For most of Donald Trump's second term, confirming his judges has been the quietest assembly line in Washington. Senate Republicans have approved 57 of his nominees to the district and appeals courts, usually on party-line votes and usually without much drama. Now, with the clock running out on their majority, the line has started to jam, and the hands on the brake belong to Republicans.
The White House has made its goal plain. "We expect all judicial nominees pending in the Senate to be confirmed this year," an administration official said in a statement this weekend. There are 23 of them. Senate Majority Leader John Thune said last Monday that judicial confirmations were a top priority for the weeks Republicans have left in control, and Senator Kevin Cramer of North Dakota repeated the point in a television interview on Sunday, describing judges as the centrepiece of the party's lame-duck agenda.
Standing in the way are two senators who no longer have anything to lose. Thom Tillis of North Carolina is retiring. John Cornyn of Texas lost his primary to a challenger backed by Trump. Both sit on the Senate Judiciary Committee, where Republicans hold a narrow edge (Domenico cleared it 12 to 10 in July), and both have signalled that they are willing to withhold their votes from nominees that home-state Republican senators do not want. In a committee that splits along party lines, one Republican defection is enough to stall a nomination.
"That's not how it works here," Tillis told reporters on Thursday, describing a White House that had at times essentially told senators, "This is our guy, I hope you'll get on board." They should expect, he added, "they're going to get this response."
The first casualty came on Tuesday. The White House took the unusual step of withdrawing the nomination of Lee Rudofsky, a federal district judge in Arkansas, to the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, which sits in St. Louis. Arkansas's two Republican senators, John Boozman and Tom Cotton, had opposed him, and according to a wire service report, Cornyn and Tillis had privately told Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley that they would vote against Rudofsky in committee. Rudofsky, a first-term Trump appointee, is known for a ruling that weakened enforcement of a major voting rights law. The White House replaced him with J. Cody Hiland, a justice on the Arkansas Supreme Court and the candidate Boozman favoured. Hiland said in August that he had been offered a trial court nomination and had turned it down.
Tillis acknowledged he had backed the Arkansas senators' effort. Senators, he said, deserve more "respect" from the White House when judges are chosen for their states.
The second fight is in Oklahoma. Zach West, a lawyer in the state attorney general's office, has won praise from conservative legal activists for defending the state's abortion restrictions and supporting the participation of religious schools in Oklahoma's charter school programme. Senator Alan Armstrong, an Oklahoma Republican, first returned a favourable blue slip for West, then withdrew it. "We put up a lot of really qualified candidates that we sent to the White House, and they basically ignored that and just put through their one," Armstrong said. With Tillis backing Armstrong, West does not have the votes to clear the committee when it next meets to advance nominees on Tuesday.
"When I've got two Republicans from the state telling me to move on it, I move on it," Tillis said. "If I have one or more asking me not to, then I'm not."
The third is in Texas, and it is the most pointed. Trump has nominated T. Elliot Gaiser for a federal judgeship in Dallas. Gaiser, who comes from Ohio, was chosen without going through the screening process that Texas senators have traditionally run for the state's federal bench. He now leads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, the office that has issued opinions endorsing some of the most contested parts of Trump's agenda. Cornyn has declined to commit to supporting him. Without Cornyn's blue slip, Gaiser cannot appear at the Judiciary Committee hearing scheduled for Wednesday.
The weapon at the centre of all this is old and modest: a blue form. Under Senate custom, the Judiciary Committee asks home-state senators to return a "blue slip" signalling their support for a nominee. For district court nominees, a missing slip usually means no hearing. For appeals court nominees, the custom has not applied for years, which is why the Eighth Circuit fight turned not on a slip but on committee votes.
That distinction is visible in the vote set for Monday evening. At 5:30 p.m. Eastern time, the Senate is scheduled to vote on confirming Daniel Domenico, the chief federal judge in Colorado, to the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver. Colorado's two Democratic senators, Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper, oppose him. Hickenlooper's office has cited Domenico's refusal at his June hearing to say who won the 2020 presidential election, as well as his immigration rulings. Bennet has pointed to Domenico's decision upholding detention without a bond hearing. But because blue slips do not reach the appeals courts, the Democrats cannot stop him. The Senate voted 51 to 27 on Thursday to end debate on his nomination, with every Republican who voted in favour and every Democrat who voted against. The same day the chamber also advanced Anna St. John, a nominee to the Fifth Circuit, and confirmed its first judge of the lame-duck session.
So the paradox of the moment is this: Democrats, about to take over the Senate, cannot block an appellate judge they oppose, while two departing Republicans can block district judges the White House wants.
The urgency is easy to explain. Democrats won control of both chambers in the 3 November midterms, and the current Congress ends on 3 January. Every nominee not confirmed by then goes back to the White House, and in the new year a Democratic Judiciary Committee will decide which, if any, get hearings. Lifetime appointments that would have taken an afternoon on the Senate floor in December could take years, or never happen at all.
The stakes are large. Trump made 234 judicial appointments in his first term, including three of the justices who make up the Supreme Court's current 6 to 3 conservative majority. Roughly one in three active federal judges is now a Trump appointee. For the conservative legal movement, the weeks before January are the last chance in this presidency to add to that number with a friendly Senate.
Rob Luther, a law professor at George Mason University who worked on judicial nominations in the White House Counsel's Office during Trump's first term, framed the problem bluntly: senators who are on "borrowed time," he argued, are standing in the way of "movement conservatives" being appointed to the bench.
There are two ways to see what Tillis and Cornyn are doing, and both have some truth in them.
The first reading is that this is personal. Tillis has a fractured relationship with Trump. Cornyn has just lost his seat to a Trump-backed opponent. Neither faces another primary. On this view, two senators with grievances have found a final moment of leverage and are using it, and the losers are nominees whose only offence was being picked by the president.
The second reading is institutional. The blue slip and the deference shown to home-state senators are among the few levers individual senators still hold over lifetime appointments in their own states. Tillis has framed his position in exactly those terms: he says he will move a nominee when both home-state Republicans want it, and not when one of them objects. In each of the three cases, the objection came first from a Republican senator from the state concerned, not from Tillis or Cornyn themselves. A president who routinely ignores the candidates those senators propose, the argument goes, is not just picking judges but shifting power from the Senate to the White House, and a future Democratic president could use the same precedent.
What the fight does not appear to be, at least so far, is a broad revolt. Tillis voted on Thursday to end debate on Domenico, and he signed the cloture motion that forced the vote. Most of the pending nominees face no organised Republican opposition. The resistance is narrow, aimed at specific seats where home-state senators feel bypassed.
Several dates will show how far the standoff goes. Monday's confirmation vote on Domenico is the clearest test of whether the floor machinery is still working. Tuesday's committee meeting will show whether West is pulled from the agenda or held over. Wednesday's hearing will show whether Gaiser stays off the list.
Oklahoma adds a twist. Armstrong leaves the Senate on 30 November and will be replaced by Senator-elect Kevin Hern, a Republican who could take a different view of West. If Hern returns a blue slip, Tillis's stated rule would no longer cover the objection. Tillis has said that, for now, he will keep blocking the nominee.
Then there is the larger arithmetic. With about seven weeks left before the new Congress, and floor time also needed for legislation such as the permitting reform bill now before the chamber, even an uncontested list of 23 nominees would be a heavy lift. Every nomination that stalls in committee is one more that Democrats, rather than Republicans, will decide in January.
For a party that has spent a decade treating judicial confirmations as its most reliable achievement, the final weeks of its Senate majority may end with a different lesson: the votes that matter most can belong to the senators with the least left to lose.
