Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

The Senate Majority Is Settled. Its Size Is Not.

2026-11-08 · Washington Eye Team

The Old Senate Chamber in the United States Capitol, with rows of mahogany desks facing the crimson canopy of the presiding officer's dais (Architect of the Capitol / public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

Five days after Election Day, the United States Senate still has two races that no one has officially called. That fact is less dramatic than it sounds, and more important than a simple unfinished count. Democrats have already secured the chamber, with 54 seats to Republicans' 44 and those two contests outstanding. The remaining ballots in Mississippi and Alaska will not decide who organizes the Senate in January. They will decide only how wide that majority becomes, and under which rulebook each last seat is awarded.

In Mississippi, the unofficial tally reported as of Saturday showed Democrat Scott Colom, a district attorney, leading Republican Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith by 2,574 votes. Colom had 467,930 votes, or 49.1 percent. Hyde-Smith had 465,356 votes, or 48.8 percent. Independent candidate Ty Pinkins had 20,028 votes, or 2.1 percent. Roughly 97 percent of the expected vote had been counted. The lead is larger than it was on Wednesday night, when Colom's advantage stood at 1,138 votes with about 96 percent reporting, but it remains well inside the range that outstanding ballots could still move.

What is left is a set of known unknowns. On 4 November, Secretary of State Michael Watson said approximately 3,600 absentee-by-mail ballots were still outstanding and that an unknown number of affidavit ballots, Mississippi's term for provisional ballots, would be processed inside the ten-day window counties have to certify. Counties must submit certified results by 13 November. Mail ballots had to be postmarked by Election Day and must arrive within five business days, a deadline of 10 November. Voters who cast affidavit ballots because of identification or eligibility questions have until the same date to resolve those problems.

The review is slow because it is meant to be particular. Kidada Brown of the Hinds County Election Commission said each ballot has to be checked. "We have to go through each one to determine whether they are eligible for their ballot to be accepted or rejected," she said. "So we're just asking people to be patient with us. We're working hard." In DeSoto County, officials said they were reviewing more than 2,000 ballots, with many voters unlikely to learn whether those votes count until after certification.

Mississippi's law makes the close margin even more unusual. The state does not hold a runoff for the U.S. Senate: the candidate with the most votes wins even without a majority. It also has no formal recount procedure. The secretary of state's office has said candidates cannot request a recount and that none is triggered automatically, no matter how tight the result. A candidate may examine ballot boxes after certification and, if problems appear, file a legal challenge. Because challenges proceed county by county, any courtroom fight could scatter across courthouses rather than land in a single statewide proceeding.

Both campaigns are already preparing for that possibility. Hyde-Smith's campaign and national Republican Senate officials have asked officials in all 82 counties to set affidavit ballots aside and preserve them, the usual prelude to litigation. Colom's campaign has urged counties to refuse, arguing that pulling aside ballots already processed would itself violate state law. Mississippi Republican Party Chair Michael Hurst said the party had sent more than 50 volunteer lawyers and observers to counting sites and vowed to "fight like hell" to ensure the law was followed, while stressing that "there's no election denying going on here." Hyde-Smith was blunt. "We are not backing down. This election is not over," she said. "We will see this through to the very end." Colom answered in kind. "We got an army of lawyers," he said. "Those election commissioners and circuit clerks, they're not going to be intimidated."

A Colom victory would be historic in a state that rarely produces them. Mississippi has not elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1982. Colom would also become the state's first Black U.S. senator since Reconstruction: Hiram Revels and Blanche K. Bruce served in that era, and Bruce left office in 1881. Recent results run the other way. The state gave President Donald Trump 61 percent of the vote in 2024, and Hyde-Smith won her last full term with 54 percent in 2020. Trump campaigned with her last month. None of that history changes the arithmetic in front of county officials: a margin of a few thousand votes, thousands of ballots still under review, and a certification deadline measured in days rather than weeks.

Alaska is operating on a longer clock and a different math. The latest first-choice totals reported through Saturday showed former Democratic congresswoman Mary Peltola leading Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan 102,962 votes to 102,325, or 48.2 percent to 47.9 percent, a gap of 637 votes with about 74 percent of the expected vote counted. Neither candidate has crossed the 50 percent threshold that would end the race on first-choice votes alone. Republican Gerald Heikes had about 2.26 percent. A fourth candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a teacher from Petersburg who shares the incumbent's name, had about 3,600 votes. Another 695 voters made a write-in their first choice. Under Alaska's ranked-choice system, those trailing totals are the raw material of the next round.

The Division of Elections says ranked-choice results will not be available until 18 November, once all eligible ballots are reviewed and counted. Absentee ballots postmarked by Election Day can continue to arrive through that same date. An official table updated on 7 November at 11:38 a.m. Alaska time showed how much of the remote vote was still out: 29,607 of 42,437 ballots issued by mail had been received, and 3,486 of 8,060 ballots issued by online delivery had come in. Early votes, 70,274 of them, were already received in full. Not every outstanding ballot will be returned, but the gap is large enough to matter in a race decided by hundreds of first-choice votes.

If no one reaches a first-choice majority, Alaska eliminates the lowest-finishing candidates and transfers those voters' next usable rankings until a winner emerges. Both campaigns claim that process favors them. "The numbers are clear: when every vote is counted, Mary Peltola will be elected as Alaska's next United States Senator," Peltola's campaign manager, Cheryl Bruce, said. She argued that tens of thousands of outstanding early and absentee ballots "will break for Mary and extend her lead." A memo from the Sullivan campaign told reporters the opposite: "If the ranked choice voting tabulation took place today of the votes that we have in hand right now, Senator Dan Sullivan would defeat Mary Peltola." Peltola's team called that account "fictitious." Both claims are predictions about a tabulation that has not been run.

Hanging over those rankings is the other Sullivan. Officials listed the Petersburg candidate as "Sullivan, Daniel J. Jr." with no party affiliation, and the sitting senator as "Sullivan, Dan S. (Registered Republican) Incumbent." The Alaska Supreme Court declined to remove him, finding that the effort to keep him off the ballot rested on a "good-faith requirement" that does not exist in the federal Constitution, state statute or the division's regulations. "I am not interested in tricking voters," Peltola said at a campaign event, and her campaign said it "has no involvement with either Sullivan campaign." In a television interview the incumbent said, "I'm sure I'm going to lose a lot of votes to that trickery." He has also said he will accept the election results regardless of who wins the most votes.

The legal fight in Alaska began before anyone voted and should not be confused with the Mississippi disputes. The Justice Department sued in late October to stop the state from certifying the Senate result if the incumbent lost, arguing that the namesake candidacy risked diverting votes. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case on 1 November, two days before Election Day, finding that the department lacked standing and had offered no workable way to segregate ballots cast for Daniel J. Sullivan and then conduct an "unspecified investigation" of them while preserving voter secrecy. Late-breaking changes to election rules, she wrote, are "strongly disfavored." The department filed a notice of appeal the same day and said, "Alaskan voters deserve a fair election, not to be misled in an attempt to rig outcomes." A separate criminal inquiry has included subpoenas, and nobody in the race has been charged.

A newer case opened after the votes were cast. On 6 November, the principal group supporting Peltola sued the Division of Elections for the names of voters whose absentee ballots had so far been rejected, saying it wanted to keep supporters from being wrongly disenfranchised. The state refused, arguing that the records are preliminary, have long been kept confidential, and that releasing them now could slow the count. "The Division has protected this information for years and will ask the court to protect it too," the state Department of Law said. They are not the same case, and they do not travel to Mississippi.

For the Senate as an institution, the remaining uncertainty is about cushion, not control. If Democrats win both outstanding seats, they will have 56 seats and Republicans 44. If Republicans win both, Democrats will still have 54 seats and Republicans 46. A split produces 55 to 45. None of those outcomes hands the chamber back to Republicans. None of them reaches the 60 votes usually needed to break a filibuster. What they change is how much room Democratic leaders will have when senators are absent, when a colleague defects on a narrow bill, and when committee ratios are bargained at the start of the new Congress. A 54-seat majority is real. A 56-seat majority is more forgiving. That difference is worth counting carefully. It is not the same as deciding who holds the gavels.

Mississippi is working through affidavit and late-arriving mail ballots under a county-based system with no statewide recount statute and a certification deadline of 13 November. Alaska is waiting for absentee ballots that can arrive through 18 November, and for a ranked-choice tabulation that cannot run until those ballots are in. The country already knows which party will organize the Senate in January. It does not yet know whether Mississippi will send its first Black senator since Reconstruction or return Hyde-Smith, whether Alaska's rankings will deliver the seat to Peltola or to Sullivan, or whether Democrats will have two extra votes of margin when the next fight begins. Those questions are large enough. They cannot answer who won the Senate. That part is already settled. The size of the majority is not.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X