Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Whose Lawyer Is the State? The Debate Over Five New Democratic Attorneys General

2026-11-08 · Washington Eye Team

Texas State Capitol dome in Austin seen through trees (photo: Daderot, CC0 public domain dedication, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

The most important legal shift of last week's midterm elections may not have happened in Washington at all. In Texas, Ohio, Georgia, Iowa and Kansas, voters handed the state attorney general's office to a Democrat, in several cases for the first time in decades. When the eleven newly elected attorneys general take office in January, Democrats will hold 29 of the offices and Republicans 22, according to a post-election assessment by a Washington law firm's state attorneys general practice. Texas, where the last Democrat to hold the job left in 1999, is the headline.

These are not ceremonial posts. A state attorney general decides which laws the state defends in court, which companies it investigates, which multistate lawsuits it joins and, increasingly, how far it cooperates with the federal government. Over the past decade Republican offices, led by Texas, turned that toolkit into the sharpest instrument of the conservative legal movement. The question now is what the new Democratic officeholders should do with the same instrument, and the two parties answer it very differently.

This piece sets out both cases fairly, then weighs them.

In Texas, State Senator Nathan Johnson, a Dallas commercial litigator, defeated State Senator Mayes Middleton by roughly seven points to succeed Ken Paxton, who gave up the office to run for the US Senate and lost. In Georgia, State Representative Tanya Miller, a former federal prosecutor, beat State Senator Brian Strickland by about eleven points; she will be the first woman to hold the office and the first Democrat since 2010. In Iowa, Nate Willems, a labour lawyer, unseated Brenna Bird by 51 per cent to 49. In Ohio, John Kulewicz, a lawyer at a Columbus firm for 44 years, defeated State Auditor Keith Faber and becomes the first Democrat in the office since 2011. In Kansas, Chris Mann, a former police officer and prosecutor, narrowly beat the incumbent, Kris Kobach, in a rematch of a 2022 race that Kobach had won by fewer than 16,000 votes.

The Republican Attorneys General Association did not dress up the result. "Last night was the worst election night for the Republican Party in 50 years," its executive director, Adam Piper, wrote in a memo to supporters the next day. The group said it had spent more than $40 million on the races, nearly double its 2022 outlay, and argued that its candidates ran on average about 4.6 points ahead of Republican Senate candidates on the same ballots. Outperformance, the memo conceded, could not make up for the scale of the defeat.

The stakes are concrete. A wire service tally of pending cases published on Sunday lists what the new officeholders inherit. Texas is a plaintiff in the long-running challenge to the Food and Drug Administration's approval of the abortion pill mifepristone; if it withdraws, Florida would be left as the remaining plaintiff. Kansas is a party to a separate challenge to rules that widened access to the pill. Texas has sued out-of-state providers who prescribe it remotely, is pursuing the maker of Tylenol over claimed links between acetaminophen in pregnancy and autism, which medical groups say lack firm scientific support, and has accused Pfizer of misrepresenting its Covid-19 vaccine. Texas and Kansas are among 13 Republican-led states suing large asset managers, including BlackRock, over climate investing. The new Texas attorney general will also decide how hard to defend SB4, the state law allowing arrests for illegal border crossings, and a 2025 law requiring the Ten Commandments in public classrooms, which families have asked the Supreme Court to strike down.

Elsewhere, Georgia's new attorney general will defend, or not, the state's six-week abortion ban. A federal judge in Atlanta has already paused a dispute over Georgia's congressional maps, citing "impending changes" in the leadership of the attorney general's office. Iowa has asked the Supreme Court to revive a state law allowing officials to arrest people who are in the country illegally; its incoming attorney general could decline to defend it if the justices take the case.

First, the case for a change of direction. Supporters of the new attorneys general start from a simple claim: the job is to represent the people of the state, not a national political project. Johnson made the point bluntly in an interview with a wire service. "The Texas AG's office has been operating as the private law firm of the MAGA movement," he said. "No more." He has described his first priority as ending the use of the office as a publicly funded law firm for one faction and rebuilding a staff depleted by heavy turnover.

On this view, the old model came at a cost to ordinary work. Mann, in Kansas, ran under the slogan "not Team Red or Team Blue, but Team Kansas" and criticised Kobach for spending state resources on culture war litigation instead of supporting local prosecutors. "I want to refocus it away from political agendas," he said after the election. Kulewicz in Ohio said he would have "far less interest in taking part in culture war cases around the nation." Willems in Iowa has pledged to focus on problems directly affecting Iowans. Their agendas lean heavily on consumer protection, scams, antitrust, utility prices and wage theft, the kind of cases that rarely make national news but touch household budgets.

The argument also has a constitutional strand. Defenders of the new offices note that state attorneys general are one of the few checks on federal power that do not depend on who controls Washington. With the Justice Department losing senior officials and a White House that has signalled it will give little ground to a Democratic Congress, a Texas office willing to question federal immigration partnerships or health policy under Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is, in their eyes, federalism working as designed. "The Texas attorney general office was never conceived to be an extension of federal immigration enforcement," Johnson said. Many of the lawsuits under review, they add, rest on contested science, such as the acetaminophen case, and a new officeholder has every right to ask whether they serve the state.

Now the case for caution. Conservatives answer that this is a familiar move dressed in neutral language. The Republican offices that sued the Biden administration more than 100 times from Texas alone were, in their view, doing exactly what Democratic offices in California and New York did to the first Trump administration: using the courts to defend state interests against federal overreach. "The Republican state AG offices are the tip of the spear of the conservative legal movement," said Mike Davis, an influential conservative lawyer. "Losing these offices is a major setback for key conservative causes." If multistate litigation was legitimate when Democrats did it, critics say, a pledge to end "political" litigation is really a pledge to change which side is sued.

The sharper objection concerns duly enacted state laws. Texas voters elected Johnson, but they also elected the legislators who passed SB4, the abortion ban and the Ten Commandments law. An attorney general who declines to defend those statutes, critics argue, effectively vetoes laws through litigation strategy, a power no voter granted. The Supreme Court has already confronted a version of this conflict. In 2022, in Berger v. North Carolina State Conference of the NAACP, it ruled 8 to 1 that North Carolina's Republican legislative leaders could intervene to defend a voter identification law that they believed the state's Democratic attorney general was not defending adequately. Republicans in the flipped states can be expected to look hard at that precedent.

There is also a question of mandate. A law firm advising companies on the results observed that the flips came largely from straight-ticket voting and strong coattails from Senate races, with very little ticket splitting. The Republican association's own figures show its candidates outran the top of the ticket. Read that way, voters in these five states were rejecting the national Republican Party in a wave year, not endorsing a reversal of every case their previous attorneys general had brought. Conservatives warn of a longer game too. Some allies of the administration fear that if Democrats win the presidency in 2028 while holding these offices, Republicans will lose the state tools they have used to block policies they regard as overreach.

Republicans are already regrouping around what they still hold. Florida's attorney general, James Uthmeier, who won a new term, said in a statement that his office "has been leading these fights since the day I took office, and we're going to keep leading them," and in a television interview cast himself as a last line of defence. The association's memo struck the same note, describing Republican attorneys general as "America's front line" against a Democratic Congress on issues from court expansion to immigration enforcement. But the Florida office is roughly a third the size of the Texas department, which the association once hailed as the party's "armory of legal talent."

Weighing the two, both sides are partly right, and the useful distinction is between cases and conduct. There is nothing improper about a new attorney general reviewing a predecessor's docket. Elections are supposed to change priorities, and dropping a weak case on contested science, or declining to join a national coalition, is ordinary discretion. Johnson's own phrase, "Everything will be examined," is a promise of review, not a promise of reversal, and Miller in Georgia has said she would join Democratic multistate suits potentially but not reflexively, depending on whether doing so helps Georgians.

Refusing to defend a statute the legislature passed is a different matter. That is where the conservative objection carries most weight, and where courts and legislatures are likely to push back, as Berger shows. The new attorneys general will strengthen their own case if they explain such decisions openly, in writing, on legal grounds, and leave room for other state officials to step in where state law allows.

The Democratic argument about the ordinary work of the office also deserves a fair test. If the next two years bring more scam recoveries, utility rate interventions and antitrust cases in Austin, Atlanta, Columbus, Des Moines and Topeka, the claim that the old model crowded out practical law enforcement will look persuasive. If instead the five offices simply become mirror images of the Paxton era, filing national suits against a Republican administration as often as their predecessors filed against a Democratic one, the conservative charge of hypocrisy will stick.

The early signals are mixed and modest. Mann's priorities read like a prosecutor's, Willems has promised to stay close to home, and Johnson has put rebuilding his office ahead of any lawsuit. What to watch first is the mifepristone litigation, where a single withdrawal could reshape the case, and any decision on SB4 in Texas. Those choices, more than any campaign slogan, will show whether the new class wants to be the state's lawyer or simply the other party's.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X