Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Who Pays for the Coal Plant That Won't Retire?

2026-11-18 · Washington Eye Team

Energy Secretary Chris Wright speaking at the National Energy Technology Laboratory, June 2025 (photo: U.S. Department of Energy, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

The J.H. Campbell power plant on the shore of Lake Michigan was supposed to go dark on May 31, 2025. Its owner had a plan, state regulators had signed off, and replacement power had been lined up. Eighteen months later the 1,420 megawatt coal plant in West Olive, Michigan, is still being kept ready to run, and on Friday the federal government told it to stay that way through the winter.

The order, signed by Energy Secretary Chris Wright on November 13 and in force since Sunday, is the seventh 90 day emergency directive aimed at the same plant. It runs until February 12, 2027, which would stretch the plant's life more than 20 months past its planned retirement. What makes this one different is timing. It is the first Campbell order issued since a federal appeals court ruled in September that the very first one was unlawful.

So the question hanging over West Michigan is no longer only whether the plant should be running. It is who pays for it, and what an emergency power means when a court has already said there was no emergency to answer.

Seven orders, one plant

The legal tool is Section 202(c) of the Federal Power Act, a provision that lets the energy secretary order power plants to run when he finds an emergency caused by a sudden jump in demand or a shortage of generation or transmission. For most of its history it was used sparingly and briefly, for blackouts, storms and wartime strains on the grid.

The current administration has used it differently. In May 2025, eight days before Campbell was due to close, the Energy Department ordered it kept available. Every 90 days since, a new order has followed. The department's own list of 2026 orders shows the same approach applied elsewhere: Unit 1 at the Craig Station in Colorado is under an order running through December 25, Unit 2 at the F.B. Culley station in Indiana received one in September, and several shorter orders have let grid operators in the Carolinas and the mid Atlantic call on backup generation during tight days.

The department frames all of this as protection against blackouts. "President Trump and the Energy Department remain committed to doing everything in our power to stop power outages for American families and businesses," Wright said in announcing the latest order. "Ensuring coal plants such as the Campbell Plant are available to operate has prevented blackouts and likely saved lives."

The department says the plant was being shut "15 years before the end of its scheduled design life," that more than 17 gigawatts of coal generation were saved from going offline in 2025, and that a joint report by federal grid regulators on last winter's Arctic cold, including Winter Storm Fern, showed the need for dispatchable plants like Campbell.

What the court actually said

On September 11 a unanimous three judge panel of the federal appeals court in Washington disagreed, at least about the first order. Writing for the panel, Judge Cornelia Pillard called the emergency provision "essentially a narrow, last-resort backstop."

The court held that a Section 202(c) emergency means "a grid reliability risk that calls for an immediate response by DOE in particular," not a long term worry about supply that states, utilities and regional grid operators are already planning around. The judges noted that the federal government had historically used the power "to address short-term crises, such as blackouts caused by war or extreme weather events, not as a substitute for the states' long-term reliability planning."

The panel was blunt about the stakes. The department's reading, it wrote, "would empower it to pick its preferred power sources in Michigan, or, presumably, any other state, and order them to operate" without regard to state planning rules. The court said it was "unpersuaded by DOE's sweeping conception of its 'emergency' authority" and vacated the order.

That ruling, however, addressed only an order that had already expired. The administration asked the full appeals court in late October to rehear the case, and that request is still pending. In the meantime the department has issued a fresh order resting on the same basic claim, that the shortage created by premature retirements is an emergency that "will continue in the near term." Legally, it is a separate order. Practically, opponents say, it is the same order with a new number.

"Here we go, again," Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel said on Tuesday, announcing a seventh request for rehearing. "In September, a federal court ruled DOE's first Campbell plant order was entirely illegal, and this seventh order makes no further effort to comply with the law." Her office has now filed six earlier rehearing requests with the department and six petitions for review in court.

Follow the money

The clearest numbers come from the plant's owner. In its latest quarterly filing, Consumers Energy reported $303 million in net costs through September 30 from running Campbell under the emergency orders, after counting $344 million it earned selling the plant's power into the regional market. That figure does not include the new winter order.

The utility did not ask for any of this, and it has been careful in public. "Consumers Energy will continue to follow the law and operate our Campbell plant in West Michigan," it said in a statement over the weekend. "Consistent with these emergency orders, we will work to ensure that everyone who benefits from power from the Campbell plant across the Midwest pays their fair share."

That last phrase is the heart of the fight. The order itself says rate recovery is available under federal law, and Consumers wants the bill spread across the northern and central zones of the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, the grid operator that runs the wholesale market for much of the middle of the country. The Environmental Defense Fund, which opposes the orders, says that would put ratepayers in 11 states on the hook: Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota and Wisconsin. How the cost is shared is still unsettled. According to the utility's filing, federal energy regulators told the grid operator to revise its cost sharing tariff and rejected its first attempt; a revised version filed in April was still pending.

For Michigan, the irony is sharp. State officials say retiring Campbell was expected to save ratepayers nearly $600 million. The Michigan League of Conservation Voters says the latest extension "will eat away at more than half" of the savings the closure was set to deliver by 2040. "Someone will be left holding the financial bag," said Howard Learner, who leads the Environmental Law and Policy Center, one of the groups challenging the orders. "DOE should just stop issuing these orders and stop the meter from running up costs."

The Environmental Defense Fund puts the wider tally at about $600 million in losses across six coal plants kept open past retirement since May 2025. It also says Campbell has released well over 1,000 tons of nitrogen oxides and more than 2,000 tons of sulfur dioxide while running under the orders, and that the administration has given some form of direct support to nearly half of the country's coal plants.

Is there an emergency?

The strongest case for keeping Campbell around is not about this winter. It is about the next few years. Electricity demand is climbing as data centers multiply, and federal reliability watchdogs have warned that the Midwest grid is tight. In April the North American Electric Reliability Corporation said that even if about 25 gigawatts of fast tracked new generation arrives on schedule, risk in the region would remain "elevated" in 2027 before falling to normal later in the decade. More than three quarters of those new projects are natural gas plants that face supply chain, pipeline and permitting hurdles. "Persistent headwinds continue to challenge timely development of new resources," said Jim Robb, the corporation's chief executive.

Supporters of the orders argue that shutting a working plant while new ones are still on the drawing board is a gamble, and that Winter Storm Fern showed what happens when the grid runs short in extreme cold. Washington, in this view, is buying insurance.

The grid operator's own forecast for this winter is less alarming. Its readiness assessment, released on October 28, found about 134.7 gigawatts of winter capacity offered against a projected peak of about 113.4 gigawatts, with 3.6 gigawatts of new capacity added for the season. "Our region enters this winter season with sufficient capacity to meet forecasted demand, but reliability is never something we take for granted," said Tim Aliff, its executive director of market operations, pointing to tighter reserve margins, steep evening ramps and the risk of large storms.

The plant's actual use also complicates the emergency story. A trade publication reported in June that Campbell had been running at a capacity factor of 46.1 percent, down from an average of nearly 66 percent in the same months of the previous four years. A plant that is needed in a genuine crisis, critics argue, would not be idling more than it used to.

What to watch

Three decisions will shape what happens next. The first is whether the full appeals court agrees to rehear the September ruling. If it declines, the administration could take the question to the Supreme Court, and the meaning of "emergency" in a decades old energy law would become a national test of how far a president can reach into state power planning.

The second is what the department does on February 12. Every previous deadline has produced a new order. An eighth would tell utilities across the country that a federal emergency can be renewed indefinitely, regardless of what courts say about its predecessors. That matters well beyond Michigan, since Colorado and Indiana plants are operating under the same authority.

The third is the bill. Federal regulators still have to decide how the costs are divided, and the answer will determine whether households in Minnesota and Missouri help pay for a plant they never planned to rely on. When a trade publication asked the department about the new order and what may happen next, it did not immediately respond.

For now, the plant on Lake Michigan stands as a working symbol of a broader argument about energy in America: whether keeping old coal plants alive is prudent insurance against a strained grid, or an expensive policy choice dressed up as a crisis. A federal court has already given its answer once. The Energy Department has given its own, seven times.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X