Washington Eye

Washington. America. The world.

Why 1,800 Venezuelans Could Be Freed by Friday

2026-11-19 · Washington Eye Team

The front of the United States Supreme Court Building at dusk (photo: Noclip at English Wikipedia, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons), edited for Washington Eye cover
WhatsAppX

The fight over legal protection for Venezuelans in the United States is back at the Supreme Court for a third time, and this round comes with a clock. On Wednesday afternoon in Washington, the Trump administration filed an emergency application asking the justices to block a September 2025 ruling by US District Judge Edward Chen in San Francisco that set aside the government's decision to end Temporary Protected Status for Venezuelans. Unless a court acts first, that long-dormant order takes effect on Friday, November 20.

Solicitor General D. John Sauer told the justices that the order would "spring into effect, inflicting severe and immediate harm." He warned that the government "could be forced to immediately release into the country some 1800 or so Venezuelan aliens from detention." Lawyers for the Venezuelan TPS holders say the opposite harm is the real one: hundreds of thousands of people who lost the right to live and work in the country after a decision a federal judge found unlawful.

Here is what the case is about, how it got here, and what could happen in the next few days.

What is Temporary Protected Status?

TPS is a humanitarian program Congress created in 1990. It lets the Secretary of Homeland Security, after consulting other agencies, designate a country whose nationals cannot safely go home because of armed conflict, a natural disaster or other "extraordinary and temporary conditions." People from a designated country who are already in the United States can apply. While the designation lasts, they cannot be deported or detained on the basis of their immigration status alone, and they can get permission to work.

The protection is temporary by design. Designations run for set periods and must be reviewed. That built-in impermanence is at the heart of the legal fight: the statute gives the secretary wide discretion, and it contains a clause that bars "judicial review of any determination" with respect to the designation, termination or extension of a designation.

How did Venezuelans get TPS, and how did they lose it?

Then Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas designated Venezuela for TPS in March 2021, citing a severe political and economic crisis. He redesignated the country in October 2023. On January 17, 2025, the last Friday of the Biden administration, he published an 18-month extension of the 2023 designation that would have run until October 2, 2026.

Within weeks, his successor, Kristi Noem, reversed course. She first vacated the extension, calling its basis "thin and inadequately developed," and then announced on February 1, 2025, that she was terminating the 2023 designation. She concluded that letting the group remain was contrary to the national interest, pointing to strained city shelters and police stations, a possible "magnet effect" drawing more migrants, and public safety concerns. The termination took effect in April 2025. She later ended the older 2021 designation as well, effective November 7, 2025. That second termination has not been challenged in this case.

Why did a judge block the termination?

A group of TPS holders and an organisation called the National TPS Alliance sued in February 2025. Judge Chen first postponed the termination in March 2025. He found the plaintiffs were likely to win on the argument that the decision was arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act, and he also found it was likely motivated by racial animus, in violation of the Constitution.

In September 2025 he went further and granted summary judgment, setting aside both the vacatur and the termination. He ruled that Noem had failed to engage in "meaningful consultation" with other agencies and had failed to conduct "a meaningful country conditions review." Notably, the final judgment rested only on the statutory claims, not on the constitutional race claim, which the plaintiffs had not asked him to decide at that stage.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with him. In January 2026 a panel affirmed his judgment, holding that the TPS statute's review bar did not stop courts from hearing the challenge. The full appeals court declined to rehear the case in March, over a dissent by Judge Bumatay, joined by eight colleagues, and another by Judge Nelson.

If the lower courts ruled against the government, why did Venezuelans lose their status anyway?

Because the Supreme Court twice put the lower court orders on hold. In May 2025 it stayed Judge Chen's postponement order, with only one justice noting a dissent. In October 2025 it stayed his final judgment too, explaining in a short order that "although the posture of the case has changed, the parties' legal arguments and relative harms generally have not."

Those stays meant the termination stayed in force while the litigation continued. The government says that during what it calls a "nineteen-month hiatus," the Department of Homeland Security ended work permits, placed people in removal proceedings, won deportation orders and detained thousands of Venezuelans. Lawyers for the TPS holders have criticised those rulings as "unexplained 'shadow docket' orders."

What changed in June?

The Supreme Court decided a related case about Haitian and Syrian TPS holders, Mullin v. Doe. By a 6-3 vote, in an opinion by Justice Samuel Alito, it held that the TPS statute's language barring review "is clear, and its plain meaning is very broad." Courts, the majority said, cannot hear non-constitutional challenges to the secretary's decision to end a country's designation. Justice Elena Kagan, joined by Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson, dissented. She argued for a narrower reading that would let judges check the procedural steps the secretary must take before deciding.

On October 5, 2026, the Supreme Court applied that ruling to the Venezuela case. It granted the government's petition, wiped out the Ninth Circuit's January decision and sent the case back for another look in light of Doe. That sounds like a clean win for the administration, but it created a gap. The court's earlier stay was tied to the petition it had just resolved, so the stay would lapse once the court's judgment formally issued on November 6.

So why is the deadline Friday and not November 6?

The administration asked the Ninth Circuit to keep Judge Chen's order frozen while the appeals court reconsidered the case. On October 30 the panel denied that request. Four days later, on November 3, the same panel withdrew that denial and granted a 14-day administrative stay, starting on November 6, while it ordered expedited briefing on what Doe means for this case. Fourteen days from November 6 lands on Friday, November 20.

The government says the appeals court has been silent since then. Mr. Sauer called the Ninth Circuit's handling of the case "inexplicable" and accused it of "gamesmanship." The plaintiffs, for their part, celebrated the October 30 order as a ruling that cleared the way to restore protection for "hundreds of thousands" of Venezuelans.

What is the government arguing now?

Its main point is simple. The case is a non-constitutional challenge to a TPS termination, and Doe says courts cannot hear those. The application calls the government's success "certain" and describes the request as "a remarkable third trip to this Court in the same case."

It also lists concrete harms if the order takes effect even briefly. Beyond the roughly 1,800 people it says might have to be released from detention, the filing says reviving TPS would block the government from carrying out up to 332 final orders of removal and would force it to issue work authorization to large numbers of people, only to revoke it again if it later wins. It argues that because it could not rely on ankle monitors, released detainees would have "an overwhelming incentive to flee" before the justices rule.

And what do the Venezuelan TPS holders argue?

Their lawyers say the case is not simply a challenge to the termination itself. According to the government's description of their filings in the appeals court, they argue that courts can still review Noem's separate decision to vacate the Mayorkas extension, and that if the vacatur was unlawful, the termination took effect on the wrong date. In their public statements they have also framed the case as one about checks and balances.

"The Trump administration bears substantial responsibility for the untold horrors that Venezuelan refugees have suffered over the last 18 months," said Ahilan Arulanantham, a law professor who argued for the plaintiffs, after the October 30 order. He said the government's conduct "has only been possible because of the Supreme Court's unexplained 'shadow docket' orders" and urged the justices to leave the district court's decision "undisturbed."

The government's answer to the vacatur theory is that it no longer matters. Even if the extension had never been cancelled, the filing argues, it would have expired on October 2, 2026, so the 2023 designation would be over either way. It adds that the harms the TPS holders describe, including family separation and job loss, are the same ones the justices already weighed twice and found wanting.

Who decides, and how fast?

Emergency applications from the Ninth Circuit go first to the justice assigned to that circuit, and this one was submitted to Justice Kagan, who wrote the dissent in Doe. Any single justice can grant a short administrative stay to freeze things while the court considers the request, though circuit justices often refer contested applications to the full court. The government asked for exactly that kind of immediate pause. As of Wednesday evening in Washington, the docket showed only the filing itself.

There are three realistic outcomes. The court could issue a brief administrative stay before Friday and then rule on the full request later. It could grant a full stay, keeping the termination in force while the Ninth Circuit works through the Doe question. Or it could do nothing by Friday, in which case Judge Chen's 2025 order would take effect and DHS would, by the government's own account, have to treat the 2023 designation as alive again.

Why does this matter beyond Venezuela?

TPS has become one of the sharpest tests of how far courts can police immigration decisions. Doe narrowed that role considerably, and the Venezuela case is the first big test of how lower courts apply it. If the justices step in again, it will confirm that the administration has wide room to wind down humanitarian protections for other countries with little judicial interference. If they decline, it would signal that challengers still have some openings, at least on procedural side questions like the vacatur.

There is also a practical lesson about emergency orders. For 19 months, the legal status of a large community has turned on short, largely unexplained stays rather than full rulings on the merits. Supporters of the administration say that is what the statute's plain text demands. Critics say it leaves people's lives hanging on orders that are hard to predict. Either way, by the end of this week, Venezuelans with pending TPS cases should know which way the wind is blowing, at least for now.

Write to the editor with letters, corrections or story tips.

Follow @WashingtonEYE_ on X