Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

The Teacher Diversity Crackdown Is Half Right

2026-11-18 · Washington Eye Team

Education Secretary Linda McMahon at her desk on her first day in office, 2025 (photo: U.S. Department of Education, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

Last Friday the federal Education Department's Office for Civil Rights opened a batch of investigations into programs that recruit and pay for future teachers. Four named targets sit at the centre: the City University of New York's NYC Men Teach programme, two diversity efforts at the University of Maryland's School of Education, a Minnesota tuition aid programme for teacher candidates, and two Minnesota scholarships for students from groups underrepresented among the state's teachers. Eleven more colleges, from the University of California campuses at Berkeley and Los Angeles to Seattle University and Westfield State, face separate probes over race or sex exclusive scholarships and programmes.

"Race, national origin, or sex should not decide who will shape America's next generation, yet many states and universities seem to prioritize recruiting and training 'minority' candidates rather than evaluating candidates based solely on merit," said Kimberly Richey, the assistant secretary for civil rights, when the department announced the probes on Monday.

The reaction split along the usual lines within hours. Advocates called it an attack on the teaching pipeline. Supporters called it overdue enforcement of the Civil Rights Act. Both camps are treating these programmes as if they were one thing. They are not, and that is the point the debate keeps missing. Our view is simple: the administration is right about some of these programmes, wrong about others, and it is choosing a blunt instrument when a sharper one would serve students far better.

Where the department has a case

Start with Minnesota, because it is the clearest. According to the department, the state's Aspiring Teachers of Color Scholarship pilot and its Underrepresented Student Teacher Grant "conditioned eligibility for receiving the awards on the applicant's race." The programmes' own descriptions say the money goes to students who "belong to racial or ethnic groups underrepresented in the Minnesota teacher workforce." Minnesota lawmakers created both in 2021. A spokesperson for the state's higher education office has said the scholarship pilot already ran out of funding after the 2024-25 academic year, while the grant continues under state law.

A public benefit handed out only to applicants of certain races is exactly the kind of practice that Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was written to forbid, whatever the good intentions behind it. The Supreme Court's 2023 decision in Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard ended race-conscious college admissions, and while that ruling was about admissions, its logic does not sit comfortably with a state check that depends on the colour of the recipient's skin. Defenders of these scholarships should be honest that a race gate on public money was always legally fragile, and that a careful lawyer in 2021 could have seen this day coming.

Nor is it unreasonable for Washington to ask questions about programmes that describe themselves in racial terms. Minnesota's Education Tuition Assistance Program, once known as Collaborative Urban and Greater Minnesota Educators of Color, says part of its mission is to "increase the number of teacher candidates of color and American Indian candidates." Whether that mission translates into who actually gets money is a fair question for investigators. Opening an inquiry is not a finding of guilt, and it should not be treated as one by either side.

Where it overreaches

Now look at NYC Men Teach. Its stated aim since it was launched around 2015 under then Mayor Bill de Blasio has been to add 1,000 male teachers of color to the city's pipeline. That goal is plainly race and sex conscious. But according to reporting on the programme's rules, its eligibility requirements do not limit applicants by race. The university says flatly that its programmes "are open to all students regardless of race, gender or national origin." A March 2026 evaluation prepared for the mayor's office by the research firm Westat found the effort contributed more than 3,100 new male teachers of color to the city's public schools between the 2015-16 and 2023-24 school years.

The University of Maryland's EdTerps CARES Network is similar. It recruits community college transfer students into teaching. Its website says it prioritises recruiting students "from racially and ethnically minoritized backgrounds," but that is not an eligibility requirement. The state grant it is tied to describes its purpose as helping "students from groups historically underrepresented in the teaching profession" meet certification requirements.

There is a real legal and moral difference between closing a door to some people and knocking on more doors. Telling a white applicant that a scholarship is not for him is discrimination. Sending recruiters to community colleges, high schools and neighbourhoods where few young men ever consider teaching, and then admitting whoever applies and qualifies, is outreach. If federal civil rights enforcement cannot tell those two apart, it will end up punishing the very kind of race neutral recruitment that critics of affirmative action have long said colleges should use instead.

The problem nobody is solving

The deeper trouble is that this fight is about symbols while the classroom problem is about numbers. Federal education statistics show that in the 2020-21 school year roughly 80 percent of public school teachers were white, about 6 percent were Black and about 9 percent were Hispanic. Districts across the country have struggled to fill posts. Representative Suzanne Bonamici of Oregon, who is seeking to chair the House education committee when Democrats take control of Congress in January, said Washington "should not be penalizing schools for bringing underrepresented populations into the teaching profession, particularly when there is a nationwide educator shortage." She also called the probes "another misuse of the already limited capacity of the Office for Civil Rights."

She has a point about capacity. The civil rights office has spent this administration chasing diversity programmes on a large scale. In 2025 it opened investigations into 45 colleges over their ties to the PhD Project, a nonprofit that helps business doctoral candidates from underrepresented backgrounds; by February this year 31 of those colleges had cut ties. The department also cancelled more than $600 million in teacher training grants in early 2025 that mentioned topics such as diversity, equity and inclusion or critical race theory. It admitted in a March court filing that it had cancelled 104 of 109 active grants in two major teacher programmes. A survey released in October found that at least 127 teacher candidates dropped out and another 259 accepted candidates never enrolled after those cuts.

Those are not abstract losses. They are people who wanted to teach and did not. Whatever one thinks of the grants' language, the administration has yet to explain what replaces the pipeline it dismantled.

The other side owes an honest answer too. Eric Duncan of EdTrust, an equity advocacy group, argued that the administration's "false divide between 'merit' and diversity" suggests "that teachers of color are less qualified or less deserving." Cheryl Holcomb-McCoy, who leads the American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education, said "decades of research confirm that a diverse educator workforce benefits all students." Fine. Then build programmes that reach those candidates without a race test at the door. Need based aid, first generation preferences, targeting high poverty schools and regions, paid residencies and loan forgiveness for hard to staff posts would draw heavily from the same communities. They would survive a lawsuit. And they would help a poor white student from a rural county, too, who is just as absent from many teacher pipelines.

What a smarter Washington would do

Most of these complaints came from one place. The Equal Protection Project, a group founded by Cornell law professor William Jacobson, says 12 of the 15 investigations grew out of its filings. "The opening of these investigations reflects OCR's determination that the allegations warrant further review," Jacobson said. Activist complaints are a legitimate way to trigger enforcement. But a civil rights office that lets one group's docket set its agenda risks becoming a referee that only watches one end of the pitch.

A better approach would sort cases by what programmes actually do. Where a state or college sets a race or sex gate on money, the department should say so plainly, require it to open eligibility, and resolve the case quickly, as several colleges did in the PhD Project probes. Where a programme only aims its outreach, the department should close the file and say why, so that every district in the country knows where the legal line sits. Clear guidance would do more for compliance than a parade of press releases.

States have homework as well. Minnesota's legislature should rewrite its grant around need and school shortage areas before a federal finding forces its hand. New York and Maryland should publish their eligibility rules and outcome data so the public can see for itself whether anyone is turned away. Openness is the best defence against a charge of discrimination.

And the incoming Democratic majority in Congress, which will have new oversight powers in January, should resist the temptation to turn this into another hearing room shouting match. If members believe a more diverse teaching force matters, the most useful thing they can do is fund race neutral recruitment at a scale that makes the old race specific scholarships unnecessary.

Children do not care about the ideology of the person who recruited their teacher. They care whether there is a qualified adult at the front of the room in September. On that measure, this round of investigations is half right. Ending race tests on public money is fair. Treating every effort to widen the pool as a civil rights violation is not, and it leaves the country's classrooms no closer to being staffed.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X