republican lawmakers had opposed expansion because it did not require enrollees to work, he noted. "Regardless of whether that talking point is true or not, you now have a work requirement to screen out whatever people you think are not doing what they should to participate," he said. The law also added cost-sharing for some enrollees, which he said "matches the world view of some people" that beneficiaries should have "skin in the game." Combined with more frequent renewals, he argued, these changes mean fewer people enroll, so "the total price tag for doing Medicaid expansion has decreased."

Supporters of expansion see that as a grim trade. Fewer people covered, at lower cost. Conservatives can read the same facts differently: expansion under the 2025 rules is a narrower, work-linked program aimed at people who are working or trying to, closer to what Republican governors such as Georgia's Brian Kemp tried to build on their own.

Georgia is the clearest test. Rather than expand, Kemp created Georgia Pathways to Coverage in 2023, a limited program for low-income adults who report 80 hours a month of work or other qualifying activity. It helped inspire the national work rule. Pathways is now scheduled to expire at the end of this year unless it is renewed. The state asked federal officials in October to pay 90 percent of its costs, the same match given to full expansion states, even though Pathways covers adults only up to the poverty line. State officials have said that bringing Pathways in line with the more generous federal exemptions would add an estimated 100,000 people and about $1.4 billion in spending by mid-2028.

The Georgia Republican Party has already signalled where it will stand. Its post-election playbook says the party will "negotiate any wider coverage on Georgia terms: work requirements and private plans." Under the 2025 law, the first of those terms is no longer a concession Democrats can refuse. It is federal law.

The state senates still hold the keys

The second reason Republicans retain leverage is arithmetic. In Georgia, Democrats will control the governor's office and the state House, but Republicans still hold the state Senate, and a 2014 Georgia law requires legislative approval for expansion. Republican senators contacted after the election did not rule it out. "My answer is, 'I don't know,'" said Sen. Kay Kirkpatrick, a physician and member of the Republican Senate leadership. Sen. Russ Goodman, who has backed expansion before, said he was listening. "You can't commit to anything until you see it," he said.

Texas looks similar. Democrats swept the statewide offices and won the state House, but Republicans kept the state Senate. Texas law bars the state from changing Medicaid eligibility without legislative approval, and it is not clear whether Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa could direct state officials to file an expansion plan on her own. John Henderson, who leads the state's association of rural and community hospitals, was sceptical that Republican senators would change course. "There was an appetite in the House, but never enthusiasm in the Senate," he said.

In Kansas, Gov.-elect Cindy Holscher won a close race, but Republicans held both legislative chambers. Democrats did break the Republican supermajority in the state House, which advocates say gives them more room to restart talks. Her campaign did not answer questions about how she would get expansion past two Republican-led chambers.

Only Wisconsin will have Democrats in charge of the governor's office and both legislative chambers from January. Yet even there the momentum has slowed. Gov.-elect David Crowley embraced full expansion early in his campaign, later called for letting anyone buy into the state's partial expansion, and has since moved further away from full expansion. The state's hospital association estimates that full expansion could put hundreds of millions of federal dollars at risk because of the new provider tax limits. "These are going to be hard conversations," said Bobby Peterson, a Madison attorney who helps clients navigate benefit programs.

The Democratic gamble on Washington

Democrats know the rules are against them, which is why some are betting on Congress. They will control both chambers in January and have pledged to roll back the Medicaid cuts in the 2025 law, though they have not said how. Any repeal would still need the signature of a president who championed the law.

In Texas, that uncertainty has produced an unusual idea: a "trigger" bill that would switch on expansion only if Congress first repeals some of the costliest federal restrictions. State Rep. Donna Howard, an Austin Democrat, explained the logic. "We can't pass something that is going to not achieve our goals," she said.

Critics on the right can fairly ask whether that is a plan or a postponement. Brian Blase, president of the right-leaning Paragon Health Institute, warned that the uncertainty itself is a problem. "When states operate in an environment where they're uncertain about federal policy, that makes it harder for states to legislate," he said. Lawson Mansell, a health policy analyst at the free-market Niskanen Center, put it more simply: "It's a lot of complicated math."

There are real costs to waiting. Texas has the highest uninsured rate in the country, about 16 percent, and more than 5 million residents without coverage. No childless working-age adult in Texas can qualify for Medicaid today. Gov. Greg Abbott, who leaves office in January, long argued that "the best way to get health care insurance is through an employer," but only 38 percent of small employers in the state offer coverage, and the minimum wage there has been stuck at $7.25 for 17 years. More than 4 million Texans picked private marketplace plans for 2026, which opponents of expansion cite as proof that the private route works.

Expansion advocates also point to hospitals. "One of the positive benefits (of expansion) is improved operating margins for hospitals, because they have fewer uninsured patients, less uncompensated care," said Edwin Park of Georgetown University. But Park also warned that the new rules could leave people uninsured "just because of all these changes that essentially add more red tape."

What to watch

The first signal comes on December 11, when states must tell federal officials whether they will use the work rule grace period. The second is Georgia's request for a 90 percent match on Pathways, which would let a Republican-designed program survive on expansion-level money without full expansion. If federal officials approve it, the Kemp model becomes a template other holdouts could copy.

The third is the 2027 legislative sessions in Atlanta, Austin and Topeka, where Republican senators will decide whether to deal. Ryan Loke, a former Kemp health adviser who now backs full expansion, told advocates in Georgia he was "100% confident" the legislature would expand Medicaid in 2027. Then he added the warning: expansion under the 2025 law, compared with expansion without it, means "massively different scenarios."

That is the point Democrats celebrating their midterm wins would rather skip. They won the governor's offices. But the shape of any Medicaid deal in these states was set in Washington a year ago, by the party they just beat, and for now the Republicans who still hold the state senates have every reason to insist on it.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X